Greatest Idea VIII - Game Over

[Shadowlesscloud]

Setup A:
Bulletproof Alien Lover
Compulsive Childkiller
Mafia One-Shot Dayvig

Setup B:
Jailkeeper
Watchlisted Townie
Wereparrot

Choices:
A
Mafia alignment
Bulletproof lover ability
threw out compulsive child killer

B
USed Jailkeeper as alignment
Had Wereparrot as role cause it looked fun
Threw out watchlisted Townie

[Vedith]

Why not? It's unique roles and proves that I always like to pick town like I said last game.

[davesaz]

Setup A:
Werewolf Cop (alignment)
Bulletproof Townie (role)
Alien Prober (discard)

Setup B:
Mafia Fruit Vendor (role)
Vanilla Townie (discard)
Werewolf Supersaint (alignment)

Setup C:
Town unique role that I'd rather not say yet...
Alien Mass Redirector (discard)
Doctor (alignment)

[Wisdom]

doctor sounds pretty safe too

please do claim your ability card

[pinturicchio]

Ok I want to be popular:

Setup A:
Vanilla Townie - alignment
Vanilla Townie - discard
One-Shot Paranoid Gun Owner - ability

Setup B: (at first I chose Werewolf bulletproof lover but Micc told me that's illegal)
Bulletproof Alien Lover - ability
Werewolf - discard
FBI Agent - alignment

Setup C:
Compulsive Childkiller - alignment
Guess - ability
Alien Silencer - discard

[Wisdom]

Compulsive Childkiller - alignment

CC. Thats mine.

VOTE: pint

[Shadowlesscloud]

What

Why was WW bp lover illegal but mafia one legal?

[Shadowlesscloud]

Compulsive Childkiller - alignment

CC. Thats mine.

VOTE: pint

Oh? Whats this?

[Vedith]

VOTE: Pintu

\o/

[pinturicchio]

Great! My ability is Mason Doctor, I think there are posts that Alch and A50 that confirm that. I hinted it when I said scumreading Wisdom wasn't my own read; A50 was scumreading JunkoChan because of the replacement and Alch thought that Junko had enough scum equity without the replacement itself.

I protected A50 at D1 so one of the scumteams had a stronman shot, or I was roleblocked/Jailkept by someone, probably Chemist. At night 2 I protected Irrelephant and that could explain the lack of one of the nightkills.

Kevin Costner, I want you to protect me tonight.

VOTE: Wisdom

[Micc]

From the Bodyguard Wiki:
"yaddah yaddah Doctor+Bodyguard can lead to circular protections yaddah yaddah"

Micc, could you confirm this is how it works here?

Sorry, it's not clear to me what you want me to confirm and/or explain. Please be more specific.

Votecount 3.02

pinturicchio (2) -

Wisdom, Vedith

NotMySpamAccount (1) -

Shadowlesscloud

Wisdom (1) -

pinturicchio

Not Voting (8) -

TTTT, ofrhz, davesaz, NotMySpamAccount, DoubtingThomas, Gamma Emerald, Trekkie99, Irrelephant11

With 12 players alive it takes 7 votes to lynch.

The deadline for Day 3 is in (expired on 2019-04-08 11:30:00).

[Vedith]

Can't mason be not town? Just can't be Mafia?

[Vedith]

That was the thing last game right?

[pinturicchio]

From the Bodyguard Wiki:
"yaddah yaddah Doctor+Bodyguard can lead to circular protections yaddah yaddah"

Micc, could you confirm this is how it works here?

Sorry, it's not clear to me what you want me to confirm and/or explain. Please be more specific.

Now that I claimed...

If I protect a bodyguard and the bodyguard protects me, are we immune to nightkills? Or at least at one directed nightkill?

[Vedith]

Who did you protect, Pintu?

[Irrelephant11]

Wisdom what’s the rest of your claim? Did I miss it?

[pinturicchio]

Can't mason be not town? Just can't be Mafia?

Yes, I could be a Werewolf or an Alien I think. But as I said before this game started, I wanted to be a 3p and I had no chance in any of the setups

I had no choice in this setup actually. I didn't want to be an Alien, Compulsive Childkiller is antitown and Mason Doctor was better than Silencer. I'm saying this 'cause Alch and A50 thought that Gamma could be scum because of discarding the Mason Lover card, but I told them that she could think that Mason is not a really cool role. I don't think being a Mason is a cool role either, for example. But I got to be Masons with Alch and A50 and we all townread each other.

[pinturicchio]

Who did you protect, Pintu?

Great! My ability is Mason Doctor, I think there are posts that Alch and A50 that confirm that. I hinted it when I said scumreading Wisdom wasn't my own read; A50 was scumreading JunkoChan because of the replacement and Alch thought that Junko had enough scum equity without the replacement itself.

I protected A50 at D1 so one of the scumteams had a strongman shot, or I was roleblocked/Jailkept by someone, probably Chemist. At night 2 I protected Irrelephant and that could explain the lack of one of the nightkills.

Kevin Costner, I want you to protect me tonight.

VOTE: Wisdom

[Vedith]

I don't ever see a world where Wisdom CC here with 4 potential night kills if lying.

[Micc]

If I protect a bodyguard and the bodyguard protects me, are we immune to nightkills? Or at least at one directed nightkill?

If a Doctor and a Bodyguard protect each other and the Doctor is targeted with a nightkill, then the Bodyguard would die.
If a Doctor and a Bodyguard protect each other and the Bodyguard is targeted with a nightkill, then neither would die.

[Wisdom]

Wisdom what’s the rest of your claim? Did I miss it?

no, havent claimed it

my ability is another unique so im waiting until after dave and dt at the very least claim

[pinturicchio]

If I protect a bodyguard and the bodyguard protects me, are we immune to nightkills? Or at least at one directed nightkill?

If a Doctor and a Bodyguard protect each other and the Doctor is targeted with a nightkill, then the Bodyguard would die.
If a Doctor and a Bodyguard protect each other and the Bodyguard is targeted with a nightkill, then neither would die.

Thanks! There goes my plan to run into the woods with Kevin Costner

[Irrelephant11]

I don't ever see a world where Wisdom CC here with 4 potential night kills if lying.

This is a good point
Though we have no idea how close scum might think they are to a win
Mafia might be close to equity maybe?
Come to think of it, cult recruits lose the ability to nightkill, right? Which could also explain fewer kills. A medium-to-large cult might feel confident about cc’ing here

But I agree Wisdom is more likely to be telling the truth here

[Shadowlesscloud]

If I protect a bodyguard and the bodyguard protects me, are we immune to nightkills? Or at least at one directed nightkill?

If a Doctor and a Bodyguard protect each other and the Doctor is targeted with a nightkill, then the Bodyguard would die.
If a Doctor and a Bodyguard protect each other and the Bodyguard is targeted with a nightkill, then neither would die.

Thanks! There goes my plan to run into the woods with Kevin Costner

What if another doctor protects the OG doctor? Does it still trigger the Bodyguard?

[Shadowlesscloud]

I don't ever see a world where Wisdom CC here with 4 potential night kills if lying.

This is a good point
Though we have no idea how close scum might think they are to a win
Mafia might be close to equity maybe?
Come to think of it, cult recruits lose the ability to nightkill, right? Which could also explain fewer kills. A medium-to-large cult might feel confident about cc’ing here

But I agree Wisdom is more likely to be telling the truth here

Do cultist know other cultist?