Fire on the Mountain [Over]

[Liger_Zero]

I was actually sort of thinking this too but I don't think Rei is very invested into the read and didn't think the jab meant much. Seems weak but I definitely was thinking along these lines

Who do you think scum is Liger
I have like -2 reads so far and a ping is a ping

Side note appreciate Eagle helping me get into this.
Idk if its towny but its making my life easier

Not sure yet. The thread will know when I have a strong scumread.

[MaxwellPuckett]

She has a cute avi and is very much aware of what's going on with the game. Plus her grapes vote was good

Being aware of the game isnt a towntell

Will check out the grapes vote tho.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

I was actually sort of thinking this too but I don't think Rei is very invested into the read and didn't think the jab meant much. Seems weak but I definitely was thinking along these lines

Who do you think scum is Liger
I have like -2 reads so far and a ping is a ping

Side note appreciate Eagle helping me get into this.
Idk if its towny but its making my life easier

Np

[Liger_Zero]

Players with random thoughts:

Vedith - Where is the thoughts? I don't see much here reading. Maybe scum staying at low level.
DrDoLittle - Seems genuine. Maybe cares too much about what people think of him. Not sure that means anything with that. I like his posts.
Reiuji - Ehhhhh. This person just seems like a sheep that goes along with the crowd. Can't tell where they are going mentally, seem disinterested in game.
Jingle - Snarky player. I like snarky players, very enjoyable to have some sparing matches with. Seems to be critical of the game, I don't see any manipulation going on, want to say town just on attitude but won't.
Alisae - Hyperactive posting would have this person on as a poster child. Or ADHD? I have hard time reading hyperactive posters because you can't really make heads of tails of a lot of their content when its muddled through a lot of random noise. Easier for scum to hide in it and just go with the flow of the game. Not sure I liked a few posts of theirs, but can't tell why.
Ankamius - Seems sheepish and trusts people too easily. Not sure if that means scum. Would scum make it that easy for people to trust them without trying to make it seem more like they are reading into them? Who knows. If town would probably be easy to manipulate given the personality seen so far.
Dannflor - Seems highly analtyical player from little I read. Not sure I could follow all his logic trees. Not sure what to make of him either since the harder it is for me to logically follow a player the harder it is for me to read them because I think they are spouting nonsense to make it look like they are trying or just in another world. Probably just need to get on his wavelength. Seems like cool person though.
Prince of Renais - Not sure. Think he is playing a different game than the rest of us with the postings I have seen.
mcqueen - Uhhhhh didn't know this person was playing till recently.
Xtoxm - Who?
NerfedBuj - Don't know who this be.
Max - Ehhh seems to be looking for reasons outside themselves for reads. Makes me suspicious either this person is easily influenced by others or just looking for reasons to make reads/adjustments based on others.
Eagle - On one hand he is very actively trying to push the game. The other is that he seems to be trying to pocket people very hard and cares deeply about others reads in a way that doesn't scream trying to get everyone on the same page but more how to get into the position he wants. So that makes me go with scum leaning right now, but theres townie things I can see from his ISO. Its just weird the progression of certain things.

[Liger_Zero]

I guess if i was making an arbitrary read list of least concerning to most concerning players i would go something like:

Jignle
DrDoLittle
Ankamius
Dannflor
Max
Reijui
Eagle
Vedith

And to those I hold no strong opinion of so can't say a thing:
Prince of Renais
mcqueen
xtoxm
nerfedBuj

[MaxwellPuckett]

How am I doing either of those things tho

Youre the one who agreed with my Rei thoughts not the other way around and Im asking others opinions to get into the gams best and also read them
If I had given a read in agreement to anyone I might agree but I havent done that once

[Liger_Zero]

Okay

[Extrapolated Eagle]

i care deeply about how ank reads me because i know, respect, and trust her in ways that i don't any other mafia player

also because the more i can share my thought process with her and get her to share hers with me the better i can read her

you'd be hard pressed to find me treating any other player like i treat ank

and taking the way i treat ank as a pattern of play throughout the game is a misrepresentation of my play

whatever. i've said enough.

[Reiuji Utsuho]

VOTE: Rei
So far its a vote on me (town)

So OMGUS.

and wanting to vote someone I think is town

(And, well, I don't feel it anymore either.)

and also a sort of lame jab abt me having a gutread on Ank in spite a not reading when Ank had a shitton of posts right when I came in

Where did this even come from?

You didn't read the game so I'll give you a bit of BoD.
You really should read the game though, at least first half of Day 2.

[Liger_Zero]

Reiuji how strong is your scumread on Max here? I am not getting that you have a strong one in the very least.

[Reiuji Utsuho]

I solve via PoE, so it is natural that I don't really "push" my scumreads, per se.
But I do get to answer "why are you scumreading me" with "others are townier than thou."

[Liger_Zero]

Ehhh PoE players....so hard to read cause I can't discern their scum cases are legitimate. You are the bane of my existence Reiuji. My mortal foe.

[Liger_Zero]

Why is Vedith townie to you?

[Reiuji Utsuho]

Eh not really at this point.

I'm very sure two scums are in this list and rest are town.

- DDL
- Vedith
- MP
- Thou

[Liger_Zero]

Eh not really at this point.

I'm very sure two scums are in this list and rest are town.

- DDL
- Vedith
- MP
- Thou

Who is Thou?

[Reiuji Utsuho]

You.

[Liger_Zero]

Ohh cool.

[Reiuji Utsuho]

Also, it's more that I'm waiting on people like you to catch up than being disinterested in the game to be honest.
I am forced to process garbage like this post when people do things without grasping at least the basic idea of the game.

VOTE: Rei
So far its a vote on me (town) and wanting to vote someone I think is town and also a sort of lame jab abt me having a gutread on Ank in spite a not reading when Ank had a shitton of posts right when I came in

[Reiuji Utsuho]

(And, well, I don't feel it anymore either.)

Why?

He reacted to my bickering decently enough.

[Liger_Zero]

Yeah, I am not going to read the rest of this game.

So you think that is garbage because more reading would help develop his read on you? Or just that your post wasn't a jab or what exactly? I think it was obvious that Ankamius had posted quited a bit after max replaced in so max could make some sort of read and your post could be perceived as a weird jab at someone who read a few posts to make a read. Do you not agree with that?

[Reiuji Utsuho]

Yeah, I am not going to read the rest of this game.

So you think that is garbage because more reading would help develop his read on you? Or just that your post wasn't a jab or what exactly? I think it was obvious that Ankamius had posted quited a bit after max replaced in so max could make some sort of read and your post could be perceived as a weird jab at someone who read a few posts to make a read. Do you not agree with that?

First of all, he voted me, the most obvious town in this game.

That whole post literally came off of exactly one post I made, and even then he didn't even read it correctly.

[Liger_Zero]

Yeah, I am not going to read the rest of this game.

So you think that is garbage because more reading would help develop his read on you? Or just that your post wasn't a jab or what exactly? I think it was obvious that Ankamius had posted quited a bit after max replaced in so max could make some sort of read and your post could be perceived as a weird jab at someone who read a few posts to make a read. Do you not agree with that?

First of all, he voted me, the most obvious town in this game.

That whole post literally came off of exactly one post I made, and even then he didn't even read it correctly.

I initially read it the same way he did. So we got an issue of either you communicated that wrong or everyone else doesn't understand you.

[Reiuji Utsuho]

And although he was (and still is) in the very bottom of my readlist even before his replace-in, and could've just call that post a blatant post, if he's actually doing something in this game (he is!) I want him to at least get some grasp of the game first.
Who knows, he might actually town up after he understands what's happening in the game and climb up my readlist.

[Reiuji Utsuho]

I was responding to this, actually.

I initially read it the same way he did. So we got an issue of either you communicated that wrong or everyone else doesn't understand you.

I was responding to this, actually.

Yup. I don't see anyone pushing a wagon. I see people pussyfooting around us. I see people pussyfooting around ClemSlot. I see shade at pretty much half the list. But I don't see any particular pushes.

[Reiuji Utsuho]

Welp, ignore the first "I was responding to this, actually."