Newbie 1924 - Game Over

[Voted]

Well was the text white or red?

Thats on whom? Also, asking newbies for things experienced players can easily fake? Thats not very nice of you.

Correction. You are checking the capability of reading sample PMs.

I didn't like the delay for you to just read the sample PMs.
Lucky you called me town.

I though it was on Salad, and the delay for checking sample PMs and my PM would be... similar.

[Vedith]

I mean your responses in between. You delayed it.
*waggles finger*

[Voted]

Well was the text white or red?

Thats on whom? Also, asking newbies for things experienced players can easily fake? Thats not very nice of you.

Correction. You are checking the capability of reading sample PMs.

I didn't like the delay for you to just read the sample PMs.
Lucky you called me town.

I though it was on Salad

, and the delay for checking sample PMs and my PM would be... similar.

[RCEnigma]

Worrying trends:
-Vedith is top poster
-Voted is 3rd too poster with little to no original content
-Navneet is mia after establishing a low post meta in his previous game (which Vedith hasn't questioned)
-Vedith is top poster.

[RCEnigma]

Ah the bit in parentheses is because Vedith replaced into the scumteam with navneet during that game and got his closest Town Ally to counterclaim against him.

Still reading through that game.

[TTTT]

@voted
what are your reads?
also how good/bad is 2200 elo?

2200 elo is Master tier elo where are usually only good player. The problem is that ToS is different than this. Day lasts cca 2 minutes; there are no vanilla towns. Everyone's role has an ability. I am good in finding people making fake claims and being able to claim fake roles (even as town) which are believable. I basically don't scum read in that game.

That being said, my scum reading abilities are in infinitesimal level and it is going to take my same time to scum read sameone here.

thanks for answering my dumb question
can you answer the good one now plz?

[Micc]

Votecount 1.04

RCEnigma (2) -

thenavneet, Vedith

Saladman27 (2) -

TTTT, Datisi

Voted (2) -

RCEnigmia, ClearlyClarity

ClearlyClarity (1) -

Miss Kobayashi Maru

Not Voting (2) -

Voted, Saladman27

With 9 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

The deadline for Day 1 is in (expired on 2019-04-11 12:10:00).

[ClearlyClarity]

I don't know why everyone scum reads me. In every game. Would love to know. Probably because of my inability to make constructive early in game and my strange sense of humour.

IMO, your reaction in 137 and

your eagerness to push a claim on D1

, three days into the topic, makes you seem kinda sus.

Could be just inexperience though. I've been there.

I still am there.

I am almost sure it doesn't, but if this vote hammers Saladman, just don't count it (if it is possible?).
I am aware of fact that I am joining a wagoon on him.
VOTE: Saladman

Putting Saladman in L-1

If you are a PR, would be nice if you tried to defend yourself before revealing.

*****************************************************************


I think it is obvious! He is a scum doing tactic - if I don't post anything, they can't find me scummy! He even haven't joined any vote wagoons!

Vegetables are neat
Inspiring little lad anxious Saladman is sad
Cause his votecount is three
And that is very bad

VOTE: RCEnigma No true buddy/friend would call their friendship a deal.

This is not a reason! We are already out of RVS! Do you have

any

kind of reads?

If you are unsure, start with me, my posts have usually slight scummy flavour (knowing from ToS) so it should be easier. I guess.

Don't want to make him claim. I just want to make him give ammo for scum readers.

So may I ask why you aren’t trying to play to wincon?

Your gambit to frame salad isn’t going to do anything if you announce what it is.

[TTTT]

VOTE: Voted

[Voted]

What wincon?
As I said, I am not framing Salad, there is no point in it. It would make me even more scummy. I just want to know if he behaves scummy or not - which I nor you can't find out from his posts so far.

I will try to do same reads today. But I am really bad in it.

[Voted]

What's wincon?*

Is there a way how to edit posts?

[Datisi]

That was more towards voted. I can't say I don't think you're scummy though. What do you think about the game salad? Do you think scum are voting you at the moment? Who do you think is town? Was the text in your role pm red?

UNVOTE: RCEnigma

You ask too many questions to be an informed scum, so I'm making unvote you for now.

Can't say this gives off Town vibes. Salad, would you care to change my opinion?

[Datisi]

What's wincon?*

Is there a way how to edit posts?

Correct me if I'm wrong, editing is not allowed, right?

[RCEnigma]

You canz edet by way of pos. By just correcting in a quote if you want, if you can't live with typos.

[RCEnigma]

You can edit by way of post. By just correcting in a quote if you want, if you can't live with typos.

Ebwop.

Also wincon is just your win condition: Lynch all baddies or outnumber the town.

[Voted]

Pushing silent people to post thing from which you can find out if he is likely to be scum or town is not helping town archieve its wincon?

[Datisi]

My guess is that she believed you were trying to frame him and push a lynch rather than make him talk. The former is scummy.

[thenavneet]

Hm that's a poor question, it's because my name looks like RC. Why are you content your rvs vote landed on scum? Is probably a better question.

At the time when I had posted that, I saw no real reason for any of the other 8 people to be scum so you had just as good a chance at being scum as anyone else.

Worrying trends:
-Vedith is top poster
-Voted is 3rd too poster with little to no original content
-Navneet is mia after establishing a low post meta in his previous game (which Vedith hasn't questioned)
-Vedith is top poster.

Just to clarify, you're saying my meta is that I don't post as often? Or did I state something about making reads based on people who don't post much. My posting frequency has directly to do with my availability at work and my motivation in the game as a whole and nothing to do with the color in my role PM.

Ah the bit in parentheses is because Vedith replaced into the scumteam with navneet during that game and got his closest Town Ally to counterclaim against him.

Still reading through that game.

That was a fun thing to read after getting back from a 5 hour flight.

[thenavneet]

UNVOTE: RCEnigma

You ask too many questions to be an informed scum, so I'm making unvote you for now.

VC seems a bit off. saladman unvoted here but the reasoning is paper thin. Any Experienced player and even a fair number of new players can ask enough questions to appear to be scum hunting. It doesn't make them unlikely scum.

I get mild SvS vibes from these two salad posts. Feels like RC coaching salad what to say here.

Vegetables are neat
Inspiring little lad anxious Saladman is sad
Cause his votecount is three
And that is very bad

VOTE: RCEnigma No true buddy/friend would call their friendship a deal.

If you were in my shoes do you think you would be reading your slot as town?

Nope, I have bad post ethic and even I can assume that is scummy.

[thenavneet]

People I wouldn't lynch as of now are TTTT and Vedith. TTTT because this gamestate is progressing at glacial pace and from what I've seen of him activity wise he makes his presence count. Vedith for entertainment factor because his presence will hopefully lead to me being more motivated to catch up more often. Pretty much anyone else is fair game.

[thenavneet]

People I wouldn't lynch as of now are TTTT and Vedith. TTTT because this gamestate is progressing at glacial pace and from what I've seen of him activity wise he makes his presence count. Vedith for entertainment factor because his presence will hopefully lead to me being more motivated to catch up more often. Pretty much anyone else is fair game.

EBWOP Add Datisi to the list of people I wouldn't lynch today. Succinct and to the point. I like her posts.

[Voted]

What's a noobscum intro look like?

I'll tell you later...

Is the time now? I guess we are far behind intro stage.

[Voted]

Tried to make same reads. Didn't went very well so I will post same observations here. Hopefully it helps.

People who are trying to scum hunt
-TTTT
-RCEnigma

People who made at least same kind of reads
-MKM
-themavneet

People contributing to scumunting conservation but slighty
-ClearlyClarity
-Vedith
-Voted

People who haven't posted anything of value
-Saladman


I have a feeling that TTTT is trying to push the converstion forward, moderate it. Probably most town like behaviour here.


Votes:

Voted

-TTTT
(end of RVS)
-Vedith
-RCEnigma
-ClearlyClarity (claimed to be random)
-TTTT

Saladman

-ClearlyClarity
-RCEnigma
-Voted
(end of RVS)
-TTTT
-Datisi
-Voted

Saladman and thenavneet never joined these wagoons. Clearly Clarity joined only as random voter.
Ignoring TTTT who is more or less trying to move conservation forward, I and Saladman have different non-random voters.

Based on votes:

Wild accustation:

me and Saladman have different alignment.

Even wilder accustation:

his potencial scumbuddy would be RCEnigma (salad's vote and unvote)

Don't take it that I am trying to frame Salad as much as I can. Just posting my reads.

[Voted]

That being said,

Saladman

, are you going to post scumhunting related posts or do you want me to push you into posting it?

[Datisi]

Can't help but notice you didn't include me in the first part of your message.