Newbie 1924 - Game Over

[Vedith]

You won't get reasons from me sadly. :<

[Voted]

Why?

[Vedith]

Because if I scum read someone I'm going to be biased on my reasons regardless.
It's a pointless thing unless I feel necessary.

[Voted]

20-35ish
but the number of pages are less important than the interactions
that we can go back and see later

if salad flips town where do we go from there?

If both, me and Salad are town (what I think is truth), than datisi and thenavneet have a huge problem for pushing against Salad (day 1 - lynch Salad, day 2 - lynch me, that would be a really nice start for scum). With pushing I don't mean making him post more, but making him sus, lynched.

[Voted]

I townlock TTTT.
I am doing it to pin out the fact that he is trying to direct the converstion in constructive way.

[Datisi]

20-35ish
but the number of pages are less important than the interactions
that we can go back and see later

if salad flips town where do we go from there?

If both, me and Salad are town (what I think is truth), than datisi and thenavneet have a huge problem for pushing against Salad (day 1 - lynch Salad, day 2 - lynch me, that would be a really nice start for scum). With pushing I don't mean making him post more, but making him sus, lynched.

Here's the thing, you cannot make someone post more. You can give a chance, ask questions, but ultimately it's their decision, and other players will react to those decisions.

If you don't think Salad is scum, who do you suspect?

[RCEnigma]

I townlock TTTT.
I am doing it to pin out the fact that he is trying to direct the converstion in constructive way.

In what ways? I think TTTT has a pretty weak iso tbh. I feel like he may just not be invested in this game tbh.

[RCEnigma]

Ok so there is now a mechanical reason TTTT and voted are not together that we can talk about tomorrow. Siri remind me.

[Voted]

20-35ish
but the number of pages are less important than the interactions
that we can go back and see later

if salad flips town where do we go from there?

If both, me and Salad are town (what I think is truth),

than datisi and thenavneet have a huge problem for pushing against Salad

(day 1 - lynch Salad, day 2 - lynch me, that would be a really nice start for scum). With pushing I don't mean making him post more, but making him sus, lynched.

[Datisi]

20-35ish
but the number of pages are less important than the interactions
that we can go back and see later

if salad flips town where do we go from there?

If both, me and Salad are town (what I think is truth),

than datisi and thenavneet have a huge problem for pushing against Salad

(day 1 - lynch Salad, day 2 - lynch me, that would be a really nice start for scum). With pushing I don't mean making him post more, but making him sus, lynched.

I wanted to take that as "you two could be suspected as scum" and not "i suspect you two as scum", but alrighty then.

[Datisi]

Because you can't know if Salad is scum or not. Unless you do?

[Voted]

Sigh. I have a feeling that if Salad were scum, he would be more agressive than he is now. He would defend himself more. With Salad failing as a substitutional lynch for me, I will have to find out sameone else.

So, VOTE: MKM, do you have same reads on sameone else than me or Salad?

[Voted]

About TTTT's ISO. Here is what I meant with he moderating the discussion.

@Voted
you are caught scum at this point
the only way I'm unvoting if you find someone scummier

-makes me defend and starts 1st wagoon.

UNVOTE:

I'm going to click on that little activity overview thing
and vote for whoever is least engaged in this game

-starts 2nd wagoon and makes us make Salad post more.

20-35ish
but the number of pages are less important than the interactions
that we can go back and see later
if salad flips town where do we go from there?

-tries to start a discussion to add pages which can be used to read people.

[Datisi]

Sigh. I have a feeling that if Salad were scum, he would be more agressive than he is now. He would defend himself more. With Salad failing as a substitutional lynch for me, I will have to find out sameone else.

So, VOTE: MKM, do you have same reads on sameone else than me or Salad?

Again, you can't

know

. Wasn't saying you can't suspect his alignment.

[Datisi]

Besides, if you're suspecting me and/or thenavneet, why vote for MKM?

[ClearlyClarity]

Out of the three on the wagon, from most scummy to least IMO:

Voted
Navneet
Salad

What makes you feel that Navneet is scummy?

It's less that I'm reading him as scummy than just being second in my order of progression. Little things like his defensive interaction with RCE and his play being similar to his scum games' meta. Scumlean.

I'm loathe to policy lynch salad just for being bad at scumreading/being lurky, etc, because I did just that in my only other game. It's different when you have had no prior mafia experience, which most other newbies on this site at least have had on different platforms. It's reasonable to lynch in any other setup, but this is a Newbie game, and the aim is to help newbies segue into the MS meta.

[ClearlyClarity]

I realize that my reasons for being against this lynch are personal rather than logical, but I just vibe heavily with newbtown!Salad rn.

[Voted]

Besides, if you're suspecting me and/or thenavneet, why vote for MKM?

To put same pressure on MKM and test her for being scum.

[ClearlyClarity]

About TTTT's ISO. Here is what I meant with he moderating the discussion.

@Voted
you are caught scum at this point
the only way I'm unvoting if you find someone scummier

-makes me defend and starts 1st wagoon.

Why do you think TTTT was genuinely trying to start a wagon on you on page 3, post 60, during the game's RVS, when you had only made 4 posts prior, none of which implicate you as scum?

UNVOTE:

I'm going to click on that little activity overview thing
and vote for whoever is least engaged in this game

-starts 2nd wagoon and makes us make Salad post more. [/quote]

So TTTT started two wagons and eventually settled on yours. Why do you think he changed his mind about Salad?

[ClearlyClarity]

Ok so there is now a mechanical reason TTTT and voted are not together that we can talk about tomorrow. Siri remind me.

!remindme 24hrs

I'd like to know this actually

[ClearlyClarity]

Just to clarify. Voted, you've been trying to get people to act scummy — even if they're town — so you can throw them to the wolves instead of yourself, correct?

[Vedith]

Ok so there is now a mechanical reason TTTT and voted are not together that we can talk about tomorrow. Siri remind me.

!remindme 24hrs

I'd like to know this actually

I think he meant day 2

[RCEnigma]

Yeah day 2, don't nk me please, it makes sense.

[RCEnigma]

I think everyone is scum except for CC and mkm, maybe datisi.

[Vedith]

I'm killing you tonight for that comment alone.