Newbie 1926: Baseball (Game Over)

[Ryno56]

*Has anyone

(Is there a way to edit posts?)

Even if you can edit posts in a forum, sitewide rules strictly prohibit this for players. Mods, of course, can edit as needed, like I did here. -brass

[the worst]

Nah, nobody has been inactive. And no there isn't a way to edit posts (even mods who have the ability are strongly encouraged not to).

My reads are going to weight themselves really really well when Lavender gets back and posts some more. If anyone hammers in the next ~48 hours they're scum 100%.

Lavender, please speak your mind. Don't doubt this. It's better to speak up and risk being wrong than stay quiet and never be right (+ you'll also be lynched every time).

[brassherald]

Votecount 1.04

Lavender (3)~

Godmid, Ryno56, Shoshin

godmid (2)~

the worst, u r a person 2

Shoshin (1) ~

whig

Not Voting (3)~

Lavender, Marcus325, Robotnick2

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.

Mod Notes

The day will end in (expired on 2019-04-22 05:45:00)
Whig and Robotnick2 have been prodded.

[Lavender]

Well I really want to ask why Ryno has any big evidence for voting me and such. But they seem very inclined not to give that information.
Godmid has stated why they have voted me, so I won't ask why they have voted me.
Shoshin seems to just testing my reaction, though I am unsure if that's the case.
Hey, Ryno, if you may, what are your reads at this moment?

[Ryno56]

Yeah this reply makes me definitely read you as scum, I'm ~80% confident now

[the worst]

I don't have a firm partner read and I'm a little worried ryno is bussing zzz

[Ryno56]

Isn't that a little too obvious? In any case, I'm happy if you lynch both of us. That way we get out a scum, which is huge.

[the worst]

The way you approached Lav was just so ott! Like I don't townread her either but I'm slightly worried we're just powerlynching a frozen noob tbqh. It just feels like you're so hardcore and remorseless.

Saying that Sho's push is hardcore as well. I think I'm just used to seeing her pushes.

[u r a person 2]

I do not understand the scum read on Lav. Please explain

[u r a person 2]

And the whole, seems like they want to be seen as helping isn't doing it for me so either flesh that out so i can see it or show me scum!lav some other way

[Ryno56]

Don't want to tell you atm. I doubt I can convince the group for to do a D1 lynch so it doesn't help to spill the beans. Just - see if you can read it yourself and let me know

[Marcus325]

What is wrong with telling us? If you want us to believe it you need a strong case not 'believe me because I say so'

[Ryno56]

Why should I tell you NOW? As opposed to later?

[Godmid]

@Ryno, earlier you criticized using reads to try and guide the lynch as well as saying that mafia can make themselves effectively unreadable by randomizing some of their responses. Do you think that you would have made those same comments regardless of your alignment?

[Ryno56]

If I thought I had a winning strategy for playing scum, I would use it and not advertise it

[the worst]

Why should I tell you NOW? As opposed to later?

Why tell us later?
Saying now and stimulating the gamestate seems ideal to me. if you're in GOTCHA mode you may as well spew it, look townie, and keep the conversation rolling
if you're trying to reaction test lav (sorry if you are & i'm calling it out rn) she's obviously a newbie and uncomfortable so the reaction is always going to reflect that unless she's extremely clumsily coached which isn't like A Thing Which Happens

so let's hear what's on your mind

[Ryno56]

What do you mean coached?

[the worst]

like if she's scum with an experienced player and the experienced player is like "hey you should react with ____" and they do, you can catch coaching

it doesn't actually happen like that tho

[Ryno56]

Nah I don't think they're being coached

[the worst]

ok so back to my point - why tell us later over telling us now?

[brassherald]

Chris Davis finally got a hit yesterday, ending his record breaking 0 for 54 streak.

Votecount 1.04

Lavender (3)~

Godmid, Ryno56, Shoshin

godmid (2)~

the worst, u r a person 2

Shoshin (1) ~

whig

Not Voting (3)~

Lavender, Marcus325, Robotnick2

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.

Mod Notes

The day will end in (expired on 2019-04-22 05:45:00)
Whig and Robotnick2 not picked up their prod and will be replaced.
Shoshin has been prodded.

[Ryno56]

I'm repeating myself over and over hahaha. I said, the moment I reveal the tell, the scum will all stop doing it

[Ryno56]

Concerned about the lack of chat going on

[brassherald]

DENMON replaces Robotnick2

[Shoshin]

Duck, what's your read on U2?