Newbie 1924 - Game Over

[Datisi]

At least 50%. Everybody would be at less, but it might be my indecisiveness and general newbiness speaking

[Datisi]

At least 50%. Everybody else* would be at less, but it might be my indecisiveness and general newbiness speaking

I need sleep

[MaryJoLisa]

Because I think we've got scum in our hands.

[TTTT]

it just seems unlike you to rush

[MaryJoLisa]

I give you Newbie 1915 day 2.

I favor 24-36 hour days.

[TTTT]

like what do you think of RCE pushing a Nav lynch as the counterwagon to Salad
but then jumping on that chance to lynch Salad
I even moved my vote to Nav

[MaryJoLisa]

like what do you think of RCE pushing a Nav lynch as the counterwagon to Salad
but then jumping on that chance to lynch Salad
I even moved my vote to Nav

I *think* RCE rolled scum this game. I'll read through it again, but my feeling was that the Nav wagon was a distraction to the saladman wagon, and he figured he could gain town cred for voting for Salad.

[TTTT]

I think if he's scum it's the opposite
and salad is a mislynch
I am not saying if salad is a mislynch then RCE is scum btw

[MaryJoLisa]

Can you flesh that out for me?

[TTTT]

still I don't think RCE would be a bad investigative tonight if salad is green
if salad is red maybe Clarity or Nav

[TTTT]

Can you flesh that out for me?

I dunno
just felt odd that he tried to build a counterwagon then jumped back on for that hammer

[TTTT]

MJL you never explained why you didn't read the spoilers before starting your game-read

[TTTT]

Town: ClearlyClarity is cautious, and voting with her gut. I think she’s taking stabs in the dark and scum!Clarity would stab with more precision. (unless she’s scum in which case her stabs in the dark are staged!)

Town: TTTT is conducting himself as his usual self and I see he’s putting out tests and feelers to try to indirectly get reads on people. Scum!TTTT would already know who’s who.

which of these two TRs ranks higher?
I'm assuming Clarity unless you say otherwise

[RCEnigma]

like what do you think of RCE pushing a Nav lynch as the counterwagon to Salad
but then jumping on that chance to lynch Salad
I even moved my vote to Nav

I think Nav is more likely scum. Both have scum equity but salad is going to be an extremely easy push for scum if he's town in a Mylo situation where it actually matters.

I'm confident I can make my town case tomorrow and TTTT's as well. In the event I go down I think TTTT can piece together the game with help. And the converse is true. As a matter of fact if salad flips green then I have the game solved.

[MaryJoLisa]

MJL you never explained why you didn't read the spoilers before starting your game-read

I think I did in post #550.

@MJL
why'd you decide to read and post thoughts without looking at the flips first?

I wanted to play the game. I got impatient, though.

ok
but why not click on the dead players spoiler in the opening post
to help guide your thinking as you review?
what is the benefit of going in blind when replacing in on day2?

I can do that after I do an uninformed read through and get authentic first impressions.

To clarify, I just wanted to read through the game and get a feel for everyone in the order I would have gotten if I'd been playing the game from the start. I wanted to see who I was jibing with. And also this is the first game I've replaced into where the slot has actually been played, so I'm embarking in new waters. It may take several different approaches before I find a method that fits me best. This was the method I chose for this game.

[RCEnigma]

TTTT should be townreading me for the same reasons I'm townreading him based on the gamestate day 1 and 2 but I think he's out gaming himself based on his perception of the setup.

Tomorrow we can massclaim and it should be pretty clear what's going on.

[TTTT]

I will say that if RCE is scum that last post was really good

[TTTT]

so I feel better already

[MaryJoLisa]

Town: ClearlyClarity is cautious, and voting with her gut. I think she’s taking stabs in the dark and scum!Clarity would stab with more precision. (unless she’s scum in which case her stabs in the dark are staged!)

Town: TTTT is conducting himself as his usual self and I see he’s putting out tests and feelers to try to indirectly get reads on people. Scum!TTTT would already know who’s who.

which of these two TRs ranks higher?
I'm assuming Clarity unless you say otherwise

Close to the same if I'm taking you both at face value from the information that has been presented to me. I can see accepting a scum case on her more readily than I can a scum case on you.

[MaryJoLisa]

TTTT should be townreading me for the same reasons I'm townreading him based on the gamestate day 1 and 2 but I think he's out gaming himself based on his perception of the setup.

Tomorrow we can massclaim and it should be pretty clear what's going on.

I look forward to seeing that, and you will find that my mind is wide open to the possibilities of you being town, pending Saladman's flip.

[Saladman27]

Wait, did I get hammered? Cause you all keep talking about me like a dead man.

[MaryJoLisa]

I think so, yeah.

[Saladman27]

If these are gonna be my last posts, well.
I don't blame you, I've been pretty bad at this, like on a whole new level of bad, so bad, I don't even read the posts right behind others. Well, I'll probably still be watching and getting mislynched in other games.

[MaryJoLisa]

Awww. I hope I get the chance to see you again. Assuming that you are actually lynched and that I haven't miscounted the votes (which trust me, does happen quite a lot with me.)

[RCEnigma]

Hope we play again bud. I look forward to it.