My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Mafia (Game Over)

[Bins]

it's almost like there were interesting things happening then.

i just feel like this has to be wrong, one of my main townreads is wrong. UGH

your problem is that you're half-assedly calling a bunch of people town, and then thinking that you called them town not half-assedly.

VOTE: Maria

like wtf does this mean

make me discredit my reads in my own head. FEED THE PARANOIA. but in reality i really like my townreads

I just ignored it but I think town implosion could actually say this
especially cause i was scumreading him mainly for poe

[T-Bone]

I meant most recent not sheer postcount your postcount is fine
I'm mostly worried about people lurking thru this gamestate

Okay.

Well, I'd rather you come back and consolidate on Elsa, as I think Maria is town.

[Elsa Jay]

Woah there buckaroo. Let's not do crazy talk.

[T-Bone]

I've been saying it for a long time and we ran you up to L-2, it's not that crazy.

[Papa Zito]

Woah there buckaroo. Let's not do crazy talk.

Do something.

[T-Bone]

If you vote for Elsa he might threaten us again!

[Papa Zito]

Elsa is prime vig fodder. I don't feel like voting there is a good use of our time.

[T-Bone]

Well our vig is dead, unlikely another one exists, and scum aren't going to shoot themselves. If you think Elsa is town, say it. But don't give me the bullshit that lynching scum is not a good use of our time.

[Bins]

elsa isnt a bad lynch but im not sure its flipping red

[Papa Zito]

You remember that part in Empire Strikes Back when Luke is all "yo I gotta leave" and Yoda's like "hey dumbass you gonna get your hand cut off just sayin" and Luke is like "lol k bye" and Obi Wan goes "that dude's our last hope we're fucked" and Yoda's all "nah we got another" which when you think about it is kinda weird cuz Obi Wan was literally there at the birth of the twins, like I get he's both old and dead at that point but how the hell did he manage to forget that Leia you know

exists

, is this another one of those patriarchy things where Leia doesn't count cuz she's a chick and Obi Wan spent too much time in the backwater south in his little hut and it infected him uh anyway yeah I hope there's another.

Also I think Elsa's just utterly useless town yes.

[T-Bone]

And I think Elsa is doing it on purpose to elicit that exact reaction.

[Elsa Jay]

If you vote for Elsa he might threaten us again!

I don't threaten. I passive-aggressively request.

[Papa Zito]

Doing what, being utterly useless? Zoraster Jr, Second of His Name, Bearer of the Keys, Keeper of the Gates of Ineptitude?

There was I reason I decided this some pages back but I don't remember what it was.

[T-Bone]

Yes Zor is doing something similar. Coincidentally I am also scumreading him.

[Papa Zito]

I don't think that's a path to victory for any scumteam though. At some point the town's going to get fed up with the barnacles and start scraping them off. Theoretically anyway.

My desire to see Zoraster dead is far less being actively useless and much more because he point blank refused to defend his position on implosion with the most bullshit reasoning I think I've ever read on here, and may I remind you I've played multiple games with Mastina. The concept of bringing "good faith" into a Mafia game is one of the dumbest things I've ever heard. I'd love to let him decorate the rafters with a little sign reading "good faith" in gold script and festooned with ribbons and bows but apparently fruit vendors are now sacred or something.

[T-Bone]

I agree with you so what exactly are you trying to say? Because Zor is playing the way he is playing a potential scumbuddy wouldn't also use similar tactics?

I don't agree. Player's are going to play to the best of their abilities regardless of who is on their team. I don't think scum!zor is going to look at scum!elsa and go "well, Elsa is choosing this route, so I can't choose it".

I think it's much simpler. Both are playing to their abilities as scum. In Zor's case, he is trying to avoid taking hard stances on his reads and trying to avoid making any associations at all...because that is probably how he plays scum.

I think Elsa is trying to occupy the "is so useless can't be scum" space, because that's how he plays as scum.

In a world where both of these players are teammates, I don't think either would make fundamental adjustments to the way they play.

Also my scumreads on both players are not dependent on each other. I've even softened on Zor late in the day because I've felt he has deviated his tactics in a way I wasn't expecting.

[T-Bone]

To clarify that first paragraph, I mean I agree with you generally in why I think Zor is scum. I don't agree with the premise that I think you were trying to put forward in comparing Zor to Elsa.

[zoraster]

Bluster doesn't make you right, zito.

I don't know how I can impress this on people further though: stop trying to find new lynches. You'll just let new claims and while that might clarify things on day 1, it'll hurt the hell out of us in future days We HAVE a safe "VT" Lynch and unless you have some game confirmed way of knowing he's town, he should be the Lynch. This is basic shit, y'all.

[T-Bone]

That's an awfully pro-scum argument.

[zoraster]

Is it? Argue the protown pro-running up four+ people to claim side tbone

[Papa Zito]

Bluster doesn't make you right, zito.

This'll be on my tombstone.

[T-Bone]

Zito, you can join me on Elsa, or we can work on reforming the Zor lynch. I'm not lynching Maria. I'm only voting implosion if I have to hammer with less than 12 hours to go. His wagon composition has my two highest scumreads on it, and at least one of my pet scum leans.

[Elsa Jay]

Is it? Argue the protown pro-running up four+ people to claim side tbone

Seconded.

[T-Bone]

Is it? Argue the protown pro-running up four+ people to claim side tbone

The pro-town argument is to find a scum lynch. I don't care how many people have to be run up to do it.

Zor is presenting a false choice here by the way. "You're either in favor of running up 4 or more players or you're not" is not a town argument.

[Papa Zito]

I'm only on Maria cuz she's the least bad option I see atm and I have 0 trust in this town to do anything significant before deadline. If we can reform the Zor lynch I'm all over that like edge of extinction castaways on a ham sandwich.


pedit: Elsa I asked you to do something, is this really all you can offer here