My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Mafia (Game Over)

[Elsa Jay]

What did you ask me to do again Zito?

[zoraster]

Is it? Argue the protown pro-running up four+ people to claim side tbone

The pro-town argument is to find a scum lynch. I don't care how many people have to be run up to do it.

Zor is presenting a false choice here by the way. "You're either in favor of running up 4 or more players or you're not" is not a town argument.

Now

there's

a scummy take.

[T-Bone]

So, you're not on Maria because you think she is scum?

Cause, that's not okay, not at this point in the phase.

[zoraster]

Elsa or me?

[T-Bone]

Is it? Argue the protown pro-running up four+ people to claim side tbone

The pro-town argument is to find a scum lynch. I don't care how many people have to be run up to do it.

Zor is presenting a false choice here by the way. "You're either in favor of running up 4 or more players or you're not" is not a town argument.

Now

there's

a scummy take.

You might try explaining how not presenting a false choice is the scummy take. I would like to see you try something, anything, to put some reads out there.

[T-Bone]

I was asking Zito, if I phrased that in a confusing way.

[zoraster]

True or false: a properly designed game with a day 1 mass claim is horrible for town?

[Papa Zito]

What did you ask me to do again Zito?

Woah there buckaroo. Let's not do crazy talk.

Do something.

So, you're not on Maria because you think she is scum?

Cause, that's not okay, not at this point in the phase.

I don't know what she is.

[Papa Zito]

Zor's gonna make me start blustering at him I can feel it.

[Papa Zito]

Don't make me do it zor.

[zoraster]

BTW only have a few more minutes before I have to go to this funeral so apologies if I bug out without responding. Trust me when I say I want you or ,if you are not town others , to understand why this is an actual dichotomy at this point in town and is so antitoen it hurts

[zoraster]

Don't make me do it zor.

Weirdly your bluster as dumb as it is just makes me more sure you're town.

[Elsa Jay]

Don't make me do it zor.

[T-Bone]

And you have stronger scumreads at this point in time?

True or false: a properly designed game with a day 1 mass claim is horrible for town?

True.

It doesn't change the fact that your argument is a false choice. I'm not demanding we run everybody up until they claim. I'm demanding we don't "settle" on a lynch just because it is "safe". Which seems to be your position on lynching implosion. That's not a pro-town position.

I also happen to be advocating lynching someone who has a. Already claimed (you) and b. someone who said they will refuse to claim so we can have no information (Elsa) and c. both players have already been run up to L-1 so nothing new will happen.

[Papa Zito]

Weirdly your bluster as dumb as it is just makes me more sure you're town.

Of course I'm town, I'm the towniest thing in the damn thread. Yes that includes the worst.

Nobody's suggesting a massclaim and I already noted in my weekend catch up that I don't get why implosion didn't get lynched. That said there's really not much difference between VTs and fruit vendors so this is a really weird argument for you to be having anyway.

[Errantparabola]

VOTE: maria
Im pretty lost
Soneone talk to me?

[Papa Zito]

Hello Ep it's Captain Bluster here how can I help

[Errantparabola]

hi captain bluster, long time listener, first time caller
i have like 4 reads, can i sheep you on the rest

[Untrod Tripod]

Votecount 1.15

Elsa Jay - 2 (SleepyKrew, T-Bone)
implosion - 5 (MariaR, zoraster, Alchemist21, Elsa Jay, xRECKONERx)
MariaR - 5 (implosion, Papa Zito, the worst, Bins, ErrantParabola)
T-Bone - 1 (Baezu)

With 14 alive, it's 8 votes to hug someone until they are too full of friendship to continue the game. Day ends in (expired on 2019-04-20 09:11:00). Everypony play mafia!

[Papa Zito]

If you're gonna sheep someone I'd suggest sheeping the worst, who is both confirmed town and the site's official Rising Star. Somehow. What those reads exactly are I'm not sure.

The gamestate is such that despite having fairly strong reads on a number of people I don't really trust my feelings on people at all :V

That said if you wanna discuss someone I'd be reluctant but willing to. I'm full of loathing atm you see because while normally I'd be playing my cards way way closer to my chest, I feel like I gotta be more forthcoming otherwise this thread would be nothing but dry tumbleweeds. I'm sure the scumteam appreciates it.

[Bins]

VOTE: zoraster

[Errantparabola]

I'm the same re not trusting my reads at all

[Bins]

Actually do I want to dissolve the Maria wagon


Idk

Also Skrew and Gif are much worse than Elsa

[Bins]

ep who do I vote Zor or Maria

Best case theyre both scum

[Bins]

VOTE: Maria

She can respond to the wagon first and if I like the response Ill switch back