Mini 2074: Madness at Port Arthur (Game Over)

[Persivul]

I have carried you as town so yeah I think you know how strong my townplay can be when I actually bother to play

Just tell us your fucking main if you want meta to count. The hydra's garbage anyway. I doubt you'll ever want to use it again after this shitfest.

[Irrelephant11]

Yes, in a stagnant gamestate with three equally viable lynches I am thirsty for the mislynch of the mighty, terrifying Smile, capable of garbage cases and not reading the thread
You are my mislynch priority rn, and for good reason

I have carried you as town so yeah I think you know how strong my townplay can be when I actually bother to play

Well this is actually baffling because I've never T/T'd the person I thought you were

[tris]

I'm a day 2 IC

Haha. I don't believe this. VOTE: Smile

[Smile]

Why not? My only goal was to be alive on day 2. do you know how hard that is in a 5 person hydra?

[Smile]

Yes, in a stagnant gamestate with three equally viable lynches I am thirsty for the mislynch of the mighty, terrifying Smile, capable of garbage cases and not reading the thread
You are my mislynch priority rn, and for good reason

I have carried you as town so yeah I think you know how strong my townplay can be when I actually bother to play

Well this is actually baffling because I've never T/T'd the person I thought you were

during

You have and I carried you and I kinda don't believe you forgot that game

[Irrelephant11]

I don't know what "during" means

Either I'm wrong about who you are or have a bad memory. I'm leaning towards the first rn, because I just double checked and still can't find any t/t games with who I thought you were. There are not many potential grand reveals here that would dramatically change my read on you though

[Smile]

Like sure I barely read this game but essentially I can be an endgame townblock with 2 jailers. I kinda didn't care about the wagon because I wanted to claim for jailer to protect me anyway. I just wanted to see who would be the scummiest jumping on me.

[Irrelephant11]

you're not a duck, penguin, or zebra, right? 'Cause those are the only three dramatic reveals I can think of that would break my read on you

[Smile]

you're not a duck, penguin, or zebra, right? 'Cause those are the only three dramatic reveals I can think of that would break my read on you

Relly is now trying to backpedal by implying he thinks he thought I was a different person as though he doesn't know who I am. This is not something someone asks *after* making a meta argument. This is something someone asks when they realize their mislynch is an IC.

[tris]

you're not a duck, penguin, or zebra, right? 'Cause those are the only three dramatic reveals I can think of that would break my read on you

Relly is now trying to backpedal by implying he thinks he thought I was a different person as though he doesn't know who I am. This is not something someone asks *after* making a meta argument. This is something someone asks when they realize their mislynch is an IC.

That post doesn't imply to me that he's backing away.

[Irrelephant11]

A D2 IC is not enough of a reason for me to not lynch you in a role madness game

To reiterate, your goal in voting fuscezu was not anything you said here:

I mean, we have a lot of vanity votes on solo wagons right now. At some point people have to start being willing to work together. If you want tris to go through today you should push that but I don't see that happening right now. I'm not really in love with your CC wagon. You seem to townread Fusc but if I remember right you basically said "I can't explain why" one of the last times you were asked about it. Maybe you explained somewhere else that I missed. So what's bad other on fusc than your gut townread on the slot? So if you want to lead on tris then go for it, and yeah my vote can be seen as survivalistic because I don't really see a point of starting a new wagon at a point when there's so much apathy in the game that half the player list is barely posting at all. -Beauty

But rather to further the wagon on yourself so you could find a new scum to start a wagon on within the last 24 hours of the game day?
And, presumably, this scum you've found is me, who you have not yet cased for the rest of the town to be able to sheep you.
You played this way because you knew that drawing the lynch toward yourself by playing poorly near deadline would not, in fact, lead to your own demise, but would rather be easily explained away, your (new) preferred lynch would go through, and then you'd be an IC D2.

Is that summary correct?

pedit: I am not trying to backpedal. Talk about misrepping. I don't care who you are, you're clearly scum.

[Smile]

That post doesn't imply to me that he's backing away.

He's pushed too hard. He has to test the waters first to see if he can back off for a plausible reason.

[Smile]

I am not trying to backpedal.

This is what he says when he realizes he's dug himself too deep

[Irrelephant11]

I guess I trust town will just know what to do here. I'll check in before deadline but I've let this endless arguing distract me from work for too long

peditx2: I'm actually laughing

[Smile]

Tris what is your read of irrelephant and why?

[Smile]

peditx2: I'm actually laughing

someone is getting desperate and now is going to start lurking so he doesn't spew anymore

[tris]

Town. He has thoughts that seem organic and nuanced, and a couple of times have meshed with how I'm thinking.

[tris]

peditx2: I'm actually laughing

someone is getting desperate and now is going to start lurking so he doesn't spew anymore

Lol

[Smile]

Town. He has thoughts that seem organic and nuanced, and a couple of times have meshed with how I'm thinking.

What times are those?

[Chara]

day 2 IC isn't good enough to not lynch, sorry. i haven't read much beyond that (and that's on me).
1003 makes me disbelieve the claim completely, anyway.

[Chara]

Smile's attitude i think comes from town more than scum in a vacuum, but the degree of certainty with which i can say that isn't good enough that i'd want to move the wagon or try to hit Fusco instead.
and their arguments aren't great, i'm also kind of ignoring all of the "meta" seeing as i don't know who this is and elephant doesn't seem to either. it's not hard to forget a game you shared when the description you're going off is so vague, Beauty. (it's that one, right)

[Chara]

you're not a duck, penguin, or zebra, right? 'Cause those are the only three dramatic reveals I can think of that would break my read on you

Relly is now trying to backpedal by implying he thinks he thought I was a different person as though he doesn't know who I am. This is not something someone asks *after* making a meta argument. This is something someone asks when they realize their mislynch is an IC.

i also don't really get this point or how you came up with it.
the only way elephant could use this to backpedal would be if it would give him some sort of out. unless you actually are one of these three players (it's very obvious you aren't) he can't exactly use that.

if you are town i'm sorry this happened to your hydra, but you can't only rely on others being active so that you don't have to be. and one active head in a hydra is enough to be a player in a game.

[Chara]

Mᴀᴅɴᴇꜱꜱ

ᴀᴛ Pᴏʀᴛ

Aʀᴛʜᴜʀ

Moderator: funkybike1 ⋄ Backup Moderator: brassherald

Spectator thread is open. If you're not playing in the game and you wish to spectate, PM me.

Spoiler: Alive (13/13)

ceejayvinoya
Chara
ClearlyClarity
Fuscezu
insomnia
Irrelephant11
Brown Eyes

(replacing Miss Kobayashi Maru)

Persivul
RCEnigma
Flavor Leaf

(replacing Shiidaji)

skitter30
Smile
tris

Spoiler: Dead (0/13)

you can forget what i said about towny attitude, i think it's just NAI attitude.
i have more reads now but i'll hold off on them as they're irrelevant to approaching deadline.

[RCEnigma]

Still on page 38. I don't want to come around to irrel just bring town, I've been on the opposite side if all his reads up to this point afaik. So I either have really terrible reads or he's likely scum putting the game in his hands right?

But I agree with the assessment on CC though I wouldn't doubt her to placate town voices if she's scum. Also agree on the FL assessment, he's not going anywhere, it's not an immediate issue.

Didn't dive too deep into smiles case on fusco whom I think is town. I remember thinking smile was indirectly deflecting from CC with the vote and even though I think CC is town... It's a believable team.

[ClearlyClarity]

What does being an IC have to do with anything? I thought that role was defunct now?