Newbie 1934: Tundra (Game Over)

[Eggs]

re 69

On your three main points.

1) that teacher wagon needed the L-1. I laughed at myself. Sue me.
2) I can't handle less than 8 hours sleep. UK.
3) fair cop. I'd be voting me.

[Flavor Leaf]

Flavor, I’ve given a case for Eggs, which I’ll concede isn’t beyond refutation but at least has a logic to it. Why am I scummier in your eyes?

Vote placements.

I could be wrong, I admit. This question is rather townie, but I don’t know you as a player yet, so I don’t want to be fooled by underestimating you. I imagine I’ll figure it out if I’m wrong or right pretty soon.

[Uncle Bob]

Bob, why did you say "one of his partners"? What did you mean?

That was a mistake.

Vote: Flavour Leaf

This is better. I'm concerned about how he's keeping his options open.

[Flavor Leaf]

That’s just how I play when I’m town.

[Flavor Leaf]

I’m not silly enough to think I can solve so early, so i dont get manipulated by the gamestate.

[Flavor Leaf]

I think that’s a townie play by Uncle.1

[Flavor Leaf]

I generally say all my thoughts.

Why am I expected to have solid and confident reads on page 4? We just started the game, and I’m still learning who you guys are as players.

[Flavor Leaf]

Also, you said I’m leaving my options open, but I really am only pushing 2 people, and I’ve chosen one over the other, so that is a flawed post in itself, but it makes sense to me why you’d push for that as town, if that makes sense.

[Menalque]

That's fair, I figured that hopping around might come across a little scummy. However, I thought it was worth the risk as from the wiki it seems that the recommendation is that getting wagons going Day 1 is important for information gathering. My votes for irrelephant and thenavneet were both a part of that, whereas my vote for eggs is because I still think that the claim that he didn't realise that he was putting nav at L-1 is the scummiest thing in thread so far.

If we look at his last post, there's also no effort to defend himself beyond "I was sleepy". Plus "I'd be voting me" seems like it could be very plausibly be a double bluff.

[Uncle Bob]

I’m not silly enough to think I can solve so early, so i dont get manipulated by the gamestate.

I was also thinking of your one of these two must be scum post.

Why am I expected to have solid and confident reads on page 4?

You're not. I'd say your unnecessarily laying the ground work to move your vote.

[Menalque]

Bob, what do you think of my points re: Eggs?

[Uncle Bob]

They're reasonable.

[Menalque]

Why do you think Flavor's behaviour (keeping his options open) is scummier than Eggs claiming to not notice he was putting someone at L-1?

[Cinnamon]

I'm not sure how Flavor plays but to me he's trying to look town, whereas Eggs seems more apathetic than anything. Both of them aren't giving off towny vibes but Flavor seems more scummy at the moment.

VOTE: Flavor

[Uncle Bob]

I voted Flavour then because he'd just posted and I was hoping to get a chance to hear from him quickly. I'm not sure if he's scummier.

[Uncle Bob]

That was for Menalque.

[Menalque]

I'd like to add this about Eggs: we can see that he made his first post of the day at 6:40 UK time, while his post here didn't come until after 7:30. Therefore, it's not convincing that he wouldn't have been awake enough by that point to miss that he was putting nav at L-1.

[Menalque]

Cinnamon, same question as the one for Bob: why do you think Flavor's behaviour (trying to look town) is scummier than Eggs claiming to not notice he was putting someone at L-1?

Also, thanks for the response Bob.

[Flavor Leaf]

Neat. Keep it coming.

I reckon 1 scum on me already, 1 scum in the pair I said previously.

[Flavor Leaf]

I never try to look town, not even as town. I just be town.

[Flavor Leaf]

What do you mean by unnecessary? Why would I ever do unnecessary work as either alignment, let alone scum?

[Flavor Leaf]

UNVOTE: Melanque

[Flavor Leaf]

Cinnamon is more likely scum than Bob is here.

[Cinnamon]

I said that because I think acting apathetic can happen as either alignment but generally trying to look town is something a good town wouldn't do

[Cinnamon]

I don't like flavors behavior here either but again I haven't looked at how he previously plays