Gameshow Mafia (Reroll): Game Over

[RadiantCowbells]

like i believe the mathematical case for why it's incorrect to lynch a truly unreadable player except under niche circumstances has been made to death

so... it's not trying to win. particularly when you factor in calling me scum when i'm scum is an exercise in futility and calling me scum when i'm town is extremely disruptive to town's chances of winning in general. i just... can't reconcile that.

[RadiantCowbells]

i'm not even saying this for just this game. this is a bigger problem than this game
really... what's the point of playing with me if you're just going to call me scum based off of arbitrary shit that you know has nothing to do with my alignment
what are you even working towards? if i roll scum someday and you win because of it, does it say something meaningful about your abilities?

and for the record a long list of people have been doing this for years. it doesn't work when i'm scum. it certainly ruins games when i'm town tho

[Chemist1422]

rc do you desire pats

or should I read isos

or should I just continue to barely exist

[NanceFloor]

I’m sorry you’re not having fun playing mafia, RC. <3

I really trust my reads when my head is really in the game and I have you and Sky almost on townlock and PB, 99999999.99% close to it. I think when he answers my repicker power question, I hope to lock that in and then we won’t need anymore than 3 coalition members in veto.

My Creature tr has now degraded to the point where I think Creature/Chemist/Clemency. So based on failed coalition, my best current guess for scumteam is TD/Moon/Creature. I think following Titus’ plan is pretty much a death sentence for PB.

Him not wanting coalition factored into that as well and you have been 100% pro 2nd coalition since early game as is Titus. That’s what is still pinging me about Moon - him wanting to repick veto but Creature wanting vengeful next isn’t good. Vengeful is worse than lynch because it probably just removes a strong tr.

[Pink Ball]

I don't know how answering that question would help you sorting me, Nancy, but I'm not answering it 'cause I'm not putting more effort in this game that I have already put, sorry.

[NanceFloor]

I don't know how answering that question would help you sorting me, Nancy, but I'm not answering it 'cause I'm not putting more effort in this game that I have already put, sorry.

Because I think you’re town and this would help me lock you in. I wish you would put in the effort, because it would make much easier to convince Titus and everyone to sheep my 3 person coalition but if you’re not willing to do that, I will probably wind up having to sheep her and I’m going to be really pissed at you, when I get proven right about you flipping town.

[NanceFloor]

I don't know how answering that question would help you sorting me, Nancy, but I'm not answering it 'cause I'm not putting more effort in this game that I have already put, sorry.

Because I think you’re town and this would help me lock you in. I wish you would put in the effort, because it would make much easier to convince Titus and everyone to sheep my 3 person coalition IN VETO but if you’re not willing to do that, I will probably wind up having to sheep her and I’m going to be really pissed at you, when I get proven right about you flipping town.

[RadiantCowbells]

gut says that creature is town and that chennis's complaining about the setup being scumsided is scum.

[chennisden]

this setup is ridiculously townsided so its ok

but i never said the setup is scumsided, did i?

[RadiantCowbells]

i meant townsided. dunno. feels like you're mad about it. could be wrong. my emotional investment in this game is almost gone.

[RadiantCowbells]

i'm totally fine with creature and/or pink ball flipping town at this point

imo there's basically one of two worlds here

one where scum have been directing the game and it's some combo of {mbakislot, ankslot, titus, etc.)
and one where they have just been lurking where it's some combo of {mariaslot, chemistslot, clemslot)

i'd expect like some amount of overlap but fundamentally i'm happy to just get this veto done as long as it doesn't involve flipping my hard trs

i'd still oppose creature's presence and replace him with chennis or something but i dunno how much i actually care about losing this game anymore

[RadiantCowbells]

like there's a time where i'd have just been like

nah we're doing this veto

and i think a solid 33% of the time i would have actually hit 3 scum here and won the game outright with my recent record

but it's just not there.

[Pink Ball]

I don't know how answering that question would help you sorting me, Nancy, but I'm not answering it 'cause I'm not putting more effort in this game that I have already put, sorry.

Because I think you’re town and this would help me lock you in. I wish you would put in the effort, because it would make much easier to convince Titus and everyone to sheep my 3 person coalition but if you’re not willing to do that, I will probably wind up having to sheep her and I’m going to be really pissed at you, when I get proven right about you flipping town.

Pissed at me?!?!?!? Pffffffft

I'm sheeping Titus too, you should be doing the same

[MariaR]

Sheeping titus oh boy.

[NanceFloor]

I don't know how answering that question would help you sorting me, Nancy, but I'm not answering it 'cause I'm not putting more effort in this game that I have already put, sorry.

Because I think you’re town and this would help me lock you in. I wish you would put in the effort, because it would make much easier to convince Titus and everyone to sheep my 3 person coalition but if you’re not willing to do that, I will probably wind up having to sheep her and I’m going to be really pissed at you, when I get proven right about you flipping town.

Pissed at me?!?!?!? Pffffffft

I'm sheeping Titus too, you should be doing the same

Because I could convince people to sheep me. I don’t know why you’re so gung ho on following Titus’ plan, since you’re in veto.

[NanceFloor]

Sheeping titus oh boy.

I’m really confused, help me make some sense of this, because I can’t.

[MariaR]

Sheepinig Titus at this stage in the game when a fight broke out because of 'sheeping' in the first place mostly puzzles me.

[NanceFloor]

Alright fine, if PB is so hellbent on being in veto.

VOTE: Creature, Chemist, Clemency, Pink Ball

I still think he’s town and gamethrowing but whatever.

[NanceFloor]

Sheepinig Titus at this stage in the game when a fight broke out because of 'sheeping' in the first place mostly puzzles me.

Yeah, I totally don’t get it but I’m done fighting for someone who doesn’t want to save themselves, so meh. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[MariaR]

Do I get to do the I told you so dance 2 times in a row whenPink ball and creature die in this veto and I have to get Chemist lynched normally?
Prob
VOTE: Creature, Chemist, Clemency, Pink Ball

[Pink Ball]

Nancy, being in the veto is not gamethrowing. I've explained like a thousand times why I think I'm a good option to be in the veto. I fucking KNOW I'm town and I want to be in the veto 'cause it will be better in the long run. So please for the love of god, stop implying I should do something else.

p-edit: you don't know what the scumteam will do, do you? You don't know if I'll be dead or alive tomorrow if I'm in the veto.

[Skygazer]

VOTE: Creature, Chemist, Clem, Pink Ball

w/e

[NanceFloor]

@Succinct, please repick coalition tonight.

[Skygazer]

@Succinct, please repick coalition tonight.

[Pink Ball]

VOTE: Creature, Chemist, Clemency, Pink Ball

I think that's the hammer.

Ego bet: NanceFloor, RC and Sky. Byeeeeeee