2078: Any Non-Dead Person Can Post In This Mafia Game [end]

[rosterfoster]

Like I don’t think scum maybe possibly having a BP means I can’t be a town commuter

[Pine]

I'm pretty sure I've seen a scum commuter before?

Also commuter being reasonable is true but like. Do you get the impression xyzzy sat down to make these roles and thought, "ok it's time to make a reasonable setup."?

W/r/t this, I suspect we’re not being told the whole truth. It’s probably conditional or dependent on circumstances in a way he’s not saying. Hell, I’ve been an even commuter and claimed odd commuter just to bait the kill.

When you have multiple killing roles, it makes sense to throw in some defensive ones. Classic is bulletproof, but that’s passive and boring. Commuter is great because it’s active, and a bit of a gamble. Yes you’re protected, but you also can’t be cleared by a cop or make your factional kill. There’s more inherent jeopardy to it.

Xyzzy knows all of this, and enjoys convoluted PRs, so while commuter makes sense, simple even night modifier does not. That lends itself to being a partial fakeclaim.

Nom, come back to the wagon. And kill Lavender tonight, ok?

[Ausuka]

So you’re doubting my role BECAUSE it makes sense?

I kind of wanna speedwagon Ausuka.

yes

By all means think I’m a scum commuter but you’re trying to attack my townieness from two mutually exclusive angles

I don't particularly think you're that but if someone says something I know is incorrect I'm going to point that out?

[Pine]

So you’re doubting my role BECAUSE it makes sense?

I kind of wanna speedwagon Ausuka.

Both this and roster’s mad scramble to defend himself feel further scummy to me.

[rosterfoster]

I’m an even number of posters commuter

[rosterfoster]

I don’t like being lynched

[nomnomnom]

I'm just trying to think here, the "even" part sounds weird in the sense that it's even less controllable than say... admins posting, yeah?

[rosterfoster]

It’s a way of making it random basically.

Hence 50% commuter

[rosterfoster]

And that part is xyzzy’s fuckwitted mindfuck part of the setup

[nomnomnom]

That sounds really fucking stupid

[rosterfoster]

...which is why it’s in the game

[Ausuka]

Hmm actually the 50% thing probably makes this believable.

Unsure if it's necessarily a town role however?

[Pine]

I maintain that this sounds like a real xyzzy role with the lie being the alignment.

[nomnomnom]

I mean roster hasn't claimed a self-sided wincon which would ACTUALLY make me believe this is a role in the game, like, this being a town role is eeeeeeeeeeeew

[nomnomnom]

Just what does this accomplish... Like at least the other roles you can see why they're in the game it's just PEW PEW AHAHAHAHA EX FUCKING DEE but this is like jesus christ

[nomnomnom]

Nah fuck this mate

VOTE: Roster

L-1

Xyzzy if this is actually a town sided commuter im gonna scream @ u

[rosterfoster]

Nom townclaimed with the indecision at least <3

Please lynch Who, Lavender and Ausuka

[rosterfoster]

My role is like the antidote to all the pew prepare roles

[rosterfoster]

*pewpewpew

[rosterfoster]

Nom how well do you scream?

[nomnomnom]

Nom how well do you scream?

Really fucking bad lol

[rosterfoster]

The indignity of being the only person on the site not allowed to post in this thread though

[rosterfoster]

Your throat’s gonna get a whole lot worse

[nomnomnom]

@Pine who are you loving btw

just so I don't shoot the same guy

[ofrhz]

UNVOTE:

I think we should wait for jingle to chime in first

I don’t think Pines role condition has been met yet either