Mini Normal 2080 ft. My Cats [Game Over]

[Detective Pikachu]

Please designate your best player so I may vote them to assert dominance

Skitter has a banner under her name so that puts her ahead of most of us I think.

I have no idea how to play this role so I'll say this: part of my role is that I am a miller.

AHAHAHHAHAAAAA
No.
VOTE: Cinnamon

Fuck it- my meta read on urap2 is based on a newbie game anyway, and seeing where this wagon leads us is interesting
VOTE: urap2

wooooow
just woooooow

Way to completely dismiss my entire case and stop engaging with that.
And of course you will still keep on trying to get me lynched even though you don't have any solid ground to push this from.
VOTE: nom x3
There's townie "ok fine I'll back off, let's look for another person to look for"
and there's
"I WILL GET THIS MISLYNCH AT ANY AND ALL COSTS"

I'm always willing to consider new and different approaches provided that there can be some sort of argument in favor for them, but THIS right here is truly disgusting.

Bah just saw the VC
VOTE: Flubber
Beetlejuicing

My gut tells me that one of {ED/Flubber} has pretty damn high scum equity
They've had the opportunity to interact on all of the things right now

I'll sort the rest of you lot in due time

flubber is your best push to date and i still kinda think it's the wrong choice vs ED?

I feel like the only slot you could have hit as scum by just randomly voting at this point is flubber but I don't see why I'd townread you for pushing three town back to back? Which is kinda what I think your day 1 looks like so far.

I don't think you're confscum, but I don't see anything that strongly leans town over scum in any of these

Urap and nom votes are both kinda overly emotional too

[nomnomnom]

@DP do you REALLY think ED is the best vote right now after everything you highlighted? Genuine question.

[Vorkuta]

Urap and nom votes are both kinda overly emotional too

Urap2 was the wagon hop vote- not emotional.

flubber is your best push to date and i still kinda think it's the wrong choice vs ED?

obligatory "have you read my nom push"?

Also like... ED is "capable" of mechanical insights- the fact that he doesn't and lurks out is scary sure, but I view flubber's drunk posting -> nothingness as a greater sin.
And an ED vote is an inactivity policy lynch wagon, not an actual scum read

but I don't see why I'd townread you for pushing three town back to back?

-and you know that they're town slots how exactly?
-oh boy I wonder what your criteria are for town reading other people if that's the case

[Detective Pikachu]

The dude read my post and refused to comment on Dunn. No man, I think he's lurker scum, he's like deliberately avoiding engaging. It's not policy.

What are you talking about mechanical insights?

[Detective Pikachu]

@DP do you REALLY think ED is the best vote right now after everything you highlighted? Genuine question.

I think Vork usually reads like a chicken with its head cut off tho so I'm just not sure that all makes him scum. sorry don't want to mainslip but I don't think his day 1 reads are typically above random so being 0/3 in his first 3 pushes isn't really out of form.

But it doesn't make him town and so he's more poe scum than scum vs. ED who is really kinda rubbing me the wrong way. Like ED's entire iso reminds me of how I used to play scum

[Vorkuta]

The dude read my post and refused to comment

on Dunn

.

FTFY
TL;DR his slot

Like yes- I am in agreement that cherrypicking which random posts/parts-of-posts to reply to and which to selectively ignore (all of them) is scummy.
HOWEVER his ISO has a high signal-noise ratio.
That's it pretty much my distinction between ED and flubber
I'm hoping he actually pops in and engages more, but I like how his content has quality in it.
Unlike flubber

[Detective Pikachu]

I feel like scum tends to have a higher signal to noise ratio tho? I feel like town shitposts and fluffposts way more than scum, on average, in any given game. Not like scum can't fluffpost but I don't think being noisy is worse than being quiet

[Vorkuta]

I don't think his day 1 reads are typically above random so being 0/3 in his first 3 pushes isn't really out of form.

ok now I'm butthurt at you as well

-I build up my town block BEFORE scumhunting and my pushes primarily serve to build up a townblock first
-7 completed non-newbie town games
-Jazz D1 (most recent) readlist- 2 for 2 @D1

[Vorkuta]

I feel like scum tends to have a higher signal to noise ratio tho? I feel like town shitposts and fluffposts

I mean that's just something each and everyone of us is going to have to pass judgement on individually.

I personally think that flubber's drunk posting and then "soberposting" comes from scum.
I personally think that ED is more interested in """"""solving""""" the game rather than shitposting which makes him towney.
Like if he wanted to shitpost a bit as either alignment, he had ample opportunity to reply to anyone that accepted his first post challenge.

That's just my interpretation of the 2 slots

[Detective Pikachu]

Do you think he's solving because he's townreading you?

[Vorkuta]

oh my how on earth did you get to that conclusion?

also based on what you should know about me as a player, you know I don't place too much emphasis on who town reads me, but I like those that scumread my scumreads.
He townreads nom so that cancels out the ^

[teacher]

I don't think his day 1 reads are typically above random so being 0/3 in his first 3 pushes isn't really out of form.

ok now I'm butthurt at you as well

-I build up my town block BEFORE scumhunting and my pushes primarily serve to build up a townblock first
-7 completed non-newbie town games
-Jazz D1 (most recent) readlist- 2 for 2 @D1

Whose your townblock then. Last is see is 553’s non-read list.

[teacher]

@DP can you sell me on nom?

[Vorkuta]

I'll post it when it's been refined and updated and when nom x3 and Dunn do something other than tunnel me
not at your prompting

But you guys already probably know that buj, nc, and salad have been binned yes?

[Nero Cain]

Why is teacher null, Dp?

[teacher]

Yes.

Why not when I ask? What benefit do you see in waiting?

[teacher]

Nero since your on and still haven’t answered my question from yesterday, why am I scum? I liked 265 but the game has, in corks words, tons of analysis since then, so presumably it has confirmed your views? How?

[Nero Cain]

But you guys already probably know that buj, nc, and salad have been binned yes?

I do not like being stuck in a bin. I needs my freedom.

[Vorkuta]

Why not when I ask? What benefit do you see in waiting?

refined and updated and when nom x3 and Dunn do something other than tunnel me

To draw out suspense

/s

I want to see how players approach other slots- my reads aren't the most accurate when I'm in the spotlight. I need other players to enjoy their time on stage so I can look at them

[teacher]

You haven’t been in the spotlight since Wednesday.

[Nero Cain]

I'm just tunneling you and I think you are p likely to be POE scum but let's pretend I'm wrong. Who should I tunnel instead?

[teacher]

That’s not answering my question. Ok you’re tunneled on me. Why?

[Vorkuta]

And absolutely nothing of interest has happened since then

[Nero Cain]

That’s not answering my question. Ok you’re tunneled on me. Why?

yes, it is? FMPOV nothing has really changed. It may not be an answer you like but it still is one.

And now I', asking you questions.

Who should I tunnel instead? Who is the scum on your wagon? If you don't think there are any why do you think they haven't voted you?

[teacher]

I think scum has voted me. I am less sure about whether scum is voting me.

If being useless with vote is such a big deal for you, why are you resisting ED, who iirc has not voted all game?