Mini Normal 2081 — My First Game! [Game Over]

[chennisden]

quick first ever readslist -
town
robb
dann
luv
exilon
skitter
pisskop
menalque
scum

HMM

[Cinnamon]

If you are actually town here I think your play is pretty bad. I don't think I'll get any more benefit out of interacting with you like this.

[chennisden]

You've taken weak defensive stances on Menalque whenever you've needed to.

[chennisden]

VOTE: skygazer[/]

I wanted to vote for cinnamon

as a policy lynch

but now you’ve made it so that would be sheeping

You like should not be saying this

[Cinnamon]

VOTE: Menalque
I'm scumreading Menalque here. Compared to my previous experience with him, his thought process is much less cohesive and I find myself a bit confused by his play. I find 560 to be an example of that.

As a hot take, I think there's exactly one scum in {Menalque, skitter}

Where is my thought process less cohesive?

In our last game, I could see myself thinking most of the things that you said and I understood where that thought process came from. Here, that's much less of the case. For instance, I'm not sure where your post in 560 came from.

@menalque: an example would be his whole exchange with u regarding the cop/doc/neighborizer thing - he thinks he found an inconsistency in your approach to the game and is using his quetions to try to understand your thought process

yeah, I agree that was townie, the problem I have with it is that it only emerged at all after someone was actually pushing and I think that doing something like that is defo within the capabilities of scum!luv

Here again, I don't see it. The person pushing LUV here was you I believe? Wouldn't that make it equally as townie or more townie for him to be trying to figure you out?

[Cinnamon]

I don't know how you interpreted this as a 'weak defensive stance'

[chennisden]

You don't get to say "your play is bad" when you're the one who can only defend himself by saying "ur shit"

[chennisden]

Scum bus their buddies before they get rung up and when they get rung up they say "I see how they could be townie"

[Cinnamon]

Am I crazy or have I actually been talking to myself this whole game?

[chennisden]

Both

[chennisden]

Cinnamon if you want me to approach your slot in good faith saying "you're shit at the game" doesn't work

[Cinnamon]

Cinnamon if you want me to approach your slot in good faith saying "you're shit at the game" doesn't work

I made very real points to you and you made poor responses. I don't think I can work with your slot right now.

[chennisden]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=79718

evidence of menalque/cinnamon being good

[chennisden]

I'm not going to hand you a free TR for being more townie as scum than most newbies can muster

[chennisden]

You gave me a perfect chance to sort your slot

[chennisden]

And I've sorted it

[chennisden]

I do take back the point about associatives with Menalque though

[chennisden]

But the consensus PoE is

{cinnamon menalque luv pisskop}

and I'm not letting pisskop get rung up today.

[chennisden]

Pushing me is the wrong play as either alignment

[chennisden]

I'm kinda rethinking the menalque read

I'll join you on this

[chennisden]

Cinnamon if you want to force this 1v1 be my guest.

[chennisden]

But on the off chance you're town you can go lynch scum instead?

[chennisden]

there's two problems with pushing me as a scum lynch

1) im town
2) im not gonna get lynched

[Cinnamon]

You're making up so many lies it hurts. Nobody's talking about 1v1s but you. The consensus PoE list you made is terrible. You just linked to a game where I was town and used that to explain why you think I could look townie as mafia. I don't understand your play at all.

[skitter30]

ok i'm catching up now, i'm a few pages behind