Role Call I (Game Over)

[Oversoul]

Its just a space filler, imo

Itll stop us from giving that person a strong pr on a day we get a protective, or after the bodyguard item has been given out though.


I have a suspicion itll be relevant

After thinking about it more, the mafia rolestop ability makes protective roles almost pointless.

[Oversoul]

1-shot Gladiator: apthet
Inactive: Vecna
Day 5 Innocent Child: CheekyTeeky
Inventor: Gamma Emerald
Day 3 King: pisskop
Macho: popsofctown
Miller: Oversoul
Odd-Night Motion Detector: Hidden Happiness
Neighbour: Titus
Neighbour: Lil Uzi Vert
Timid: Almost50
Night 1 Universal Backup: Nero Cain
Vanilla: momo
Compulsive Quitter: Iconeum

huh?

I dont like the negative utility on me and pops. giving the two of us neighbours is a better fit with more options for later days.

Id be even willing to swallow an icon lynch, although hes not.my prefered option.

Agree. Give Titus the inactive and LUV Macho and I would support that.

[Vecna]

GM: does rolestopping a person also prevent the nightkill?

[pisskop]

GM: does rolestopping a person also prevent the nightkill?

Rolestop (Night, Factional). Choose a player. All other actions targeting that player, except for Eliminate, will fail. Unlike most night actions, you may target this at yourself if you wish.

Please read. Dont do that.

[Vecna]

the OP links to the wiki which states only variations of a rolestopper wont stop kills, so im pretty sure scum cannot use their rolestop to circumvent protectives

[pisskop]

All other actions targeting that player, except for Eliminate,

Im pretty sure you need to read

[pisskop]

Everything. Except for the explicit factional kill, named 'eliminate'

Everything. Except. The. Kill

[Vecna]

Ehm ok. Not used to additional setup info being hidden under the role pm spoilers

[Oversoul]

If I was a betting man I would say that CFJ is gonna have like a day of protective roles and then a day of investigative roles with one or two tweaks between them.

[Vecna]

queue the whiners stating I just faked a townslip

[pisskop]

Not faked a townslip.

It wasnt a potential townslip

[pisskop]

I dont think it is AI for anyone.

[Almost50]

But please correct me if I'm wrong on this. I've scumread you correctly a most of the time when we've been TvS with me as the T.

That's misleading. When you SR me ALL THE TIME then you will always "correctly SR me when I'm scum and you're Town". It's not because you CAN read me. It's because you will always SR me regardless, so when I'm scum you'd be correct (that's 30% of the time in average).

[Vecna]

Not faked a townslip.

It wasnt a potential townslip

the information you quoted is literally from the scum role pm is my point (and hidden behind a spoiler in the op).

[pisskop]

again. It wasnt a viable townslip

[Vecna]

i want my townslip

[Almost50]

I don't know if you'd take it this far as scum though

Tbh, I might. But then the tone will probably give me away. Anyone who is good at tone reading can tell this is not an act as I'm genuinely pissed here.

But OK. Nero voted against, so I'm less confident this is the way to go. If it turns out to be the right call in the end I can always tease him about it for the next few games.

[pisskop]

lol.

[Vecna]

I don't know if you'd take it this far as scum though

Tbh, I might. But then the tone will probably give me away. Anyone who is good at tone reading can tell this is not an act as I'm genuinely pissed here.

But OK. Nero voted against, so I'm less confident this is the way to go. If it turns out to be the right call in the end I can always tease him about it for the next few games.

care to respond to my post regarding nero?

[Almost50]

No. You ask a lot and give little in return. I happen to know it's how you play so no -ve points given, but I don't care to respond on why I TR Nero so hard.

[Almost50]

Besides, it won't change a thing for you. You and I both know that. You will try to lynch him regardless, and if given a Vig shot you're still going to shoot him.

[Vecna]

Thats just disingenuous. Ive not made a single attempt to lynch him so far, and whenever I make an attempt to sort either of you, mend fences or just try to have a dialogue, I am met with hostile statements.

You clearly dont think im scum, so why given the opportunity dont you even attempt a little to change my mind if you have good reasons to think im so wrong?

I really dont get it

[Almost50]

Mate, it is not easy to quote certain stiff from Nero to call him town. That's not how it works. It's how he posts, and the general way he approaches the game that enables me to read him. In this game he clearly does not have a scum agenda. He's not being cautious or fictitious or even overly survivalistic. There's nothing that scum!Nero gains from playing the way he is playing this game.

[Hidden Happiness]

1-shot Gladiator: apthet
Inactive: Vecna
Day 5 Innocent Child: CheekyTeeky
Inventor: Gamma Emerald
Day 3 King: pisskop
Macho: popsofctown
Miller: Oversoul
Odd-Night Motion Detector: Hidden Happiness
Neighbour: Titus
Neighbour: Lil Uzi Vert
Timid: Almost50
Night 1 Universal Backup: Nero Cain
Vanilla: momo
Compulsive Quitter: Iconeum

huh?

I dont like the negative utility on me and pops. giving the two of us neighbours is a better fit with more options for later days.

Id be even willing to swallow an icon lynch, although hes not.my prefered option.

Agree. Give Titus the inactive and LUV Macho and I would support that.

Don't give pops Macho. I'd agree with these mods but I'd prefer Titus stay as a neighbour since people want to sort her that way.

[Hidden Happiness]

Also arguing protective roles are useless so Macho doesn't matter is like arguing roles don't matter so everyone should stay vanilla, scum can't block everything. - Shadoweh