Newbie 1943: Crosswords (Game Over)

[cyrus62]

show me why they anit town

[Spangled]

i wii make this know here and now im not okay with a cyan lynch so i will not vote them

Would you take a Cyan lynch over a no lynch though?

[cyrus62]

their is 9 people 5 needed for a lynch my vote doesn't matter today and also like i said case him show me hes not town other wise your openly voteing town to me.

[osuka]

I don't think I was pocketed, personally.

that's exactly what someone who was pocketed would say

So you don't think a single action she made or thing she displayed came off as towny?

this is a misrep of monumental proportions

[osuka]

What are the pros and cons of no lynch D1?

there are no pros for town in a d1 nl

[osuka]

And especially with a claimed PR, there is no reason to let scum have the killing and the night all to themselves.
Alright.
I don't really like a Cyan lynch, but I like it better than many lynches the town seems to be going for right now, and we have 12 hours left.
This is an okay compromise lynch. Not great, and we might lose a valuable player for lategame, but we kind of need to lynch someone, so I will
VOTE: Cyan Talon

this reeks of scum

as of this post, i am 100% okay with lynching spangled

[TemporalLich]

case of cyan:

177/178 felt towny to me

he was passive in early D1, 269 acknowledges that

334 isn't indicative of efforting

353 is relatable

382 doesn't feel like a good reason to SR cyrus imo

567 can either be towny or scummy, but never null

733 is a good point

737 seems a little unfair

814 is a really bad post, I can't discern Cyan's reads and this post is just salt in the wound

Cyan Talon has

still

yet to vote

My SR is modest, but still an SR. Cyan looks towny at a quick glance, but... cyan hasn't given any useful information

[cyrus62]

to be fair its wi bit hard to give info when every time you turn around some one else is replaceing in or out

[cyrus62]

now that you gave your reasons let cyan defend it .

[Spangled]

I don't think I was pocketed, personally.

that's exactly what someone who was pocketed would say

So you don't think a single action she made or thing she displayed came off as towny?

this is a misrep of monumental proportions

Sorry, the so was not really meant to be there. I was trying to concede the point to you (that I could have been pocketed) and ask another question.

[Spangled]

Who would you prefer lynched, osuka?
'Cause we need a lynch.

[Spangled]

Oh, whoops. Other than me, maybe?

[Spangled]

now that you gave your reasons let cyan defend it .

We only have 12 hours though.

[Spangled]

I don't think I was pocketed, personally.

that's exactly what someone who was pocketed would say

So you don't think a single action she made or thing she displayed came off as towny?

this is a misrep of monumental proportions

Maybe so, but I do think you're stepping around and trying to avoid her towniness.

[cyrus62]

cyan is on ora with are 1st game so im pretty sure hes town im willing to lynch sera since they ran up a pr on day1

[cyrus62]

pra

[Cyan Talon]

Back again, and considering the deadline's probably cutting short and I'm about to die...

I'd like to inform you that if I am to believe everything I currently do as of now, there is a Mafia Roleblocker among us. Meanwhile, let me catch up.

[Cyan Talon]

case of cyan:

177/178 felt towny to me

he was passive in early D1, 269 acknowledges that

334 isn't indicative of efforting

353 is relatable

382 doesn't feel like a good reason to SR cyrus imo

567 can either be towny or scummy, but never null

733 is a good point

737 seems a little unfair

814 is a really bad post, I can't discern Cyan's reads and this post is just salt in the wound

Cyan Talon has

still

yet to vote

My SR is modest, but still an SR. Cyan looks towny at a quick glance, but... cyan hasn't given any useful information

I suppose that in response to this, I'll be posting my reads on everyone as of now. Let me know if I miss anything.

cyrus62: He played a fairly strong early game, but lost the gleam as the day progressed. He's currently null-town to me, since if he were scum his partner would likely be controlling his actions or taking advantage of his lost position, and I don't see any indication of either.

Spangled: While I must admit I like this slot by virtue of gut feeling, he rubs off as fairly neutral to me. Nothing obvtown, and nothing obvscum, so I'm leaning on him being town (albeit slightly less that I do in Cyrus). On the other hand, he seems to want to jump on my wagon while saying outright that he doesn't want to, which is odd.

TemporalLich: Early game was more than a little odd, but the claim he made along the way made me have to revisit any suspicions I had against him (of which there weren't much). I will take his claim for what it is for now, but if anything comes up that tells me he's lying I won't hesitate to push further.

Adorable: Null-town. She's not very active, but seems to be honest with her plays. Everyone seems to be townreading her, so I get the feeling someone's trying to pocket her. Who it is, I can't be sure, but pocketing more likely to be directed at town than at scum.

Sera Masumi: This slot is who I'd believe to be town more than anyone else. She was actively catching up with the game and put in a lot of effort into scumhunting; that's generally a more towny thing than scum for obvious reasons. However, as Adorable pointed out, she has gone inactive, which hurts my stance on her a bit.

Osuka/WhemeStar: Bunching these together because they're fairly new in the PL (referring to join time not experience). I feel like people who replace in give out a sort of aura that makes them easier to read as town or scum than players who have been playing the game for longer, and my feeling here is that Osuka is more likely to be town than WhemeStar slightly. The difference is small, though, and I might just be unconsciously biased against WhemeStar for lynching me, so I'd rather refer to both of them as nullreads.

RedFlavor: Blank slate; neither he or his sub have spoken much. Can't read text that isn't existent.

[WhemeStar]

UNVOTE:

[TemporalLich]

TIL cyan's top read is

Sera

[TemporalLich]

VOTE: Sera Masumi

I don't agree with Cyan's read on Sera at all, but Cyan's reads seem to come from a town mindset

[TemporalLich]

but I have a feeling Cyan could be pocketing Sera

[Spangled]

And especially with a claimed PR, there is no reason to let scum have the killing and the night all to themselves.
Alright.
I don't really like a Cyan lynch, but I like it better than many lynches the town seems to be going for right now, and we have 12 hours left.
This is an okay compromise lynch. Not great, and we might lose a valuable player for lategame, but we kind of need to lynch someone, so I will
VOTE: Cyan Talon

this reeks of scum

as of this post, i am 100% okay with lynching spangled

Could you tell me which parts of that post you found scummy? I can see how certain parts of it could be seen as scummy, but I'd like you to tell me what

you

found scummy.

[Spangled]

but I have a feeling Cyan could be pocketing Sera

Cyan is probably about to die and Sera has repped out. I see no pocketing there.

[Spangled]

Spangled: While I must admit I like this slot by virtue of gut feeling, he rubs off as fairly neutral to me. Nothing obvtown, and nothing obvscum, so I'm leaning on him being town (albeit slightly less that I do in Cyrus). On the other hand, he seems to want to jump on my wagon while saying outright that he doesn't want to, which is odd.

I don't want anyone lynched more than you, and we need a lynch (or so I'm lead to believe).
All the rep-outs have made the game really hard to read, and I'm having trouble finding scum.