Mini 2091: The Purge - Game Over!

[Menalque]

Pagetop

[Menalque]

Hectic can be town for now

[Menalque]

I was wondering about you being an alt because your posting style reminded me of something

[Carl Tuckerson]

Top.

I'd rather let either the other half of Serene take the wheel or let kuribo get some badly needed R&R lol. He's not going to be any use to anybody answering questions like he was.

Hectic, you agree Gandalf is mafia then? edfug is currently voting for Gandalf (I believe I misspoke earlier about this).

[Carl Tuckerson]

Lol fucking destroyed. Worst pagetop effort ever.

I'm not seeing what he and edfug are seeing re: Gandalf, which I'm getting hung up on.

[Formerfish]

Fun fact: my only legit warning came from emulating kuribo in a post. Fun times!

You're not doing it right unless you've been banned for calling someone an inbred pigfucking jizz genius

I did not go that far. I just created an imaginary world where the guy I was 1v1ing was really a stephanie myers knockoff.

[Menalque]

Here’s where I’m at:

Delta
Serene
Carl
Oversoul
Gandalf
EP

Hectic
Formerfish

Tet
Icon

TD
Egduf

[Carl Tuckerson]

Welcome to the game Hectic! I think the set up and night stat dissucssion has been useful, but I agree with moving on from that a little bit more.
With that said, here are my town leans so far, in no particular order:

[...]

Gandalf - Because I think he seems pretty geuine so far, and if he was mafia I think he would have been getting more help with vote formating and other questions in the mafia day chat rather than having to ask them here.

[...]

It doesn’t matter if you can’t check the exact maths. If you can provide a single scenario in which it wouldn’t work (no maths is required for this) then you are opposing it for a bad reason.
VOTE: Gandalf

Specifically this progression bothers me about edfug so far. I don't see how Gandalf became less genuine or helpful from the former post to the latter post.

[Hectic]

No, I mean I agreed with her previous

assessment

of Gandalf's posts feeling like genuine newbie!town. I don't agree with her flip on him and her vote. I think it's unlikely Gandalf is newbie€scum who's against Delta's strat because he realises it's

great

for town, and

bad

for him. He's newbie¥town who simply doesn't

understand

it.

[Menalque]

Let’s wagon him then

[Menalque]

Wagon her*

Shit, sorry

[Carl Tuckerson]

No, I mean I agreed with her previous

assessment

of Gandalf's posts feeling like genuine newbie!town. I don't agree with her flip on him and her vote. I think it's unlikely Gandalf is newbie€scum who's against Delta's strat because he realises it's

great

for town, and

bad

for him. He's newbie¥town who simply doesn't

understand

it.

Oh duh right. That's my fault. I got mixed up on the order of the posts. You had said that before edfug's read changed. This checks out, thank you.

And sure what the hell.

VOTE: edfug

[EspressoPatronum]

This isn't the same town!FF I saw in Newbie 1936. I think he's aware of this and he's using the setup as an excuse:

I like that idea. I think we should try it unless someone points out a glaring issue.

Im going to do what i did in ultimate wolf and let you guys decide the best actions to make and ride your coatails to victory.

This is more of a puzzle than a mafia game usually is for me. If you guys think we can find scum by doing that then lets go for it.

VOTE: FormerFish

[Menalque]

Yo EP do me a solid? Go read his iso then read edfug’s iso then hop on this here wagon with us

[Formerfish]

Harvester of Sorrow

[Egduf]

[float=][/float]this progression bothers me about edfug so far. I don't see how Gandalf became less genuine or helpful from the former post to the latter post.

He didn't. I was moving my vote off of Hectic, since it was only there to get him to contribute something. I moved it to Gandalf because I wanted to pressure him to explain his reasoning better as I don't think "I don't like the look of those numbers" is a good reason, or one I would expect from him. (we have played mafia before in person). I mostly liked his answers to my questions though and was genuinely trying to help him with my responces. I'll move my vote to someone else later on when I have an actual scum read or some new questions to ask. I wasn't trying to push for a Gandalf lynch, and if it had got close I would have unvoted.

[Formerfish]

Like w/e I don’t really give a shit if you kill each other at night, but can you give your top scum reads for now so that I have something to go off when your cold, dead corpses are heating up in the morning sunlight

This pings me. Like the not caring if 2 people you are calling town kill each other, and asking who they scum read so you can push their reads tomorrow instead of having to rely on your own scream like scum trying to bolster some bullshit tvt killings and then avoid resposibility for reads and pushes tomorrow. Mane has a high likely hood of being scum here.

[EspressoPatronum]

Yo EP do me a solid? Go read his iso then read edfug’s iso then hop on this here wagon with us

Fair. It's mostly a rehash of Delta's arguments. I'm not sure I buy the explanation at 315 as the Gandalf vote being for pressure.

Interesting note - why did Oversoul dislike Gandalf's entrance but not mention edfug? I hate the, 'newb!scum address the thread in entry' theory fwiw, but he didn't apply it to both people.

I'm happy to swap over to edfug, but we really need to keep an eye on FF. From what I've seen, he doesn't coast as town.

[Menalque]

I’m kinda thinking FF is gonna town it up as time goes on, if he doesn’t I’ll get behind it

But see his last post for him actually doing stuff

[Oversoul]

Edfug doesn’t seem like a newb to me :shrug:

[Egduf]

Edfug doesn’t seem like a newb to me :shrug:

I'm new to the website, not new to forum mafia.

[Menalque]

Good point: Oversoul, why did you dislike gandalf’s entrance?

[Formerfish]

This isn't the same town!FF I saw in Newbie 1936. I think he's aware of this and he's using the setup as an excuse:

I like that idea. I think we should try it unless someone points out a glaring issue.

Im going to do what i did in ultimate wolf and let you guys decide the best actions to make and ride your coatails to victory.

This is more of a puzzle than a mafia game usually is for me. If you guys think we can find scum by doing that then lets go for it.

VOTE: FormerFish

This is nothing like a newbie game? Kuribo says he doesnt like doing math in mafia games and he gets a pass. I say that I'm going to let the math nerds work their shit out if it means we get a better chance of winning.

I am going to be poking and prodding people on the sidelines and questioning and playing devils advocate to the ones planning the solve here.

What is different exactly?

[Menalque]

What’s your experience like then egduf?

[Egduf]

I play a lot of mafia in real life. A lot. I've played two forum games elsewhere, and am currently in another one here.