Newbie 1951 (Day 4)

[Farkran]

if he flips town i think menalque

if he flips scum i think selynee

Agreed, almost best possible answer from town!skit. Still scares me but analysis is top quality.

(Out of game: you have my respect skitter, you are a very good player regardless of faction)

[Farkran]

i dont think anyone would mind if i gave

intent to hammer creeper

claim and defend urself ty

I don't mind.

[Selynee]

I looked back over emps' push on Fark; I think it comes from town. The tone is right and the things he points out are mostly reasonable things to point out.

The way skitter keeps defending Fark largely on the basis of him coming from a different site and being used to a different style of play, etc., gives me bad vibes.

I'm still kind of leaning town on teacher, I think? His reasoning is easier to follow than Fark's at any rate, but part of me is a little uncertain whether scum!teacher would use this argument to his advantage, knowing he'd be more capable of expressing himself reasonably.

Umm....I mean I agree with read on emps, though I wouldn't look only on Fark, but reads on others as well. If Fark town- there would be pretty easy to appear more reasonable (PS: I mean language differences and maybe gamestyle )

The same for teacher.

[Selynee]

wait why sely? is creeper/mena just not a thing?

Doubt it, Menalque was the first one to scumread the first post EC made. Doubt he would have made it if he knew his partner was so new.

[Farkran]

wait why sely? is creeper/mena just not a thing?

Would you go at mena if creeper flips scum?

Why not sushi though?

[skitter30]

wait why sely? is creeper/mena just not a thing?

I think sely has p bad associatives with them

[Selynee]

[quote="I

Agreed, almost best possible answer from town!skit. Still scares me but analysis is top quality.

[/quote]

Yeah, top quality. Actually, care to walk me through it? Cuz I've seen skitter's reasons, though I obviously disagree with me-scum, but not from you.

[skitter30]

if he flips town i think menalque

if he flips scum i think selynee

Agreed, almost best possible answer from town!skit. Still scares me but analysis is top quality.

(Out of game: you have my respect skitter, you are a very good player regardless of faction)

Y does it scare u ?

[skitter30]

[quote="I

Agreed, almost best possible answer from town!skit. Still scares me but analysis is top quality.

Yeah, top quality. Actually, care to walk me through it? Cuz I've seen skitter's reasons, though I obviously disagree with me-scum, but not from you.[/quote]

Also why do u think that?

[Menalque]

Finally some good content from Mena. Sushi, on the other hand, actually isn't great.

Fine

Just loudly repeating that i still think menalque is scum

VOTE: epic

Oh, I agree. I just think creeper is better for today.

err

qué?

[Menalque]

But idk how to respond to that thought: I thought she was p towny the first game we played and she was town, but pfup just finished and I thought she was p towny when she was scum

So idk what conclusion to draw from thinking she’s p scummy this game

yo skitt, what conclusion should I be drawing from the fact that I am lowkey scum reading you this game?

[skitter30]

The fact that you pretty clearly dont know how to read me

[Menalque]

hmm, but I also thought I didn't know how to read FL

and then it turned out I did

[Farkran]

if he flips town i think menalque

if he flips scum i think selynee

Agreed, almost best possible answer from town!skit. Still scares me but analysis is top quality.

(Out of game: you have my respect skitter, you are a very good player regardless of faction)

Y does it scare u ?

Because i can

almost

see scum!skitt talking like that IF creeper flips town, very much possibly in team with selynee. Not my current read though.

[Farkran]

Failed syntax

[Menalque]

UNVOTE:

I wanna think more about scum!skitt

[Menalque]

and this wagon is kinda pinging me for reasons I can't talk about

[Farkran]

UNVOTE:

I wanna think more about scum!skitt

Dude i believe i know what you're talking about but this is not a good choice

Get back on the wagon

[Menalque]

no longer convinced I want creeper over skitt today

[Menalque]

I find it rly weird that she's SRing me and setting me up in the case of a creeper town!flip

esp considering that skitt knows I'm hard to mislynch as town

[Menalque]

Sring me but not pushing me*

[skitter30]

Yes i agree that sitting on your wagon for like 3 irl days and trying yo get other people to vote with me is 'scumreading you without pushing you' , totally

[skitter30]

Is menalque really not a thing that we can do today or ... ?

[Menalque]

oh, just looking at my ISO to find where I declared intent: I'd forgotten that I was calling fark/emps as a possible pairing. So that means I've got to Farkran as possible scum in two pairings, through two more-or-less separate reads

sorry so was it serious or not ?

skitt is a good enough player to know that even if it wasn't serious then I'd want it to look serious or it'd be worthless

acting like this is just trying to paint me as scummy

I think I would be townleaning me based on my play so far

ehhhh this is kinda icky

this is NAI

I find it weird that you’re as keen for this wagon as you are skitt

because i think you've been trying to get in a lynch on lynch-bait-y town

and yeah the fact that the game stalled when you got wagoned is ... slightly concerning

btw the townread i had on selynee has all in all evaporated

surely the definition of Lynch-baity town is that they do things that seem justifiable for lynching

why is this scummy rather than me just disagreeing with you about whether the tells are genuinely scummy vs town being scummy?

I've been more reticent on fark than I think I might have been and I think you know why

because i'm wary of people repeatedly subtly pushing wagons on someone who i believe is town but is playing in a way that makes them imminently lynchable

this is the thing that makes me most thing creeper could actually be town getting pushed by skitt. she's been doing this on creeper by throwing out light SRs on the slot all day but not pushing there at all. there's

just

enough to justify a hop on if the wagon picks up traction, and lo and behold, when it does she does

I think a lot of people are overlooking Selynee and Sushi Martyr. I see good questions from them both, feels like town but could easily be made up.

big oof

we can lynch this too, i think

let me check the vc

like, I think the move to hop on here is super scummy. why not try to move the lynch if you don't like it? why if you SR me do you hop onto the wagon I was just starting to get on board with?

ehhh that wagon is kinda icky; both of the people i'm scumreading are on it rn

still happy wiht my vote i think

don't think her acknowledging it makes it a towny move. also "I'm happy with my vote" to be v shortly followed by a change

vote mena with me!

half heartedly pushing me

prob justifies a hop to me "menalque wasn't really going anywhere" for example, and she's setting up the "if creeper!green then menalque!scum" narrative. and getting me mislynched means she can NK teacher/NMSA if they're town meaning she can bring a bunch of scummy slots to LYLO (like, is anyone really gonna SR it if she was to completely flip round her read on fark? I doubt it)

Fine

Just loudly repeating that i still think menalque is scum

VOTE: epic

keeping pushing the narrative of me!scum to be consistent and avoiding pushing me.

I believe skitt when she says she doesn't really push as scum. what's she doing her? avoiding pushing, but building up narratives to set the tone for D2

[NotMySpamAccount]

UNVOTE:

I wanna think more about scum!skitt

get back on the wagon or there'll be a new one on you. there is no good reason not to be on creeper right now. he's the most likely player to be scum, and if by chance he happens to be town, we've gotten rid of a slot that wasn't giving us anythig anyway. I'm fine with you thinking about scum!skit, but you're not getting that lynch today without an insane scumslip.