Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Day One Wagon]

Lurking and pretending to not understand what's going on while claiming not to read thread isn't beyond scum behavior and I have 0 experience with Croag to say that something like that is beyond her scum range

how about i tell you that

i actually dont understand the thing with perry

and how about i tell you that

i actually havent read the entire thread

isn't it more plausible that someone who has been absent for a lot of the game actually hasnt had the time to read 70+ pages lol

How about I ask you "Why should I trust you?" I'm not saying you're scum, I'm saying I'm not clearing you for your claim to not understand case and claim that you haven't read thread, you're null in my book

[Gorkington]

whatever ill own the egg on my face if pelican is town.

is he l-2 right now?

will give him a chance to drop last will and testament before voting in case i counted votes wrong.

[Chandra Nalaar]

VOTE: Chandra

After some consideration, I feel like lynching this

...That's all you got?

I placed my vote and expressed my wish to lynch you, do I have to do something more? Ah, yes, I was thinking, if I want to hear more of your complaining going forward, but decided against it and hence we are here

i've composed several replies to this but they all still leave me feeling frustrated.

are you voting for scum this game, or people who annoy you? if the former, i want an explanation.

[Chandra Nalaar]

(and if the latter, i want to lynch you.)

[Chandra Nalaar]

i don't take being disliked well and that's another reason this account is a terrible idea

[Gorkington]

basically we both are dummies for having alts like this

[Day One Wagon]

VOTE: Chandra

After some consideration, I feel like lynching this

...That's all you got?

I placed my vote and expressed my wish to lynch you, do I have to do something more? Ah, yes, I was thinking, if I want to hear more of your complaining going forward, but decided against it and hence we are here

i've composed several replies to this but they all still leave me feeling frustrated.

are you voting for scum this game, or people who annoy you? if the former, i want an explanation.

I'm not petty enough to vote people that annoy me, as for voting scum, well, I wasn't informed who is scum and who isn't, so that's not it either

I was thinking who I want lynch after I saw that people changed their mind and didn't hammered Pelli (I'm not touching that 50/50 stinking pile Pelli vs FL) and your name came to my mind. I see you complaining how no one listens to you, you shot down my attempts to spark some discussions, you complain that you tired, yet I can't really remember what have you done, ofc outside of defending Pops, who is free real estate now. Also I took into consideration fact that were quite a few other people that expressed scumread on you, so chances to achieve your lynch are greater than trying to build wagon on someone with less attention

[Day One Wagon]

basically we both are dummies for having alts like this

Will we see ever again "The Wall"

[Gorkington]

bleh it was so much effort. i couldnt even do it for one game

[Day One Wagon]

But it had so nice gimmick

[Chandra Nalaar]

VOTE: Chandra

After some consideration, I feel like lynching this

...That's all you got?

I placed my vote and expressed my wish to lynch you, do I have to do something more? Ah, yes, I was thinking, if I want to hear more of your complaining going forward, but decided against it and hence we are here

i've composed several replies to this but they all still leave me feeling frustrated.

are you voting for scum this game, or people who annoy you? if the former, i want an explanation.

I'm not petty enough to vote people that annoy me, as for voting scum, well, I wasn't informed who is scum and who isn't, so that's not it either

I was thinking who I want lynch after I saw that people changed their mind and didn't hammered Pelli (I'm not touching that 50/50 stinking pile Pelli vs FL) and your name came to my mind. I see you complaining how no one listens to you, you shot down my attempts to spark some discussions, you complain that you tired, yet I can't really remember what have you done, ofc outside of defending Pops, who is free real estate now. Also I took into consideration fact that were quite a few other people that expressed scumread on you, so chances to achieve your lynch are greater than trying to build wagon on someone with less attention

apparently i'm memorable enough to be lynchworthy and not memorable enough to be memorable, cool. sounds like the only thing you remember me doing is town, though, so that's a bit strange eh? maybe you should you that good ole iso function.

love the herd mentality too that's great! why try to blaze a new path!

[Kagami]

(I'm not touching that 50/50 stinking pile Pelli vs FL)

On what planet is this a 50/50?

[Chandra Nalaar]

i thought i was going to like this player list. :c

[kuribo]

(I'm not touching that 50/50 stinking pile Pelli vs FL)

On what planet is this a 50/50?

On what planet does someone get to say "we have counterclaiming vigs but I refuse to have an opinion"

[kuribo]

i thought i was going to like this player list. :c

Same

[Chandra Nalaar]

it feels like half this game is a circlejerk of people who know each other and won't lynch each other at the start ever because they all think they're meta experts. like, when i go after ofhrz, someone will pipe up and say "this player is always scummy, so you can't lynch them ever" and that makes me want to kill myself instead of doing it

[Kagami]

It's not even a counterclaim, kuribo.

In a vaccuum I'd be happy to believe there are two town vigs here, and Perry apparently already knew FL was probably vig.

[Chandra Nalaar]

i thought i was going to like this player list. :c

Same

at least you probably get to die night 1 and abandon me to this shit

[kuribo]

it feels like half this game is a circlejerk of people who know each other and won't lynch each other at the start ever because they all think they're meta experts. like, when i go after ofhrz, someone will pipe up and say "this player is always scummy, so you can't lynch them ever" and that makes me want to kill myself instead of doing it

That's exactly how I feel

Mafia has changed too much over the years, fuck this new shit

[Day One Wagon]

(I'm not touching that 50/50 stinking pile Pelli vs FL)

On what planet is this a 50/50?

Sorry, but only my opinion is right, so if I say it's 50/50, it is 50/50

[kuribo]

It's not even a counterclaim, kuribo.

In a vaccuum I'd be happy to believe there are two town vigs here, and Perry apparently already knew FL was probably vig.

I don't live in a vacuum though, and I didn't like Perry's reaction: "I'm not voting FL because I can shoot instead"


It's like, without knowing if there's a roleblocker or an X or a Y?

[Kagami]

I certainly agree that the notion of "I can secretly inform select other players of my role via meta" feels pretty contrary to how the game is supposed to be played.

I don't care too much about the other meta nonsense; I think we're currently on a pretty good track anyway?

p-edit: I agree! Outside of a vacuum, perry is probably scum, and I can't even imagine how you arrive at this as a "50/50" sort of thing.

[kuribo]

i thought i was going to like this player list. :c

Same

at least you probably get to die night 1 and abandon me to this shit

Nope the FL / Perry thing makes that a tossup now but it's okay because after nearly 80 pages we seem to be content to run as many wagons as possible so the scum can collect full claims


I 100% seriously got halfway through typing up my replace-out PM and final reads post last night between that bullshit with Gork and then Bingle


I'm too old for this shit. Mafia used to be fun

Well not really

But it used to be more fun than miserable


This game is a Fucking slog and I'm very much nearing the point where I hate every single person here on a very personal level

[Day One Wagon]

apparently i'm memorable enough to be lynchworthy and not memorable enough to be memorable, cool. sounds like the only thing you remember me doing is town, though, so that's a bit strange eh? maybe you should you that good ole iso function.

love the herd mentality too that's great! why try to blaze a new path!

Herd mentality you say? But you yourself complained that mafia is popularity contest. I have tried to push my scumreads that no one cared in the past, it went as you can expect - no one gave a shit, so, I'm sorry that I'm going after my scumread that has some potential to get lynched

P-Edit: If Perry is so obv scum, why he still alive? I expected to find this thread locked in morning, but instead I found 10 new pages that I didn't even bothered to read after previous 20 of "you're scum" "no u" between Perry and FL. "Perry messed up with his claim" I see as a scumslip, yet I was told not to go against spirit of the game, when I tried to dig in to this, FL has pretty rich history of fake claiming, so that's too. I don't know who's saying truth, who's lying, I don't even want to touch this any more

[Kagami]

Come now, kuribo... we're looking at a lynch in 6 RL days, and I feel like the game is in a pretty good place?

Yes, the meta stuff and secret alts who pretend they're not secret (I guess new players think themselves famous?) are pretty annoying, but whatever.

I think we all have a pretty long, and mostly well synced townie brownie list at this point.