Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[popsofctown]

Pops your reads feel really easy

Sometimes the reads are easy, whoever shot Fishmonger obviously agrees that one was easy

[PenguinPower]

I mean - I've played with him for years and I don't know how to.

Why the specification of this game?

Who did you replace btw?

[chennisden]

I am gorkington

[popsofctown]

Which means he's town

[PenguinPower]

ok - town

[PenguinPower]

wow - don't need you putting words in my head there.

[chennisden]

I mean - I've played with him for years and I don't know how to.

Why the specification of this game?

Who did you replace btw?

Specification of this game because i dont remember my read accuracy on him way back when. I mostly remember he was the guy who stopped my mislynch around 70 times which I am grateful for

[chennisden]

Pops your reads feel really easy

Sometimes the reads are easy, whoever shot Fishmonger obviously agrees that one was easy

By easy I mean easy for you to make pops

Convenient

[chennisden]

I think there's scum in pops/bingle

[PenguinPower]

Both or one?

[ofrhz]

Ofhrz was who scum was trying to lynch to allow for Pelican/Myself to shoot at each other

I'm going to tell you a story:

ofrhz, D1L, chen (formerly Gork) and I are in a PT. We are all 1-shot Doctors of

unknown sanities

. One of us is a CPR Doctor (kills the target if not attacked). One is Naive (does absolutely nothing). One is Paranoid (JK) and one is Normal Sane. We just duno which is which, so we're all semi-useless.

I suggested we all target someone in the unkillable PT, and thus become all unkillable ourselves. We only needed ONE of Vecna/Marquis to stay caffeine-free and we would proceed to lynch from outside our "new" hood until everyone else is either dead or confirmed, then we lynch Bingle (if he doesn't scum claim earlier by using his voting powers).

Although all 3 were basically against the idea and wanted to act as a caffeine buffer; it was ofrhz' arguments that smelled the most (or at all, really). The other two were trying to understand and argue with logic. ofrhz wasn't even reading the thread properly and kept asking really silly questions in an attempt to shoot down the idea (which I KNOW would have taken scum by surprise, and the only weakness would have been if BOTH Marquis & Vecna have acted on N1).

Anyway, ofrhz' arguments included (but weren't limited to) asking if we even knew we would get the reflexice RB modifier if we joined that PT... TWICE. Like it wasn't enough that it was mention in this thread on D1, and it wasn't enough D1L did answer her in the very next post, so she had to ask the same question 80 posts later after having tried several other arguments.

I'll let both D1L & chenn report what else happened in the PT, but suffice it to say

if there is scum in our PT

I'm betting the game it is ofrhz

Wow this is some A+ cherrypicking

JJD and I both came into the night scumreading each other. After some 1v1ing, I said I was starting to be unsure about JJD being scum. And then later JJD proposed that if all four of us in the doc hood townread each other, we should act as a masonry and target the reflexive RB hood to be NK immune.

I said that didn't make sense because none of us were likely NK targets, so it just seemed like a waste of caffeine, and we didn't even all townread each other anyway.

Anyway there wasn't that much interest in JJD's plan from anyone else atp

Later JJD said that he would target one of the reflexive RBs to get into their hood just to make us angry

I said repeatedly that JJD's justification (which is in the quoted post) for getting into the hood seemed bad and I didn't understand how it would benefit town

It seemed scummy because if JJD got into the hood, he would be immune to invest and vig shots so there's more scum motivation than town motivation to get into the reflexive RB hood imo

Yes I thought him submitting a night action was bad so I repeatedly tried to get him to not do it. I spent a lot of time trying to engage him, but you wouldn't have guessed in his version of events.

[ofrhz]

VOTE: orfhz. JJD has started to seem more and more townie

mate

[Marquis]

I really don't think Bingle is scum anymore.

I'd very much like to lunch o-guy, pls.
VOTE: ojrvz

[Bingle]

Well ok JJD is town that's not a bad read

Nah, it's pretty bad.

[ofrhz]

Bingle/Marquis/Vecna, did you guys get a new resident?

The mod hasn't informed me of any.

The neighborhood was pretty quiet last night. Vec was on vacation.

I don't understand, JJD did you end up not targeting a member of the hood?

[ofrhz]

I really don't think Bingle is scum anymore.

I'd very much like to lunch o-guy, pls.
VOTE: ojrvz

Why?

[Bingle]

I'm not going into it here

Translates as "It's anti town to discuss here".

[ofrhz]

JJD is town

WHY

[Marquis]

Town:

Marquis
Vecna
Bingle
Chandra
Gork/chennis
Day One Lynch

pops - maybe?
Pine - maybe?
Flavor - maybe?


Unsorted: ohfvz, Penguin, Croag, Kagami, JJD

[Bingle]

not properly emulating town!Bingle

Is there anything I've ever done that makes you think I'm incapable of being towny as scum?

[Marquis]

I really don't think Bingle is scum anymore.

I'd very much like to lunch o-guy, pls.
VOTE: ojrvz

Why?

I think you're flying under the radar as scum and ineffectual if town

[PenguinPower]

Wow

Marquis is scum. Or just really bad.

Why don't you have a stance on me?

[PenguinPower]

Don't disagree with orfhz btw

[Marquis]

I'd also like to look into Penguin as I can't recall any real stances of his but I have 0 experience playing with him - unsure if this is his typical activity or posting style. It's throwing me off

[PenguinPower]

I have 0 experience playing with him

You want to keep pushing this an accurate statement?