Newbie 1953 | Zooborns IV | Game Over

[skitter30]

also which scumgame did u read ?

[skitter30]

@Chemist
How do you feel about Mr Oobsy? Do you think he is scum or town?

really really town but i disagree with just about everything he's been doing

[skitter30]

[quote="In post 421, NorwegianboyEE"][/quote]

VOTE: norwegian

[skitter30]

Time to start consolidating wagons folks. I prefer Leocosticte, would settle for Oobsy, and oppose chemist.

no, oobsy is town
i could probably compromise on leu but would prefer norwegian or maybe farren rn

[skitter30]

I believe finding out whether the Semi-Experienced players are genuine is our biggest priority right now. I don't want them taking control of the game as scum players, that's a big worry of mine. Therefore based on that logic, i believe voting Chemist is the best choice out of everyone. Who's with me?

VOTE: Chemist1422

this is scummy ^^^

[NorwegianboyEE]

basically i still don't like his rvs post but like he hasn't done much else ai and i think people are scummier and being suspicious of him became like a ~popular~ opinion so i'm wondering if scum were piling on when it was popular

Such a bad argument. Your only defense of Chemist is that people are voting him because he seems suspicious... That’s why you think he’s town? Seriously?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Really feeling a Skitter30/Chemist1422 combo right now.

[Plotinus]

official vote count 1.15

baby white cheeked gibbon

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

Chemist1422

(2): Jamelia, NorwegianboyEE

Jamelia

(2): Dyrenz, Mr Oobsy

Leucosticte

(2): Micc, Farren

NorwegianboyEE

(2): Chemist1422, skitter30

Farren

(1): Leucosticte

Not Voting

(0):

None.

Deadline:

(expired on 2019-09-04 23:00:00).

Mod notes:

[/area]

[NorwegianboyEE]

(Towniest)

Dyrenz
Leucosticte
Farren
Micc
Jamelia
Mr Oobsy
skitter30
Chemist1422

(Scummiest)

[Farren]

why is micc a townread ?

I like how he's answered my questions.

The case on Dyrenz in particular, especially post 297 - yes, given what we know now the conclusion of the case was wrong, but the evidence itself was solid despite that.

[Farren]

conclusion about skitter based on games I read: not going to be productive to continue reading. I'm seeing both town and scum parallels, comparing against three town games and one scum game. More town than scum, but I read more town games than scum games, because duh.

skitter: what if anything has caused your read on Chemist to change since post 131 ?

i've been told i'm hard to read :p

basically i still don't like his rvs post but like he hasn't done much else ai and i think people are scummier and being suspicious of him became like a ~popular~ opinion so i'm wondering if scum were piling on when it was popular

Right after the RVS vote:

Micc, Leucosticte, skitter vote Chemist, in that order. You put Chemist at L-2; then Leucosticte dropped off the wagon; then Norwegianboy put Chemist back at L-2.

So that theory would put either Norwegianboy or yourself as the scum. From your POV, not you, ergo Norwegianboy. And you're voting Norwegianboy now, so that's consistent.

[Farren]

also which scumgame did u read ?

"911: what's your emergency?" - you, Tris, and Baezu as the scumteam.

[Farren]

Heading to bed; will address anything else after I wake up tomorrow.

[Plotinus]

About last night's discussion, I think we should try to avoid outside influences, to the best of our abilities. We can't help what we stumble on of course, but it is best to base our arguments on how people are behaving in this thread.

2. Do not bring outside influences into the game - this includes threats, bribes, wagers, promises, "trust tells", alliances, etc. Using

knowledge

from previous games is perfectly acceptable, but try not to carry grudges from one game to another.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I wouldn't trust the meta. Might just be scumplayers doing their tricks to fool us into a hard townread.

[Micc]

Skitter continuing to scumread Farren is scummy to me.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I assumed Skitter30 was white knighting chemist, but her reasons for defending Chemist don’t seem genuine.

[skitter30]

basically i still don't like his rvs post but like he hasn't done much else ai and i think people are scummier and being suspicious of him became like a ~popular~ opinion so i'm wondering if scum were piling on when it was popular

Such a bad argument. Your only defense of Chemist is that people are voting him because he seems suspicious... That’s why you think he’s town? Seriously?

I didnt say i thought he was town

I'm saying it makes me hesitant to vote there, which is not at all the same thing

[skitter30]

Really feeling a Skitter30/Chemist1422 combo right now.

Incidentally the two people who are voting you, got it

The whole scumteam piles on you because ...

[skitter30]

also which scumgame did u read ?

"911: what's your emergency?" - you, Tris, and Baezu as the scumteam.

Ah ok

Not sure how well that represents my scumgame as a whole

[skitter30]

Skitter continuing to scumread Farren is scummy to me.

Do tell
How are u reading norwegian?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Really feeling a Skitter30/Chemist1422 combo right now.

Incidentally the two people who are voting you, got it

The whole scumteam piles on you because ...

I read someone say on a different mafia thread (Or maybe it was this one, i can't remember) that it's been trendy lately for the mafia team to pile up their votes on one user because "There's no way mafia would do that!!"
So why not?

[skitter30]

A) it's p uncommon for scum to do that, speaking from experience
B) why do they pile on *you* in particular when there are several other wagons they could pile on that would incidentally be closer to getting hammered with their votes
C) you need a stronger reason for why scum would be doing yhis than just 'why not'. Scum usually do things for a reason and it's usually more than just 'why not lol'

[skitter30]

(Towniest)

Dyrenz
Leucosticte
Farren
Micc
Jamelia
Mr Oobsy
skitter30
Chemist1422

(Scummiest)

I have like two townreads that i feel good about ...includng the guy who claimed pr, sigh

[NorwegianboyEE]

@Skitter30
Well i'm not going to suspect myself.

So ignoring me, who do you think is the most suspicious?