Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Bingle]

Not a good look for Kagami/Croag either, tbh.

Hard veto on lynching out of your neighborhood is really sexy when 2/3 of the remaining scum are in it.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Yeah please don't hammer before I take another look at the Pine wagon

It was Vecna (2 cites), Marquis and I

[chennisden]

Ok

Um

[chennisden]

I could be wrong on Marquis town tbh

[chennisden]

Someone in Chandra's hood should claim all information that is publicly known in their hood

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Also before I forget, to post the last update looks like this

Alright, here's the deal:

I want each and every player here to state whether they would be willing to vote me today or not.

I'll keep the list public for ease:


[Y]ofrhz
[N]PenguinPower
[Y]Croag
[Y]Pine
[?]Kagami
[Y]Bingle
[N]Day One Lynch
[Y]Vecna
[N]chennisden
[Y]Marquis
[N]popsofctown
[Y]Chandra Nalaar
[N]Flavor Leaf

[chennisden]

Uh that's completely pointless today because everyone's gonna say no because well chandra slipped

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Someone in Chandra's hood should claim all information that is publicly known in their hood

^^ I second that notion

P-edit: Tomorrow then.. or the day after. I'm just keeping a record for "when it does count".

[PenguinPower]

Will do. Gotta meet with the roofer real quick - be back in about 30min.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Whoever vigged Fish should join us tonight.

I thought you were against someone infiltrating your masonry.

[ofrhz]

Has anyone (Bingle) posted about the optimal use of the doc hood actions?

[chennisden]

Optimal use? FUCKING DONT

[chennisden]

That is my Cliffnotes on what to do as a 1-shot doc (or as any uncaffenated PR)

[popsofctown]

I drew an diagram of the gamestate, a gravestone means that player is dead, an upside down cross means they are scummy and a cross with a halo means they are towny.

I drew it like an hour ago so i had to cross out Chandra's cross and redraw.

This picture should be incredibly helpful to everyone in solving the game.

I dedicate it to Pine.

Spoiler: Diagram

[chennisden]

I'm fucking hysterical pops

[chennisden]

And it's binder paper too

[ofrhz]

I’m neither scum nor a satanist

The ice cream is cute though

[Bingle]

Has anyone (Bingle) posted about the optimal use of the doc hood actions?

Kinda. Exactly one of you should have targeted kuribo last night, because he was the only viable scumkill and 3/4 of you would have saved his life.

For tonight? I haven't but it's kinda simple.

One of you should be elected to choose whether to act (by the group). That one of you should then decide whether to act or not to act individually without claiming it in the hood. The rest should holster.

That means that if one scum has infiltrated your hood there is a 50% chance of there being no possible town interference with their kill (Naive doc or Scum Doc). If there is no scum infiltration, there is a chance of a protection going through that will make them think twice about targeting an obvious NK choice (Pine/FL) and a chance that there is no additional caffeine. If two scum have infiltrated your hood then the hood is useless, both from a caffeine buffer standpoint and from a power role standpoint.

I'll have thoughts in my PT about clearing your hoodmates mechanically, but they're antitown to share with potential scum in your hood, so...

[Bingle]

I thought you were against someone infiltrating your masonry.

I am against a rando infiltrating our hood. I am 100% for a town-by-having-vigged scum player joining us.

If we get two people who join us, then it's a 1v1.

Also, there's a decent chance that FL is the vig, in which case he joins us and the scum can't kill him tonight. (I checked with FG when this occurred to me, the joining of our neighborhood would apply before the scumkill.)

[chennisden]

the NK is quite obvious but ok

[Bingle]

I mean... It’s probably Pine would be my guess. Scum can’t kill the vig from yesterday now. Scum can’t kill any of the three of us. Scum can kill Pine, unless the randomly chosen doc who has a choice of whether to act acts and saves him. Scum might be afraid enough of the chance of this happening to shoot elsewhere, which would be great for us.

[popsofctown]

I mean... It’s probably Pine would be my guess. Scum can’t kill the vig from yesterday now. Scum can’t kill any of the three of us. Scum can kill Pine, unless the randomly chosen doc who has a choice of whether to act acts and saves him. Scum might be afraid enough of the chance of this happening to shoot elsewhere, which would be great for us.

Is this kind of discussion actually better cards-on-the-table instead of close-to-the-vest with the doctor WIFOM?

[Bingle]

I mean... worst case scenario scum listen to me and don’t kill pine. Which is the goal.

Best case scenario scum try to kill pine anyway and it’s blocked.

Making scum double guess themselves and get paranoid over the nk is how you get shitty nightkills in lynchbait. “But what if croag is secretly a lie detector and not killing her will cost is the game?”

And yes, I’m a rolecop, I targeted croag and she’s a lie detector. Shoot croag, scumteam, shoot croag.

[PenguinPower]

Will do. Gotta meet with the roofer real quick - be back in about 30min.

That took longer than I thought for sad reasons...

Anyway...we're a neighborhood of Cops of unknown sanity (1 Sane Cop, 1 Insane Cop, 1 Paranoid Cop, and 1 Naive Cop). Kagami is a fox, Chandra is a dog, Craog is a dog, and I'm a penguin. Jenny Otter is a hussy.

[PenguinPower]

Gotta jet for a bit again to deal with this stuff.