Alisae V Pine: Trees Apparently Make Good Treestumps

[Ankamius]

chennis my boy instead of shading me why don't you talk about it in a little more depth?

Isn't chennis one of the masons? This looks like a bad post if so. Also yeah I'm not pushing much because I'm behind, way to go after an easy target
VOTE: Iconeum

Where the hell did you get that from and why would you out it

[Gamma Emerald]

I saw it from a mastina post

[Gamma Emerald]

And like if I'm wrong then whatever but it looks pretty bad from Iconeum, plus going after me like that is bad too

[Ankamius]

I'm too tired for this bye

[Iconeum]

chennis my boy instead of shading me why don't you talk about it in a little more depth?

Isn't chennis one of the masons? This looks like a bad post if so. Also yeah I'm not pushing much because I'm behind, way to go after an easy target
VOTE: Iconeum

they claimed?

also easy target? did you read my early case on him?

[Iconeum]

And like if I'm wrong then whatever but it looks pretty bad from Iconeum, plus going after me like that is bad too

i'm here to talk about why you think it's bad

but same as with chennis, both of you are scumreading me right after I post a scumread on you guys so ehhh

[Iconeum]

come at me if you think i'm making up cases against you

but don't both of you just stand there calling my cases on you bad and then scumreading me for it

[the worst]

I'm also confused how people glossed over menalque basically throwing my scumread of him under the "she didn't see the town thought process and that makes her scum" when his 'town thought process' was basically "chickadee did the same thing I did except she's scum for it because pine gave her an easy bargain and she accepted it" and completely ignored that if you suddenly show up out of nowhere and do exactly what you just criticize someone else for, it looks sketchy and hypocritical

This is the only thing in Melon's ISO which has piqued my interest at all so far.

[Menalque]

pls spell my name right

[Menalque]

I'm also confused how people glossed over menalque basically throwing my scumread of him under the "she didn't see the town thought process and that makes her scum" when his 'town thought process' was basically "chickadee did the same thing I did except she's scum for it because pine gave her an easy bargain and she accepted it" and completely ignored that if you suddenly show up out of nowhere and do exactly what you just criticize someone else for, it looks sketchy and hypocritical

No, it’s distinctly different because one was unprompted while the second was a reactive process prompted by the first

And while I thought it was weird I wasn’t really SRing you for it until I explained it and you started being wilfully dense about it

[Pink Ball]

Five hundred twenty-five thousand six hundred posts
Five hundred twenty-five thousand moments so dear
Five hundred twenty-five thousand six hundred posts
How do you measure, measure a game?

In scumreads, in towntells
In claimings, in bussing partners
In lynches, in memes
In hammers, in fights

In five hundred twenty-five thousand six hundred posts
How do you measure a mafiascum game

How about love?

[Iconeum]

Nice stuff, but got anything usefull to add there, Pinky?

[Ankamius]

No, it’s distinctly different because one was unprompted while the second was a reactive process prompted by the first

Chickadee also threw it out there while barely caring what people thought about her, and the way she did it made her a huge easy target

You jumped on it and got really defensive when you got any backlash from it

And again, you're telling me that I should be townreading your process when you've not only did exactly what you were criticizing Chickadee for, but while having done nothing else in the meantime except give an empty reads list with no context to any of your reads except those directly involved in this

I don't buy it sorry

[Menalque]

I have lots of love for you PB

Shall we get team love and wholesomeness back together for a second round of scumbusting?

[Menalque]

Why does that make chickadee town? It could make her town but it could just as easily make her scum if she knows people will think that doing something to make her an easy target makes her towny for not caring about it

Again, I didn’t do exactly what she did because you’re eliminating any context, which is a misrep and it’s why I SR you. Either you’re intentionally ignoring context which is scummy, or you’re being dumb town. Atm I think scum is more likely because I explained my thought process and you barely even considered it. By your own logic, if making yourself open to being a target is towny, you should at least be having major doubts about me. But you’re behaving weirdly certain for D1.

[Gamma Emerald]

chennis my boy instead of shading me why don't you talk about it in a little more depth?

Isn't chennis one of the masons? This looks like a bad post if so. Also yeah I'm not pushing much because I'm behind, way to go after an easy target
VOTE: Iconeum

they claimed?

also easy target? did you read my early case on him?

I mean that I'm an easy target because I'm behind

[Ankamius]

No, it's very different. You're the one ignoring context.

Chickadee went about it not caring at all about the consequences about how she comes off, even after she got backlash for it.

You, on the other hand, tried to pass off BS and when I discounted it, turned it into a scumread on me.

I've mentioned multiple times now that I'm scumreading your entire play this game and you're hardfocusing on this one point like it destroys my entire argument when I even said before that it's not scummy without the rest of your play without being present.

The way you're arguing this isn't helping.

[Ankamius]

I've mentioned multiple times now that I'm scumreading your entire play this game and you're hardfocusing on this one point like it destroys my entire argument when I even said before that it's not scummy without the rest of your play being present.

Deleted an erroneous word

[Gamma Emerald]

come at me if you think i'm making up cases against you

but don't both of you just stand there calling my cases on you bad and then scumreading me for it

And like my problem is you picked a point that was true, but had no real scum motivation if you actually bothered to think about it, which feels like not really trying because you don't need to

[the worst]

pls spell my name right

sorry
leavin this dialogue to Ank but for future generations of scumhunters I am firmly in her camp and do not understand what you want us to see in your behaviour

whether chickadee is town or not is largely unrelated to your alignment, help us solve you pls

[Alisae]

Pst
Hey
Want my opinion?

[the worst]

Is it better than your last opinion?

[Menalque]

I mean you haven’t discounted anything imo, you’ve just insisted that the actions are the same while I’ve explained that they’re not. Yet you keep pushing the line. I would have said it was just a difference of opinion, but you’re not even trying to see it fmpov which is scummy because you’re not genuinely trying to sort me

You’re also trying to shade me in a really subtle way at the same time, saying that i “turned it into” a scumread on you instead of “you started scumreading me for it”. That makes it sound like i crafted it instead of it being a natural evolution.

And it’s also weird that you’re STing my entire play seeing as I hadn’t done v much at the point when that started and I think anyone in this game who knows me would probably have that at pretty null. But instead you hopped on and started SRing me fairly hard with nothing to really back it up. Now you’re shoehorning in later things (my readslist) when that information wasn’t available to you at the time of your initial scumread on me

I also think I’m a good target for scum this game because of being (i think?) the newest player here and pine knowing that I often get SR early on as both alignments. So the fact that you’re pushing me like this for reasons as bad as they are is also scum!indicative

[Alisae]

Is it better than your last opinion?

Mena is town

[the worst]

actually stuff that let's unpack 1022 rq

- done nothing so we should be nullreading you
- are mislynch bait so we shouldn't push you
- Ank is scum because she's trying to crack open a discussion in as much detail as possible on your play so far and isn't trying to sort you

just unpack that post just now from the perspective of someone trying to work out your alignment. I'm concerned you're dedicating a lot of time to trying to swat at people pushing you and not much time towards sorting people. survivalism is as often a newbtown tell as a scumtell so I'm not feeling like crazy strong about scumreading that but you're also then appealing to the fact you don't think I'm entitled to scumread you because you haven't done enough yet

do you like..understand why I'm not equipped to townread you?