Newbie 1951 (Day 4)

[teacher]

My biggest skit question is her chatmafia question to creep. I had already asked it, so don’t see what she wanted to get out of it. But the flip side of that is that she might have seen an earlier one and been reaction in real time to that before getting to my question

@Skit, not sure you answered this.

[teacher]

still disagree that i was being fence-sitty

Well, clearly you are on me (youre voting me). See also 1333, acknowledging some conflict.

On emps, I dont see any other way to read 1329, 1330, and 1331 -- 1329 says Emps is different, but 1331 says his read progression is the same there as here. You would be able to push him if needed tomorrow -- theres no hard positioning there, as compared to my 1370 saying emps is different from 1941 in a way that put him off the table for me.

At this point, I think every town should have selected their two lynches. I have been clear about mine. I have no idea who your second (after me, your current vote) is -- is it pops, or is it emps? I dont think anybody can solidly answer. That is why you have been fence-sitty.

[teacher]

Skit I think were going to need to compromise, and that slot is basically the compromise. Maybe Selynee - I need to reread todays stuff, which Im not going to be able to do until tomorrow. But Menalque is off the day's list for me in the same way that Fark is for you.

FWIW, I think Menalque's posts of today are fairly town-indicative for him, especially the nuance on Fark which you can also find in my posts.

Have you had a chance to go over 1941!emps?

I cant chat tonight, so somewhat of a prodge.

i'm not voting fark today and i'd much prefer menalque

i can compromise on creeper; i'm not sure menalque is like ~viable~ anymore really
i do think the wagon is icky tho
are we ready for l-1?

i haven't had a chance yet to read the other game, i've had a p busy day
(also will be busy for the next couple of days; i'm vla over fridays and saturdays, just a reminder)

This interaction is basically why I cant be scum. Im sorry, but there is literally no way I stop a town!Menalque wagon in order to lynch my scumpartner. Not when I had been scumreading Menalque most of the game, and only defended him because of my views on how Fark joined his wagon. If Im scum, I limp off quietly and let Menalque eat rope rather than my partner. The best you can say is I was bussing, but if I wanted credit for bussing, wouldnt I at least be voting there?

Seriously, I invite anyone voting me to tell me the scum motivation for 743. Because I certainly can tell you it for 744 (especially with 748 and 797 still pushing town!Mena).

[teacher]

Pops->Skit or, if its me today, just Skit tomorrow. Godspeed, Im off to do the family thing and will be limited today.

[emps]

wait what why do i have to choose

[emps]

uhhhhhhhh idk if scum teacher makes those posts saying that we should go for skitter tmrw when there clearly isnt any chance that skitter will be lynched today

[teacher]

wait what why do i have to choose

Because you’re the only slot not voting.

[popsofctown]

his insistence EC had coaching in the PT and how firmly he seems able to hold the belief.

??

Poor choice of words, maybe. You insist there was engagement in the scum PT, and that it was somewhere along the spectrum of "poor coaching" and "no guidance at all". The latter stance seems even more outlandish than the former though.

My stance is that EC never bookmarked the mafia PT. He doesn't have an avatar. He probably checked the thread itself with site navigate instead of a bookmark. Checking the mafia PT would involve opening his PM and clicking the link again and I think he didn't go for that crazy often.

it’s a 180 from pops based on posts that were all out there

The post skitter quoted where you said you scumread Selynee during day2 is one I was just not cognizant of. I read a lot of posts. If you had asked me 2 RL days ago what teacher's d2 posts implied about Selynee slot I would have said "that he's townreading her".

I make different choices with new information. This information oughtn't be new but is.

I discussed some other points that I had already been aware of and that I was already cognizant of and you are correct that those are not reasons your standing with me changed. Those are just reasons for people to vote with me if they want to.

180 seems like a kind of strong word for swapping my top scumread and second top scumread (has been, ever since I've decided on the sheep strat for sorting emps), but in the sense that it's very likely I don't get to lynch both of you and might be gamethrowing right now maybe that choice of words is ok for gravity

[teacher]

180 seems right enough -- Ive gone three spots down in a list of 4. Perhaps youd prefer 135, but its not as vernacular.

[popsofctown]

My replace in reads was

Selynee
teacher
skitter
emps

Reads after feedback on emps was

Selynee
emps
teacher
skitter

It stayed that way for a really long time.

Now the bottom two have switched.

Do you think I ever townread you more than Selynee? Like. That's like never.

[emps]

ehhh idk im still leaning teacher and we kinda have to make a descision...

[emps]

oh well i hope im right...

VOTE: teacher

[teacher]

Nope I’m town. Lynch skit tomorrow.

And yes pops, going from 2 to 4 on a readslist is going down three slots (two, three, four)

Good luck y’all.

[popsofctown]

Uh I'll agree to disagree on the numerical representation of slot movements.

I think I probably threw, I think skitter shoots emps over Selynee because of Selynee's stance on me and then the 1v1 is EZ.

I'm sorry teacher

I found this game really hard

But it's a pretty good one, imo

[Nexus]

Votecount 3.3:

teacher (3 - LYNCH)-

popsofctown, skitter30, emps

popsofctown (2)-

teacher, Selynee

Not voting (0)-

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch. Deadline is now at 6pm BST on Wednesday 11th September 2019 (expired on 2019-09-11 18:00:00).

teacher has been lynched. Flip incoming.

[Nexus]

teacher - Vanilla Townie - Lynched Day 3

Night 3 now begins. I will accelerate the Night if all alive players PM me to say they wish to do so. If not, it will end in 48 hours, at 7pm BST on Friday 13th September 2019 (expired on 2019-09-13 19:00:00)

[Nexus]

Selynee - Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 3

Day 4 now begins. With 3 alive it takes 2 to lynch. Deadline is at 7pm BST on Friday 20th September 2019 (expired on 2019-09-20 19:00:00)

[popsofctown]

I feel a little sweet talked about ending up on teacher yesterday.

If skitter has some mindblowing and amazing compelling case on emps I'll think about it, but I'm pretty inclined to just deadsheep teacher here.

My NKA was that scumskitter would shoot emps and more easily convince Selynee to vote me than emps, but Selynee was way more townlock than emps is so there's an inherent element of risk in the play, and skitter seems like a player I think would be risk-averse as scum

[skitter30]

Hello i have weekend vla and will be around tomorrow night/sunday

[popsofctown]

Good news guys I just finished winning a different 9p I can afford to throw this one

[emps]

im pretty tempted to just deadsheep teacher tbh

[skitter30]

i need to do some rereading

[skitter30]

emps why did you end up voting teacher over pops yesterday?

[skitter30]

I feel a little sweet talked about ending up on teacher yesterday.

If skitter has some mindblowing and amazing compelling case on emps I'll think about it, but I'm pretty inclined to just deadsheep teacher here.

My NKA was that scumskitter would shoot emps and more easily convince Selynee to vote me than emps, but Selynee was way more townlock than emps is so there's an inherent element of risk in the play, and skitter seems like a player I think would be risk-averse as scum

i am p risk-adverse as scum, sure
idk who scum!me would have nk'd last night; it also wasn't my problem so it's not something i've thought too much about

[Nexus]

Votecount 4.1:

Not voting (3) -

skitter30, emps, popsofctown

With 3 alive it takes 2 to lynch. Deadline is at 7pm BST on Friday 20th September 2019 (expired on 2019-09-20 19:00:00)