Magical Girls UPick - Heart of Shadow (Game Over)

[Tana and Ephraim]

Evenstar's pretty transparently scum.

[gameplay506]

What is eventide even doing

[Dannflor]

but wait let her post a reads list

[Tana and Ephraim]

Wait my hydra partner already voted Evenstar.

I'm super proud of Tana rn

[Tana and Ephraim]

Wait my hydra partner already voted Evenstar.

I'm super proud of Tana rn

Haha, thanks!
-Tana

[RCEnigma]

Idk most players have been joking but Titus is the only one who left an odd feeling in me
Same with bitmap but replace odd with good

Oof sorry if I'm being too serious and ruining the fun, I will go back to my rl now

Ok 5 bucks based on everything that's happened gameplay is seriously scum here. Bitmap's likely scum or useful to them.

VOTE: Gameplay

RC's voting based on vendetta.
Pops is voting to get a reaction.
Cafe getting a counter wagon going in RVS isn't an issue at all. I might have done the same.

Gameplay's posting however is over justified. Titus has an "odd" feeling. Bitmap has a "good" feeling. Yet he breaks the posting up into several posts and is real defensive about it.

Pops, real life does suck. I'd rather not think about it. I put it elsewhere but there's real high odds I'm getting a divorce.

Hm idk RCE I don't see Titus trying to solve me here, I see Titus banging her fist on the table, going GP is scum, while providing some pretty made-up reasoning for it.

And the fact that she just continues to read me in the same way 15 pages later with still minimal effort to solve me out makes me think she is just comfortable keeping that read and not comfortable backing out of it.

Well she's already decided you're scum. If she had flipped the read I'd probably be suspicious of her. This is in her townrange however.

[popsofctown]

I made a level 2 Moze under a popsofctown account

Imma catch up here after dinner

[Lady Eventide]

Lady Even where are your reads at right now?

Be as thorough as you can

Right now...

Frankly I don't have a lot. But of the people I've interacted with/can recall, 5 minute version so as not to get interrupted again:

LLD:

Inscrutable, but I don't like how she seems to be ducking all inquiries. I know she loves mafia, so her silence is concerning.

Cop:

Scummy in a vague kind of way; I don't like them, I want to see more. I had a better reason but I've lost it somewhere.

Sailor Senshi:

Were lurking, which is a pet peeve of mine, and also were a source of the thread blowup, but TBQH my vote here was crappy and I ought to have known better. They've defended themselves well since and I think their reactions are towny. Not going back here today unless I find a very good reason, esp given the number of hops on here. (Who else was on this? God I want the VCA tools from MU.)

Tana and Ephraim:

Are currently pinging me very hard, both for tone reasons and because they're throwing shade at me but don't actually seem to want to lynch me. I feel like they're reading me as a weak town player they can mislynch later. Also they called me "a weak scum" when my scumgame LITERALLY GOT ME TO THE FINALE OF THE WORLD CHAMPIONSHIPS. Seriously? Have clearly not done any background meta on me whatsoever and ignored my previously posted scumgame.

Cafe Stiles:

Seems towny but fluffy at a first impression. Haven't looked into deeper, should.

Groar

Croag:

Scummy, because reasons.

Katsuki:

Is being weird, but I

think

it's a town kind of weird? Overall I want to see more and would not vote here right now.

Gameplay:

... I think they're town. I don't like how they play the game, but I think they're town. They seem to be motivated more by solving than by pushing for lynches, and that's good. Dislike them keeping me as a 'reserve lynch', but w/e.

Taristra

Titus:

Giving me very mixed signals, needs solving... but is posting enough, and is already under enough pressure, that I don't want to vote them right now. Would lynch Tana over them, would lynch them over Gameplay. Don't think that Sailor Senshi are scum rn, and that's a strike against them for an easy inactive push.

RCEnigma:

Gives me experienced-player vibes, but otherwise too early to judge alignment IMO. Gun to head, town.

DrDolittle:

Barely exists. I think he's voting me? Post seemed inoffensive at the time. Let me ISO fast he's only got 10 posts. First and apparently only

serious

vote... is on me, and IMO seems a bit opportunistic now. I was at what, three votes here? Deserves some investigation/pressure.

Bitmap:

No real read, should probably go back and look at esp. given his mentions and apparently having attracted some votes? Hm.

Hidden Happiness, Chaos Wind:

are both 2p hydras with nine posts. Need to contribute more.

Gamma Emerald:

Despite their vote on me there's nothing else in their ISO I can really complain about. They're just town.

Dannfor:

Likely town; you seem to be trying to solve me, rather than immediately writing me off as scum. I could be getting pocketed, but your ISO looks decent at a skim.

I hope I'm not missing anyone; activity list has a couple other people but I think they're parts of hydrae?

@Dannfor: I'll elaborate on this if you like but this is what I have in my head rn.

@Gameplay: her best

[Tana and Ephraim]

We're

literally

voting you right now

[Gamma Emerald]

Eventide, I didn't vote you lol

[Tana and Ephraim]

My opinion of MU championships is already low enough that you claiming that your scum game made it there doesn't change my opinion of either your scumgame or MU championships

shrugemoticon

[Gamma Emerald]

Cop: Scummy in a vague kind of way; I don't like them, I want to see more. I had a better reason but I've lost it somewhere.

Who is this cop person btw
FYI I think your thoughts are okay for now but I haven't really dug into your post at all for underlying logic.

[Lady Eventide]

We're

literally

voting you right now

I'm talking about post #847, where you literally say you're "not in a particular rush to lynch [me] because

seem like weak scum." And just say that I'm scum "for various reasons", without actually giving them.

Also you were literally the person who asked me for my past scumgame. What conclusions did you come to regarding my play, based on that game that I provided? That I was

weak scum?

Did I do absolutely nothing of note to you in that game?

@GammaEmerald: PopsofCtown. My brain fucks things up, sorry.

[Lady Eventide]

ah fuck I did square brackets around I and it fucked everything up let me fix that \

EBWOP:

I'm talking about post #847, where you literally say you're "not in a particular rush to lynch (me) because (I) seem like weak scum." And just say that I'm scum "for various reasons", without actually giving them.

Also you were literally the person who asked me for my past scumgame. What conclusions did you come to regarding my play, based on that game that I provided? That I was

weak scum?

Did I do absolutely nothing of note to you in that game?

[Gamma Emerald]

Ah thanks

[Tana and Ephraim]

I noticed several tonal tics that I find to be also present here that are present in significantly lower quantities in the town games that I read.
Yes, I said I was in no rush to lynch you. I said that about all of my other scumreads as well because like I have said many times forcing content out of lurkers is a high priority for me.
I did express before that wallpost that I intended to vote you (if we hadn't already been voting you) so claiming that I'm trying to keep you around as a later mislynch is inaccurate at best.

[Lady Eventide]

Also,

@Lady Lambdadelta:
You've played with me as scum.

1: What's your honest evaluation of my skill as scum? You ought to be an authority on this more than anybody else here.
2: Does it make sense that Tana might think I have a weak scumgame after reading WC1?

[Tana and Ephraim]

2: Does it make sense that Tana might think I have a weak scumgame after reading WC1?

I read what?
-Tana

[Tana and Ephraim]

All of the above is Ephraim posting, the request for your scumgames/towngames was from Ephraim as well. This is from Ephraim!

[Lady Eventide]

I noticed several tonal tics that I find to be also present here that are present in significantly lower quantities in the town games that I read.
Yes, I said I was in no rush to lynch you. I said that about all of my other scumreads as well because like I have said many times forcing content out of lurkers is a high priority for me.
I did express before that wallpost that I intended to vote you (if we hadn't already been voting you) so claiming that I'm trying to keep you around as a later mislynch is inaccurate at best.

... You're as of yet still not convincing me that you've actually read the scumgame. If you've read my ISO there's a big goddamn obvious

thing

I did in the game I linked, and you've

completely failed to mention it.

Here's a hint for you:

[Lady Eventide]

I noticed several tonal tics that I find to be also present here that are present in significantly lower quantities in the town games that I read.
Yes, I said I was in no rush to lynch you. I said that about all of my other scumreads as well because like I have said many times forcing content out of lurkers is a high priority for me.
I did express before that wallpost that I intended to vote you (if we hadn't already been voting you) so claiming that I'm trying to keep you around as a later mislynch is inaccurate at best.

Re: the rest of your post: we agree on forcing content from lurkers at least. I still dislike that you hedged in case this went badly for you.

[Tana and Ephraim]

I put very little stock in what most people consider alignment indicative content and a lot of stock in stuff that most people wouldn't even think to consider alignment indicative.
How people say and do things is to me far more important than what people actually say and do and your entire list on how to read you is the latter rather than the former.

~Ephraim

Re: the rest of your post: we agree on forcing content from lurkers at least. I still dislike that you hedged in case this went badly for you.

[Lady Eventide]

I put very little stock in what most people consider alignment indicative content and a lot of stock in stuff that most people wouldn't even think to consider alignment indicative.
How people say and do things is to me far more important than what people actually say and do and your entire list on how to read you is the latter rather than the former.

~Ephraim

Re: the rest of your post: we agree on forcing content from lurkers at least. I still dislike that you hedged in case this went badly for you.

Swing and a miss x

[Dannflor]

Dannfor dannfloor dancefloor damnflor

[Tana and Ephraim]

Also I am required to be as vague as possible on this given that you linked a still-ongoing game.