Magical Girls UPick - Heart of Shadow (Game Over)

[Hidden Happiness]

I AM PLEASANTLY AND CONFUSEDLY SURPRISED MARIAR DIDN'T DUMP THE TRUCK ON MY TAKE ON SAKURA

It's mostly a mix of. If Sakura is scum I'm not getting them lynched anytime soon and if they're town they're gonna die soon. So there's 0 reasons for me to try and solve the slot. The most I'm trying to do is stop some of their influence per se. Because people should think for themselves and not sheep!
pedit: Fair enough.

[RadiantCowbells]

A) Bold of you to assume your slot is gonna be alive at Lylo.
B) The world doesn't revolve around your slot (From Nine)

If I'm scum? Probably gonna be.

[Tana and Ephraim]

Wat? I mean, I’m not wrong. I get I’m being a bit unfair considering the same statement could be said about me. But it still stands. You’re already like ‘top town’ right? So does my opinion on your slot really matter that much to you? Or is it just the fact someone is going ‘I don’t townread you guys’ and not me personally?

Your specific opinion matters to me, yes. It's a personal thing because you're a person that's played enough games with me to know that... this is already beyond my scum range.
-Tana

[Sailor Senshi]

I know bitmap has a tendency to look scummy as town, but damn, that post. I can see him retracting it as either alignment as it's likely to draw attention to himself and that's messing up with my read there, not something I feel like sorting right now.
I do have other hot takes tho, I think Katsuki's post about HW where he voted Sailor means that he's already paying enough attention to the game. Will leave as town as for right now, but i better see some magical solves in the next 2 days or he's dead.
I remember groc also not doing anything in gay dance until after she was already confirmed dying and she was scum there.
I also have no issue with the vote on cafe.
MariaR's slot lack of being here maybe means MariaR town.
-Tana

Croag’s post is scum indicative because unlike disengaged town, she makes this kind of lamisty post and pretty much vanishes. Like to say, I really care about solving this game but does nothing.

[Tana and Ephraim]

A) Bold of you to assume your slot is gonna be alive at Lylo.
B) The world doesn't revolve around your slot (From Nine)

If I'm scum? Probably gonna be.

I mean, I've had to live to LyLo in all my other scum games. Why's this one supposed to be different?
Every time you mention that you want to lynch me later, every time Bitmap talks about reevaluating me on day 3, you're giving scum more reason not to kill me.

If you really wanted this tell to be reliable you would have had to not already bring up that you were planning to turn on me somewhere down the line.

[popsofctown]

RC can you quote 1651 in your hydra for isos

[Tana and Ephraim]

I did that before you made that post.

[Sailor Senshi]

Dunno who/what else i need to comment on before night, feel free to ask me
-Tana

Does MariaR have a strong vested interest in a game when she's scum?

In the two games I played with her she did but I’ve also seen her be strongly engaged as town. Iow, her not being too invested is town indicative but her being strongly invested is NAI.

[Bitmap]

VOTE: RCEnigma

Lets go here.

[Hidden Happiness]

A) Bold of you to assume your slot is gonna be alive at Lylo.
B) The world doesn't revolve around your slot (From Nine)

If I'm scum? Probably gonna be.

Hahahaha no. Good one but no

Wat? I mean, I’m not wrong. I get I’m being a bit unfair considering the same statement could be said about me. But it still stands. You’re already like ‘top town’ right? So does my opinion on your slot really matter that much to you? Or is it just the fact someone is going ‘I don’t townread you guys’ and not me personally?

Your specific opinion matters to me, yes. It's a personal thing because you're a person that's played enough games with me to know that... this is already beyond my scum range.
-Tana

Is it? I think I've only played with scum you twice and in 1 of those games you had me tricked until Lylo. My read on you is it's a waste of time to sort you as I said. I don't think you're scummy but the 'OMG THIS SLOT IS SO OBV TOWN WTF' is something I'm not seeing. Do you really want me to put in more effort to read you Sakura? Considering you're doing it for me I can do that for you, but I don't think it's needed much.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Gamma's attack on me kind of felt like genuine town. Not entirely sure though.

Go on.

Tana and Ephraim are very much in their scum ranges and have done almost nothing that I’ve seen to make me warrant a townread on them

So this is how you're going to be like huh
-Tana

Wat? I mean, I’m not wrong. I get I’m being a bit unfair considering the same statement could be said about me. But it still stands. You’re already like ‘top town’ right? So does my opinion on your slot really matter that much to you? Or is it just the fact someone is going ‘I don’t townread you guys’ and not me personally?

But if you dislike it that much then I'll try to find another way to read you.
-Tana

Thank you, I hate it when people try to read me that way it’s just. Not the way I want people to read me. I don’t care if the end result is ‘correct’ it doesn’t feel fulfilled as a mafia player to be read that way.

... @Katsuki: I think it is relevant to note that your current level of contribution compares unfavorably to both Chaos Wind and Cafe Stiles. You barely have more presence than

Croag.

I don't really care how much of a hotshot scumfinder you supposedly are; lurking to lategame like this is unacceptable behaviour, and T&E are right to call you on it.

Unacceptable behavior?

I've been barely lurking for 3 days (if this even constitutes as lurking when I've been posting every day), you haven't even seen me prod-dodging for two months yet.

... Does anybody townread this?

Welcome to Katsuki being Katsuki


I’m just gonna mark LLD as town because if LLD really would go as low as to make certain statements at Titus as scum I don’t want to play with her again, and I’d like to think scum LLD wouldn’t do that so.

I'm not particularly fond of Titus's towniness right now. Failing to stick to one topic or plug whatever read she thinks is correct and should end the day borrows me compared to her just pushing "end the day". Like.. I guess I'm taking the easy straightforward interpretation here, "end the day" doesn't serve the town wincon.

Go on.

Dannflor are you a Heart of Light

I wish I was a heart of light.

What statements did you take offense at exactly?

[Sailor Senshi]

That's because Role Call was a shit game though

In RHPS, I did the absolute minimum not to get replaced.

[Tana and Ephraim]

You're correct that this game probably wont be necessary, but for the future, yes i'd like it if you'd do that
-Tana

[Hidden Happiness]

A) Bold of you to assume your slot is gonna be alive at Lylo.
B) The world doesn't revolve around your slot (From Nine)

If I'm scum? Probably gonna be.

I mean, I've had to live to LyLo in all my other scum games. Why's this one supposed to be different?
Every time you mention that you want to lynch me later, every time Bitmap talks about reevaluating me on day 3, you're giving scum more reason not to kill me.

If you really wanted this tell to be reliable you would have had to not already bring up that you were planning to turn on me somewhere down the line.

RC you know I'm very much smart enough to know exactly what I'm posting ahd what it'll do. I have not expressed a lot on your slot for a dam good reason. We've talked about our scum games before we know how

some

of our factors work. I don't think you're gonna be alive at Lylo. Maybe you think that but I don't. Mostly because I know how paranoia in a thread works. If you're scum I'm not worried. If you're town I'm not worried. It's not a tell, it's a statement

Dunno who/what else i need to comment on before night, feel free to ask me
-Tana

Does MariaR have a strong vested interest in a game when she's scum?

In the two games I played with her she did but I’ve also seen her be strongly engaged as town. Iow, her not being too invested is town indicative but her being strongly invested is NAI.

I swear to god activity has NOTHING TO DO WITH MY ALIGNMENT EVER. I lurk as scum I lurk as town I can tryhard as town I can tryhard as scum. The factor on if I do this or not is never based on what role pm I get REEEEEEEEEE

[popsofctown]

[

I'm not particularly fond of Titus's towniness right now. Failing to stick to one topic or plug whatever read she thinks is correct and should end the day borrows me compared to her just pushing "end the day". Like.. I guess I'm taking the easy straightforward interpretation here, "end the day" doesn't serve the town wincon.

Go on.

I'm not sure why you're asking for a "go on", my thought felt complete. I'm not getting the authentic feel of a player who is doing what they can to end the day, and wields two votes that can be weaponized to that end. It's looking more like someone using the proxy vote to toy with their own moonlogic meta, rather than needle down to the strongest overlap between their own reads and the viable wagons, to end a day they are truly so tired of

Dannflor are you a Heart of Light

I wish I was a heart of light.

Oh my

[DrDolittle]

hello everyone

[Hidden Happiness]

What statements did you take offense at exactly?

The divorce stuff like, I don't see why anyone who is scum would willingly make that statement. Unless you're scum partners with Titus and got her concent but even still no. I don't think anyone who is scum would willingly make that statement. It's just, so bad. Just no.

You're correct that this game probably wont be necessary, but for the future, yes i'd like it if you'd do that
-Tana

Will do ^^

I'm not sure why you're asking for a "go on", my thought felt complete. I'm not getting the authentic feel of a player who is doing what they can to end the day, and wields two votes that can be weaponized to that end. It's looking more like someone using the proxy vote to toy with their own moonlogic meta, rather than needle down to the strongest overlap between their own reads and the viable wagons, to end a day they are truly so tired of

What advantage does scum Titus get from using the stance shes taking?
pedit: Living up to your name I see eh Dolittle?
~Celica

[Lady Lambdadelta]

What statements did you take offense at exactly?

The divorce stuff like, I don't see why anyone who is scum would willingly make that statement. Unless you're scum partners with Titus and got her concent but even still no. I don't think anyone who is scum would willingly make that statement. It's just, so bad. Just no.

You're correct that this game probably wont be necessary, but for the future, yes i'd like it if you'd do that
-Tana

Will do ^^

I'm not sure why you're asking for a "go on", my thought felt complete. I'm not getting the authentic feel of a player who is doing what they can to end the day, and wields two votes that can be weaponized to that end. It's looking more like someone using the proxy vote to toy with their own moonlogic meta, rather than needle down to the strongest overlap between their own reads and the viable wagons, to end a day they are truly so tired of

What advantage does scum Titus get from using the stance shes taking?
pedit: Living up to your name I see eh Dolittle?
~Celica

It's public info as far as I know? huh?

[Tana and Ephraim]

You're actually dreaming if you think that I wouldn't live to endgame in this game if I were scum.

We should

really

lynch SH.

[Tana and Ephraim]

LE.

[Titus]

The divorce stuff like, I don't see why anyone who is scum would willingly make that statement. Unless you're scum partners with Titus and got her concent but even still no. I don't think anyone who is scum would willingly make that statement. It's just, so bad. Just no.

I'm not offended. I am not sure LLD is town but town still has to sort me.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

The divorce stuff like, I don't see why anyone who is scum would willingly make that statement. Unless you're scum partners with Titus and got her concent but even still no. I don't think anyone who is scum would willingly make that statement. It's just, so bad. Just no.

I'm not offended. I am not sure LLD is town but town still has to sort me.

Is this not public info?

[Tana and Ephraim]

Like, I won Gameshow which was townsided beyond an even remotely reasonable amount. I would say it was significantly worse than 90/10, but I will just say 90/10 to avoid debating that further.
Why can't I live to endgame as scum here? Why won't the paranoia hammer fall on LLD, or Katsuki, or you?

Idk if I'm arguing this for any good reason but it feels exceptionally strange to me that you either are claiming to be or are actually under that impression.

[Tana and Ephraim]

Anyway. LE is scum. They need to die.

[Bitmap]

VOTE: Lady Eventide

I feel like this will get more traction than RCE. And I do somewhat scum read this slot.