Magical Girls UPick - Heart of Shadow (Game Over)

[Cafe Stile]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Cafe Stiles

You got some explaining to do.

Is this about the neighbourhood stuff

[Dannflor]

Lady E, you were claiming to be good at scum earlier in the game, right?

But you also think you’re mislynch bait?

[Cafe Stile]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Cafe Stiles

You got some explaining to do.

If it is, so heres the thing
So I was outside hanging out with my buddies and lightly skimming the thread because that's all the mafia related things I can do at the moment, and occasionally hopping into the hood to post random shit every like 5 hours because i dont got the energy to post in main thread, so at the time I read DDL's post that pinged me I went and said in the hood it pinged me
*shrug*

hmm

Eventide's vote on SS is pretty shoddy. being pressured leading to spat is a terribly weak reason to scum read people... what do you want, that after being pressured you just lay down and die?

I don't think gameplay is scum, but please don't use personal RL stuff as a point of attack.

If Eventide would flip scum, Titus's (hello titus!) attack on gameplay is very much chainsaw.

That last line pings wolf
It doesn't do anything in terms of pressuring Eva, and Titus is his townread. It doesn't make sense for town with those sets of reads to shade Titus and Eva here
Titus attacked on gameplay before Eva even posted so it wasn't even correct

Um, yeah, what else is there? the hood is us, Eva and Croag, maybe there are people that havent posted there idk. We were slightly more interested in talking about gacha games in there anyway ;p

- Hideri

[Cafe Stile]

It's not beneficial for her if Eva was a wolf to out the neighbourhood there

dont vote her

- Hideri

[Dannflor]

It's not beneficial for her if Eva was a wolf to out the neighbourhood there

dont vote her

- Hideri

??? what why

literally any of you could have outed it

Why is it more beneficial for scum!Lady E to keep it a secret

[Cafe Stile]

I'm townreading Eva so I'm not outing it
And she knows that
Croag isn't playing

A neighbourhood for scum is literally a golden pocketing opportunity and not only she didn't do that, she threw it away

- Hideri

[Cafe Stile]

Like maybe she thinks we're not worth it to pocket, which *shrug*
But it's tinfoil I'm not dealing with today

- Hideri

[Chaos Wind]

I'm townreading Eva so I'm not outing it
And she knows that
Croag isn't playing

A neighbourhood for scum is literally a golden pocketing opportunity and not only she didn't do that, she threw it away

- Hideri

Why is it impossible to pocket someone with a neighborhood that's outed

-Wind

[Cafe Stile]

I looped back, and I do NOT think the Dann case has any merit

Overall, HH seems pretty fence sitting on LE, and the interaction feels a bit exaggerated and forced "oh woe is me I cant believe I'm agreeing with LE".

In that sense, I dont think HH is scummy in herself, but there some weird stuff going on with her and LE

why is DDL being townread

this post is just
calling out Maria but at the same time it's not
It doesnt do shit

- Hideri

[Cafe Stile]

I'm townreading Eva so I'm not outing it
And she knows that
Croag isn't playing

A neighbourhood for scum is literally a golden pocketing opportunity and not only she didn't do that, she threw it away

- Hideri

Why is it impossible to pocket someone with a neighborhood that's outed

-Wind

Who's she gonna do it to after outing the hood

- Hideri

[Dannflor]

Who's she gonna do it to after outing the hood

- Hideri

You?

I assume you guys aren't just gonna stop interacting in there now that the hood is outed

[Cafe Stile]

Last post in there was a day ago

Anyhow
She's gonna call me out and vote me and then pocket me? nani kore

- Hideri

[Bitmap]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Cafe Stiles

You got some explaining to do.

If it is, so heres the thing
So I was outside hanging out with my buddies and lightly skimming the thread because that's all the mafia related things I can do at the moment, and occasionally hopping into the hood to post random shit every like 5 hours because i dont got the energy to post in main thread, so at the time I read DDL's post that pinged me I went and said in the hood it pinged me
*shrug*

hmm

Eventide's vote on SS is pretty shoddy. being pressured leading to spat is a terribly weak reason to scum read people... what do you want, that after being pressured you just lay down and die?

I don't think gameplay is scum, but please don't use personal RL stuff as a point of attack.

If Eventide would flip scum, Titus's (hello titus!) attack on gameplay is very much chainsaw.

That last line pings wolf
It doesn't do anything in terms of pressuring Eva, and Titus is his townread. It doesn't make sense for town with those sets of reads to shade Titus and Eva here
Titus attacked on gameplay before Eva even posted so it wasn't even correct

Um, yeah, what else is there? the hood is us, Eva and Croag, maybe there are people that havent posted there idk. We were slightly more interested in talking about gacha games in there anyway ;p

- Hideri

I see.

Also speaking of gacha games, Azur Lane anyone?

[Dannflor]

Last post in there was a day ago

Anyhow
She's gonna call me out and vote me and then pocket me? nani kore

- Hideri

I mean no

but outing the neighborhood itself isn't a town tell

It's just as likely that she's trying to throw you under the bus to save herself under the (maybe bad) assumption that there's at least one scum in the neighborhood

[popsofctown]

Hm, Evenstar doesn't seem like the kind of personality for enjoying gacha games.

Either Lillaire has been up to no good in there, or Evenstar has foiled my expectations.

[Cafe Stile]

Last post in there was a day ago

Anyhow
She's gonna call me out and vote me and then pocket me? nani kore

- Hideri

I mean no

but outing the neighborhood itself isn't a town tell

It's just as likely that she's trying to throw you under the bus to save herself under the (maybe bad) assumption that there's at least one scum in the neighborhood

But that doesn't matter if nobody knows theres a hood, and as far as her impression goes, we won't
Not that I believe in the one scum in hood thing

Hm, Evenstar doesn't seem like the kind of personality for enjoying gacha games.

Either Lillaire has been up to no good in there, or Evenstar has foiled my expectations.

We're adding Eva on said gacha game after the game ends so that was eva
*finger guns*

- Hideri

[Dannflor]

But that doesn't matter if nobody knows theres a hood, and as far as her impression goes, we won't
Not that I believe in the one scum in hood thing

I think the benefit she gains by being like, "yo here's the hood, Cafe is sketchy in it, let's lynch him instead"

is greater than the benefit of trying to pocket you, because no offense, I don't think that gets her much

[popsofctown]

Hm, Evenstar doesn't seem like the kind of personality for enjoying gacha games.

Either Lillaire has been up to no good in there, or Evenstar has foiled my expectations.

We're adding Eva on said gacha game after the game ends so that was eva
*finger guns*

- Hideri

Uh, you should be good to go ahead and do it now, farm a few weeks more friends points or what have you. Just don't use the app to discuss the game.

I mean I did in fact play some BL3 with LLD after all.

[Cafe Stile]

But that doesn't matter if nobody knows theres a hood, and as far as her impression goes, we won't
Not that I believe in the one scum in hood thing

I think the benefit she gains by being like, "yo here's the hood, Cafe is sketchy in it, let's lynch him instead"

is greater than the benefit of trying to pocket you, because no offense, I don't think that gets her much

lol well I guess that's true

I found she did with it could be more like, explaining her push on DDL with my one singular post on DDL in the hood, and called it "Cafe Stile played her"
ehhhhhh thats kind of a cop out

uhhhh

- Hideri

[Cafe Stile]

Like
I think I still wouldn't vote Eva because I read WC1 where she was a wolf and this game feels way different
I dont see what RC sees with respect to her meta
Also RCE and DDL are more appealing votes for me

- Hideri

[Cafe Stile]

Hm, Evenstar doesn't seem like the kind of personality for enjoying gacha games.

Either Lillaire has been up to no good in there, or Evenstar has foiled my expectations.

We're adding Eva on said gacha game after the game ends so that was eva
*finger guns*

- Hideri

Uh, you should be good to go ahead and do it now, farm a few weeks more friends points or what have you. Just don't use the app to discuss the game.

I mean I did in fact play some BL3 with LLD after all.

[Lady Eventide]

Lady E, you were claiming to be good at scum earlier in the game, right?

But you also think you’re mislynch bait?

As a wolf, I don't have to actually flail around and put pressure on people in order to develop reads. I already know people's alignments and can just focus on examining behavior. I don't votehop so much, and when I do votehop it's more controlled because it's got an actual plan behind it. Which, to be entirely honest, I ain't got as town. Plus the fact that I look scummy as town means it's hard to tell when I'm actually, y'know, scum.

@Cafe Stiles:
Looking at Mastina's page on mafiawiki, they do indeed seem like a very similar player to me. Calibrating your read via their meta is likely to return good results as a first approximation. I also think I'm quite similar to LLD in some respects; apply that meta as well if you have it.

[Lady Eventide]

Hm, Evenstar doesn't seem like the kind of personality for enjoying gacha games.

Either Lillaire has been up to no good in there, or Evenstar has foiled my expectations.

I enjoy them despite the fact that they are evil.

[Lady Eventide]

Who's she gonna do it to after outing the hood

- Hideri

You?

I assume you guys aren't just gonna stop interacting in there now that the hood is outed

Why bother? Until Croag's dead it's not secure, and Stile is... maybe not the greatest player to collaborate with tbqh, even if I knew them to be town. Seems much more likely to get me scumread for talking behind people's backs and 'trying to pocket stiles' than whatever.

Plus...

... If you're town, don't you say to Stiles "You

already are

pocketed by Eva", not "You're

going to be

pocketed by Eva"? She's already hard-defending me, it's hard to see how much more deeply pocketed she could get if I'm scum. Yeah, yeah, it's a small thing re: tense, but...

As I

still

haven't gotten around to bitmap, I think I'm moving back to you again. I think Stiles has responded to pressure well enough that I don't want to lynch her today, so it's between you, Titus and maybe-bitmap.

Gonna park this here for now pending bitmap ISO:

VOTE: Dannflor

[Bitmap]

Yeah... parking my vote back.

VOTE: Lady E