Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Vecna]

Marquis continuing to towntell hard

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Marquis is scum slipping all over the place.

If Marquis was actually a Vig, a 3 man scum team could be killed Night 1 by all the vigilantes

???????????????????????????????



i wish i knew earlier u were either scum or just plain paranoid town
i hate that i'm not 100% certain what it is because i'm assuming you're a cocky enough scumplayer to think you can act as insane as your play this game has been and get away with it

yes i think there's 3 scum. i think that vigs are inherently antitown especially when forced to shoot with low information, and in this game further scum's secondary win condition doing so. if you're really a town vig that's 4 kills per night which are most likely to hit town with a good chance of hitting uncaffeinated town. but i don't think you're a town vig after every bs claim and play you've made this game and i feel like you're finally doubling down on this one because it's what will keep you safest.

overall i'm pretty sure scum, me, and perry were the only nightkillers? plus cpr doctor. so yeah wait that's still 4 potential kpn.

i'm like 90% sure we're looking for one remaining scum. why are we even arguing this. more town power roles does not mean higher town win ratio. all it means is too many cooks.

you've also been pushing me and bingle all game is what it feels like. sorry you can't nightkill us? i'm not happy either because i still have to put up with this

GDI! I am willing to sheep this for better or worse. It is the better lynch from Bingle's PoV provided I am Town here, so let's try it.

VOTE: FL

[chennisden]

marquis, i think your reasoning has its merits, esp since this is a fakegod game.

but we shouldn't discount the 2scum case.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

@chenn: Even if it's 2 scums... it is not me, and it isn't you, Right? Vecna+Bingle can't be a thing (Bingle correctly outlined why). Marquis is "semi-confirmed" based on Bingle's logic, so if there are 2 scums left at least one of them is in FL/Croag/PP. Join us on FL and let's see how it turns. If Marquis is correct the game is over. If there are 2 scums left then -depending on FL's flip AND night action- we can determine which 2 (or 1 if FL flips scum) are/is left.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

And if you had missed it, the reason Vecna+Bingle can't be a team is that makes you the ONLY uncaffeinated Town player left alive. They shoot you tonight and it's game over.

[Bingle]

i wish i knew earlier u were either scum or just plain paranoid town
i hate that i'm not 100% certain what it is because i'm assuming you're a cocky enough scumplayer to think you can act as insane as your play this game has been and get away with it

yes i think there's 3 scum. i think that vigs are inherently antitown especially when forced to shoot with low information, and in this game further scum's secondary win condition doing so. if you're really a town vig that's 4 kills per night which are most likely to hit town with a good chance of hitting uncaffeinated town. but i don't think you're a town vig after every bs claim and play you've made this game and i feel like you're finally doubling down on this one because it's what will keep you safest.

First of all, the evidence supports that FL is a vig. (Scum vig is a maybe, sure.) This evidence is the fact that we had two kills last night, and you yourself claimed to be out of shots.

Second of all, 3 scum doesn't solve the fact that 4-5 KPN is swingy as fuck. For example, if one of Vecna and me were scum, it would be entirely possible for scum to win N1, even with town holstering shots. If none of our hood is scum (which seems likely) it was possible for EVERY scum player to be killed N1. If one of us is scum a town win N1 was possible after a single scum lynch. Any way you look at it this game with the caffeine mechanic was going to swing more than a pendulum in a tornado.

[chennisden]

i think the lynch is kinda between jjd/fl today.

[chennisden]

okay, fair

VOTE: fl

[chennisden]

actually fuckit.

i think jjd may have pocketed me and my reasoning on him isn't reliable.

[chennisden]

@Chenn: you're literally the only one here who HASN'T agreed JJD is scummy. You're also the only other one pushing Marquis and not JJD. Please respond to 3976 and/or towncase JJD.

in response to this btw

[chennisden]

yeah we aren't lynching marquis since he's town

[Flavor Leaf]

VOTE: Jjd

Out of all the times I’ve saved Chenn from an obv mislynch.

[Flavor Leaf]

I’m essentially conf town, but surface levels are getting swung by scum.

[Flavor Leaf]

If Marquis ends up being scum, everyone here needs to say post game, “FL, you are a god, we should have never doubted you.”

[Flavor Leaf]

However, I’m feeling that the PP/Chenn equity is going up, but we’ve solidly gotten to JJD vs FL.

But JJD as town should never scum read me here either

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

You don't want to lynch Bingle though, so..? And why would I want my own lycnh over yours in this situation? You're out of shots, right? You're also a Miller that cannot be copped. And you're caffeinated, just as I am.

[Bingle]

If Marquis ends up being scum, everyone here needs to say post game, “FL, you are a god, we should have never doubted you.”

Someone recently asked me if we were the same person, so I'll allow it.

[Flavor Leaf]

Makes sense, we both have that “wtf is this guy talking about—ohhhh, I get it now, he was right...” thing going for us.

@JJD - Yeah, I don’t think bingle’s scum, and if he is, you understand why townMe can’t see it nor can really do anything about it.

Why have you thrown out PP/Chennisden as the scum team? They each took a side in the JJD/FL 1v1.

[Flavor Leaf]

Marquis is scum slipping all over the place.

If Marquis was actually a Vig, a 3 man scum team could be killed Night 1 by all the vigilantes

???????????????????????????????



i wish i knew earlier u were either scum or just plain paranoid town
i hate that i'm not 100% certain what it is because i'm assuming you're a cocky enough scumplayer to think you can act as insane as your play this game has been and get away with it

yes i think there's 3 scum. i think that vigs are inherently antitown especially when forced to shoot with low information, and in this game further scum's secondary win condition doing so. if you're really a town vig that's 4 kills per night which are most likely to hit town with a good chance of hitting uncaffeinated town. but i don't think you're a town vig after every bs claim and play you've made this game and i feel like you're finally doubling down on this one because it's what will keep you safest.

overall i'm pretty sure scum, me, and perry were the only nightkillers? plus cpr doctor. so yeah wait that's still 4 potential kpn.

i'm like 90% sure we're looking for one remaining scum. why are we even arguing this. more town power roles does not mean higher town win ratio. all it means is too many cooks.

you've also been pushing me and bingle all game is what it feels like. sorry you can't nightkill us? i'm not happy either because i still have to put up with this

I’ve been town reading Bingle harder than anyone else for days for the most part. Idk what that last part is about

[Flavor Leaf]

I don’t get this close to a lynch here as scum. Simple as that.

Y’all will have proof of that if I’m mislynched here that you were played by everyone.

I’m conf town, and you’re mislynching me.

Like, it’s actually pretty terrible

[Flavor Leaf]

Just know, I will abuse this game of being mislynched in the future to defend myself further in future games.

[Croag]

I hate the idea of a unkillable decaffeinated univestigable player and I want them gone tbhhhh that sounds sooooo scummy

[Flavor Leaf]

Croag, please don’t kill me. I wanna kill Marquis, one of them.

[Flavor Leaf]

Wait...

It’s Vecna/Marquis

[Flavor Leaf]

UNVOTE: Jjd