Magical Girls UPick - Heart of Shadow (Game Over)

[Tana and Ephraim]

\o/

[Bitmap]

Can you get us Tana?

[Dannflor]

\o/

[popsofctown]

Titus why are you tunneling me so hard?

[Titus]

RC/SH, if upon 24 hour reflection, you still don't get what I have conveyed this game to you and want pops alive, I'll have to work around you. I don't like it but it is what it is. Pops is near certainly scum.

I went for an AP build. (I am only explaining this at full claim or death. This will only make sense then.)

[Titus]

Titus why are you tunneling me so hard?

Because your role has zero functionality for town, you role hinting for the day vig more than scumhunting, you were generally scummy yesterday and your sole detractors have a fundamental misunderstanding of the situation.

[Tana and Ephraim]

1-shot vig, is probably slightly less likely there wouldnt be a scum redirector, GIF hates to make situations where scum can get a double nightkill tho.
UNVOTE:
-Tana

[Titus]

*day big = day block my bad

[Titus]

1-shot vig, is probably slightly less likely there wouldnt be a scum redirector, GIF hates to make situations where scum can get a double nightkill tho.
UNVOTE:
-Tana

What about 1.5?

[Tana and Ephraim]

In FO mafia i had an ability that would make anyone targeting me also target my target, i refused to use it because someone had received an item that made them strongwilled and so we started suspecting bus driver / redirector and i wanted to avoid giving scum a 2nd kill, after I was already dead and spoiled GIF told me that "He would never put a scum redirector when there's a town vig", a town vig had flipped in that game.
-Tana

[Titus]

In FO mafia i had an ability that would make anyone targeting me also target my target, i refused to use it because someone had received an item that made them strongwilled and so we started suspecting bus driver / redirector and i wanted to avoid giving scum a 2nd kill, after I was already dead and spoiled GIF told me that "He would never put a scum redirector when there's a town vig", a town vig had flipped in that game.
-Tana

I absolutely believe this happened. I still think GiF did it anyway due to the sheer amount of power town has and that scenario doesn't happen in every instance.

But, if you disagree, I will move onto a policy resolution and drop the matter.

[popsofctown]

Well, it's not a forgone conclusion that this is a powerful town. The town has a mechanic that makes them use less of their roles than the scum, and so far we just a mason pair, an IC, and a vig in a 17p, no hard investigative power.

[Tana and Ephraim]

I do believe GIF wouldnt do that ever, the 1-shot vig does weaken my reason a bit, but I think pops role, specially the magic gauge part is more likely town than not. I also told RC that i do not believe CS is scum while motivating Gameplay, but RC says it's possible, and that reasoning is weaker than the reasons i have to believe pops is town, so if he wants to go there i wont oppose very harshly but i'd prefer RCE and to a lesser extent DDL and RC disagrees on those so we're having kind of an internal issue here.
-Tana

[popsofctown]

I need to remember to just use the macro.

I could stop since LE was the one I was aiming at.

But the purple is so pretty.

[Tana and Ephraim]

Also, not to mention that we're cleared both, by the fact that we got shot by scum (since no one claimed targeting us and i doubt we have 2 vigs) and by the fact that we're dying at the end of tonight anyways.
-Tana

[Titus]

*cries* RC hasn't explained to you my resolution, or anything. RC could probably figure out 90% of my role PM if he looked close enough. Maybe I'm giving him too much credit but I cannot risk being clearer.

UNVOTE: Pops
VOTE: Dann

[Tana and Ephraim]

I do think that's... quite a lot of clears, but if we got no hard investigative power it may make sense, im not that good at setup spec without more info out on the table and im not gonna request more role info when unnecessary.
-Tana

[popsofctown]

If you want to overrule RC's opinion on the strongman kill, I can redirect

(I'm absolutely not doing that, it'd waste gauge)

[Tana and Ephraim]

Also if Kats is conftown i hope he starts doing some magic soon, he's way better than me at finding scum.
-Tana

[Titus]

I do think that's... quite a lot of clears, but if we got no hard investigative power it may make sense, im not that good at setup spec without more info out on the table and im not gonna request more role info when unnecessary.
-Tana

I understand. I literally can't come up with

four

more reasons to explain.

So I'll do what I have to. Either town will be 100% protected, or we get a lock scum in 95% of scenarios.

[Bitmap]

If everyone is telling the truth, we have a lot of conf town.

[Titus]

If everyone is telling the truth, we have a lot of conf town.

That's part of why I think Pops needs to die.

I think SS might be our strongest investigative.

[Tana and Ephraim]

If you want to overrule RC's opinion on the strongman kill, I can redirect

(I'm absolutely not doing that, it'd waste gauge)

You're not 100% in the clear except for mod meta right now for RC, you said whoever you target gets notified that they got redirected so you need to make that happen, as much as it hurts me to ask a potential redirector to redirect something.
-Tana

[Bitmap]

I kind of still think pops could easily be scum.

The extra transformation gauge also helps scum FYI.

[Tana and Ephraim]

I kind of still think pops could easily be scum.

The extra transformation gauge also helps scum FYI.

Not as much when scum has the backup gauge.
-Tana