Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Marquis]

I'm uneasy with everything here.

[PenguinPower]

So lay out what you would like to do then.

[PenguinPower]

I mean - that's a really non-productive statement with less than 2 days to go.

[Vecna]

if you have a great argument why its bingle instead, im willibg to listen marquis. absent that, im just gonna follow the read ive had the entire game.

[Croag]

um stop

it is NOT JJD because thats means it has to be JJD and me OR JJD and PP and i do not think PP is scum

and i am not scum

ergo it is NOT JJD

please unvote

[Vecna]

why is everyone repeating themselves instead of answering questions that people ask to inform their decision?

Play the damn game

[Croag]

No, I have every valid reason to completely go against this lynch

Look, Vecna I can answer your question regarding you vs. Bingle another time. But this is more of a pressing matter.

From my point of view, JJD literally cannot be scum. Why?

- The only possibility that JJD can be scum is if PP is his partner.
- But, PP is voting JJD at this late stage of a game when he could just hammer Bingle and end the game.
- Which means, PP and JJD are not partners.
- Which means, JJD is confirmed innocent.
- So the final scum is remaining between Marquis, Vecna and Bingle.
- Marquis shot scum very early on. Amazing buss, or a towny move?
- Vecna is only remaining non-caffeinated member, which means he must be town.
- Bingle is literally confirmed scum.


@Vecna, @PP - if you scumread JJD please vote me instead and get this over with lol.

It is either:

- Bingle scum
- PP alone is scum
- Me and JJD are scum (this is not the case)
- Me alone is scum (this is not the case)

- It CANNOT be PP/JJD because PP is voting him when he could just win the game


If you town read me then unvote JJD please

@Vecna does this answer your question. Does it matter if I scumread you earlier. If you are the only non caffeinated person remaining then you have to be town so my opinion has changed

[Bingle]

No, I have every valid reason to completely go against this lynch

Look, Vecna I can answer your question regarding you vs. Bingle another time. But this is more of a pressing matter.

From my point of view, JJD literally cannot be scum. Why?

- The only possibility that JJD can be scum is if PP is his partner.
- But, PP is voting JJD at this late stage of a game when he could just hammer Bingle and end the game.
- Which means, PP and JJD are not partners.
- Which means, JJD is confirmed innocent.
- So the final scum is remaining between Marquis, Vecna and Bingle.
- Marquis shot scum very early on. Amazing buss, or a towny move?
- Vecna is only remaining non-caffeinated member, which means he must be town.
- Bingle is literally confirmed scum.


@Vecna, @PP - if you scumread JJD please vote me instead and get this over with lol.

It is either:

- Bingle scum
- PP alone is scum
- Me and JJD are scum (this is not the case)
- Me alone is scum (this is not the case)

- It CANNOT be PP/JJD because PP is voting him when he could just win the game


If you town read me then unvote JJD please

@Vecna does this answer your question. Does it matter if I scumread you earlier. If you are the only non caffeinated person remaining then you have to be town so my opinion has changed

Wow. This ignores so much truth I almost think you have a shot at the presidency someday.

1. Penguin has never had the opportunity to hammer.
2. This is a post script justification for your townread.
3. You’re still hedging bets on the actual conftown.
4. There are two uncaffeinated players. One of them is Vecna, one of them is me. Your argument for Vecna being town literally applies to the guy you’re voting.

Marquis, what about this looks like anything someone who was actually thinking would post, compared to someone copying their buddy’s arguments without understanding them in the first place?

[Croag]

LMAO bingle the fact that youre now pushing that i am maf from the post confirms to me youre scum

4. There are two uncaffeinated players. One of them is Vecna, one of them is me. Your argument for Vecna being town literally applies to the guy you’re voting.

i didn't know you were claiming non caffeinated lol

[Bingle]

There are 4 living players who are currently

addicted to caffeine

.

Either unvote JJD or vote me.

This is not a town post.

You’re not even trying to pretend to read. You were having better luck when you just let jjd do all of your talking.

[Croag]

fine. So it’s between you and vecna then

You and vecna can’t both be town together because you are both the only people claiming uncaffeinated

But you both can’t be uncaffeinated

Can you please stop implying I have no autonomy. Everything I am writing comes from my own brain and heart and just because you don’t like that I am going for you doesn’t make me scum

[Vecna]

PP could easily be voting his partner. theres no risk in bussing.

If it ever comes into hammer range, he wants to be on the wagon to win a 1v1 against you tomorrow croag. If the wagon on bingle ever gets to three he can insta swap for the win. hell need three other votes there regardless so he doesnt have to be on the wagon untill thats the case

[Bingle]

Can you please stop implying I have no autonomy. Everything I am writing comes from my own brain and heart and just because you don’t like that I am going for you doesn’t make me scum

I’ll bite. How many of the posts I made this phase have you read? Because from where I’m sitting that number appears to be countable on one hand with fingers left over. And I don’t see a reason for town you to just ignore half of the content for the entire player list.

[Bingle]

I have stuff to do on site in about 8 hours. I can’t guarantee I’ll be able to show up between then and deadline. If you are town, croag, now is your last chance to try to convince me.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

@Vecna: You said you'd HAMMER WHOEVER. Why change your mind now??

[Marquis]

I think I still want to vote PP > Bingle > JJD here...

[Marquis]

Why can't JJD be scum alone here?

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Because both Cops got a clear on me, and one of them is a Sane Cop

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

@Marquis: If it's PP + Bingle they already won. If it's Bingle alone we have to lynch him today or he shoot Vecna tonight and wins still.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

In short, it's either me or Bingle now and we cannot No Lynch.

[Bingle]

If it’s croag or pp solo scum, lynching jjd today doesn’t hurt our chances. Lynching me loses us the game, fwiw. If you feel pp is scum alone, jjd is still the correct lynch. We literally cannot lynch scum without every town vote and there’s less than a day to deadline.

When did Vecna say he’d hammer whoever, JJD?

[Vecna]

what does it matter anyway? if marquis votes bingle i can still swap.

[Bingle]

It matters because he made it up, and we need marquis to see that.

[Bingle]

Croag doesn’t vote jjd here. She wins by running down the clock. Notice, even with direct confrontation, she doesn’t respond to any of my AI questioning, but rather accuses me of personally attacking her by saying her posts look like she has no idea what she’s saying. When you said they came across as jjd posts, she flat ignored you.

The only way town wins is marquis realizing that jjd is scum and has spent the entire phase misrepresenting things and outright lying.

Anyway, the appraiser is here. See you guys in post.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

When did Vecna say he’d hammer whoever, JJD?

Let's give Bingle the benefit of the doubt. Let's just assume he didn't see it and was too lazy to go look it up.

what does it matter anyway? if marquis votes bingle i can still swap.

But Vecna acknowledges he did say that..

It matters because he made it up, and we need marquis to see that.

Yet that wasn't enough for Bingle and he is trying to convince VECNA that VECNA didn't say that!!!!!!!!!!!

Actually fuck it, ill just sit on the sidelines and hammer whatever comes first.

I absolutely made that one up. Sure. Bingle is using every psychological trick in the book to get someone to vote me.. either Marquis or Croag. He either wants Marquis to

mistakingly

think I'm lying, or he wants Croag to doubt solid logic and forfeit the game.

I have nothing more to say.