Baton Pass [Game Over!]

[Oversoul]

I find it so interesting that players like RC and ceph are so quick to the “you’re being mean to me” line when nothing mean was even said it was just disagreement.

Anyway, if Cephrir is scum I think Gay dance has a good chance of flipping scum too.

[Oversoul]

Also I don’t get the “we need to wait to baton until we decide the two kills”

Doesn’t it not matter? Someone can just hold the baton?

[Wisdom]

the first becomes bp, otherwise other baton passes are not important

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

So if we assume
1. RC is town (Nancy makes reading the slot easier I heard) = p
2. If RC is town and RC says shoshin is scum, then Shoshin is scum. (Apparently he was never wrong on Shoshin before!) = p*q -> r
3. RC says Shoshin is scum (Believe me this is a true statement) = q

Then we can prove that Shoshin is scum (r)!

1. p Given
2. p*q -> r Given
3. q Given
4. p * q Conjunction
5. r 2, 4, Modus Ponens

Simple logic really

[Wisdom]

If RC is town and RC says shoshin is scum, then Shoshin is scum. (

umm

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

What's inside the parenthesis is very important!

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

Like, if he read someone correctly 100% of the time so far as he states, assuming that he'll get it wrong this time is a gambler'a fallacy.

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

So in order for my proof in 1028 to break, either 1 or 2 have to be proven false. Can you prove them false?

[Oh]

did I miss anything important

-Edmund Duke, Alpha Squadron

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

Edmund Duke dies to spawn broodling in the missing The Culling.
Other then that, no.

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

In the mission*

[Oh]

you're mean

[Ankamius]

ego

[Wisdom]

Like, if he read someone correctly 100% of the time so far as he states, assuming that he'll get it wrong this time is a gambler'a fallacy.

thats bs and you know it

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

Like, if he read someone correctly 100% of the time so far as he states, assuming that he'll get it wrong this time is a gambler'a fallacy.

thats bs and you know it

Which part? The former or latter?
If former, go and ask RC and I'm sure he'll gladly provide you the documents.
If latter, that is literally the definition if gambler'a fallacy

[Nachomamma8]

Once a Baton Holder has been decided upon by majority vote (or plurality, if no majority is reached by deadline), all discussion ceases.

[Nachomamma8]

Like, if he read someone correctly 100% of the time so far as he states, assuming that he'll get it wrong this time is a gambler'a fallacy.

thats bs and you know it

Which part? The former or latter?
If latter, that is literally the definition if gambler'a fallacy

is it though?

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

If what RC states is true that he has never failed to read Shoshin correctly even in the harshest of times, why should I believe that he'll be wrong here? That sounds like suboptimal, to say the least.

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

From the past few pages I've read, I think personal bias is a big issue here. So I'm trying to approach with logic alone.

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

And because 1028 is a valid logical deduction (trust me, it's an easy one.), now all we have to talk about is the validity of #1 and #2!
(Since #3 cannot be unproven)

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

So in order to prove that shoshin is not scum, all y'all have to do is either

1. RC is not town
or
2. RC can not read Shoshin correctly 100% of the time!

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

Prove that*

[Something_Smart]

RC are you gambitting to get the BP rn because I legitimately don't see this and your argument feels a bit lazy.

[Oh]

In the games I've played with RC and Shoshin simultaneously, he's been wrong on her in both of them. Granted, one of those times he was scum, but just bringing this up in case anyone cares.

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

Link?