Baton Pass [Game Over!]

[Oh]

I think town is already on a lose trajectory

And it's not because of Shoshin or RC being scum

-Edmund Duke, Alpha Squadron

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

this game is getting hard to follow

[Something_Smart]

Meanwhile SS is explicitly going down that path and ur like yeah he's town I disagree in a friendly manner lulul

I was just about to say this, Ceph. There's absolutely potential town motivation in wanting to lynch RC after a Shoshin townflip.

[YukzYuk]

I mean he still trs you so he is aware that there is town motivation

It's just when it's me it doesn't exist even when it doesn't even apply

[gameplay506]

Hey so
I will start my reread
It turns out I have 50 pages to read and I was procrastinating too much
Gonna do it page by page 'cus I will lose track of posts if I try to summarize it all in one

Page 5:

Cephrir is one grumpy boar but he cute
123 is just pointless

Page 6:

128 Eh
138 I mean you replaced into that game, didn't provide a lot of content and died the same night. I couldn't really get too familiar with your playstyle. So I'm looking at those posts restricted only by this game and they stand out.

Page 7:

I like OS tone here. His posts flow naturally/ don't come off as fabricated
Soshin makes another stiff comment. Eh
This seems to be a trend for this game tho
Hey SH do you usually have formed reads on page 7 ( btw you made this post on page 7, its page 50 something which means 40 pages in. What you got as reads?)

Page 8:

184 RC I SEE YOU
185 you tr both, cool, me too
189 She hasn't been striking me as anything strong rn dunno why this exists
Btw the stiff comment from last page applies a lot to Dann. I find him different from what he was in MG even in the early game where he was a bit more serious than late
190 MMM, I haven't given it much thought, but idk, not really? Tho I might be misunderstanding this so if you can explain
191 Weird vibe from the sorry SS line
192 Lets not do magic girls again, they have only posted twice lol
197 I yell ^

Page 9:

219 Ah I think I understand now. I agree?
I can't get anything of the Wisdom/SH exchange about Nacho, sorry

Page 10:

RC going about how he is going to die N1 gives me deja vu from MG but I think that's something typical of him
WOW is 232 scummy bad
I have liked OH so far and 239 is quite good. Might be because I see where they are coming from, might be because I like the flow of the post, might be because he ACTUALLY HAS THE COURAGE(and patience) TO FIGHT RC but I like it.
I can get behind what Gay Dance is proposing too
243 Eh. I mean it raises opposition because you voted him after 2 posts when he basically said nothing AI. And you seem to have a weird attitude towards that slot for the last 2 pages.
I still like Gay Dance but its something to mark.
248 Getting a universal agreement from all players with what to do with the baton will most likely go wrong. JUST SAYING

Page 11:

257 Wut, where did this come from
269 Yes
This was it huh

Page 12:

I think that the one with a strange obsession for RC is Yukz who seems to only like to talk about him and not really bother with anything else
Like why?
284 EH
Yukz
Sorry but what Wisdom is saying makes sense, don't fight me for that RC
Since I have to mention Yukz for the third time, I really don't like him

Page 13:

300 Amazing
302Hey I haven't mentioned SS but at best he is a null. His openning was weird, his remarks are not very exciting and so far he hasn't been up to much. So why is this?
305Ah, an answer to the above. And he doesn't seem stiff now?
SS lol
OS talk I can't really join in so on to

Page 14:

329 I wanna know why
336That is just a bad proposal.
Shoshin seems to be in the RC fanclub as well
I wanna know why Wisdom too, maybe we get an explanation next page?

Page 15:

350 I don't understand what you are getting at with those
That he is filler posting? If so, I think he isn't alone there
362is more nice posting from OH
Nacho has a ok-ish/good-ish entrance post
The self-conscious argument about Wisdom is cool but shoshin is definitely not as towny as other slots so what is that vote Dann

THIS IS GOING SLOWER THAN I THOUGHT
Gonna split it in several posts so that i don't clog the thread with mine

[gameplay506]

Oof that looks just badly structured
Hope its readable guys

[gameplay506]

To sum up: OS, Oh, Gay dance kinda are good
Wisdom near that level
If all the celestial posting is RC then I can't really form much of a read there tho what has been posted is consistent with MG imo
SH is meh. I guess I expected more from her
Shoshin is so-so . I haven't been a fan of him tho the wisdom take bad at first glance can totally come from town
Yukz, SS, PM are not good

[gameplay506]

I will do more in a bit

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

shoshin what's your take on nancy

[Shoshin]

Who is Nancy?

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

believe it or not, rc has a hydra partner

[Shoshin]

Yes, I'm aware. She's been underwhelming, as I've already said.

[Shoshin]

Gameplay still feels like scum.

[gameplay506]

Do explain

[Cephrir]

I mean he still trs you so he is aware that there is town motivation

It's just when it's me it doesn't exist even when it doesn't even apply

i downgraded him from my top town tier for that, but i may be overreacting

i want to think your response here is scummy, but it isn't

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

also this whole rc vs shoshin feels off to me for some reason to the point that i can kinda see svs from all this, and I cannot pinpoint why.

[Cephrir]

i somehow like that post despite/because of it being mostly unintelligible

[Shoshin]

i somehow like that post despite/because of it being mostly unintelligible

Which post?

[Nachomamma8]

WELL THAT DIDN'T GO WELL

[Gay Dance Gone Wrong]

nacho i really don't want to make anyone suffer but
can you go through past few pages of rc vs shoshin and tell me if anything pings?
i need to know if it's my mafia intuition kicking in or i'm being affected by what i think of the game right now

[gameplay506]

I am still waiting for a reply shoshin

[Nachomamma8]

Yes, correct. The fact that I'm playing this game is a town-tell. It might not appear that way to you, because you don't know me, but that doesn't change the reality of the fact that it's very unlikely I would have confirmed my role if I was scum. I've said this before in other games where I was town, for context, so this isn't something I'm making up. This is my last game for the next two years, and I definitely wouldn't be spending it playing scum. That's just a fact, yes it might seem unethical, but I wasn't even sure I wanted to play more mafia because I was scared of getting a mafia PM. I only signed up for this game because NSG invited me and it seemed like a fun setup to play.

My contribution to the shoshin-RC debacle is that the above reallyy doesn't seem like something that comes from scum here. It's mitigated a bit by it being something they've said as town before (and am aware that they said it as town), but this is 1) pretty deep emotional manipulation if scum here, 2) kinda skeevy and something that they acknowledge is pretty skeevy, and 3) backed up by a strong confrontation of RC that I don't really think comes from scum!Shoshin based on the relationship that they seem to have.

[Nachomamma8]

I've never used a trust tell, and like I said, this is my last game on the site for over two years. Just for context, I'm leaving in two months -- I'll be serving in the Peace Corps in a small village in Africa and I don't expect to have internet. This IS my last game on here, and if I get banned, then so be it, but I can assure you I wasn't going to play scum for my last game. I'd rather be banned than waste my time doing something I hate.

Like this is basically never scum.

[Nachomamma8]

Hey so
I will start my reread
It turns out I have 50 pages to read and I was procrastinating too much
Gonna do it page by page 'cus I will lose track of posts if I try to summarize it all in one

I'm tempted to scumread gameplay for that beginning of a catch-up alone.

[gameplay506]

But it's a catchy song