Open 767: Nomination Mafia [Day 7]

[Creature]

I could see Titus and PM being scum together.

[Joey_]

Ive seen scum PM and I am thinking hes town

Do people tell you your reads are bad a lot?

Never post game

[chennisden]

VC 2.3:

Titus (3)	Awoo 380, Menalque 391, NorwegianboyEE 479
NorwegianboyEE (1)	PMysterious, 492
Correspondence (1)	Titus 354
Not Voting (5)	pisskop 484, Joey_ 485, Creature, Dongempire, Correspondence

[chennisden]

GuiltyLion replaces Correspondence.

Still searching for replacement for Dongempire.

[GuiltyLion]

Hi everyone!

I'm a little busy tonight but I'll read the game and try to give some thoughts ASAP, hopefully at least one post within the next 4-5 hours. Then I'll be around all day tomorrow. In the meantime if there's any major/important events you'd like me to give thoughts on after catchup, let me know

[Titus]

Omg, it's been ages GL. I'd like to see your content.

Just so you know hyper post Titus isn't a thing atm.

[pisskop]

lol

[NorwegianboyEE]

Titus do you have nothing more to say?
Also hi new nominee.

[Joey_]

I feel bad for the mod

[Menalque]

Hi everyone!

I'm a little busy tonight but

I'll read the game and try to give some thoughts ASAP,

hopefully at least one post within the next 4-5 hours. Then I'll be around all day tomorrow. In the meantime if there's any major/important events you'd like me to give thoughts on after catchup, let me know

this went well

did u make the one post in the scum PT instead of here by accident?

[Awoo]

No offense but can anyone quite any post in any game on this website where someone said they were going to do something in X hours and then they actually did it?

[Menalque]

awoo how do you feel about joey atm?

[chennisden]

Sujimichi replaces Dongempire.

[Sujimichi]

Hi everyone!

I'm a little busy today but I'll definitely make another post within the next 1 hour.

[Sujimichi]

Probably sooner than an hour to be quite honest.

[Sujimichi]

No offense but can anyone quite any post in any game on this website where someone said they were going to do something in X hours and then they actually did it?

Hi everyone!

I'm a little busy today but I'll definitely make another post within the next 1 hour.

Probably sooner than an hour to be quite honest.

[Sujimichi]

Ok. That was fun. I'm going to catch up now.

[Menalque]

are you an alt suji?

[PMysterious]

PM’s entire ISO is literally him describing the game and trying to look like he’s doing stuff while avoiding meaningful solving

It is not a town ISO

Until you know the answer to the question you are possessing, there is no such thing as meaningful solving.

Why did Mafia put scum-read players on the chopping block instead of prominent town players? Titus has been scum read by other players (yes, I read this game), Correspondence has been inactive and just now replaced, and Norway, as mentioned, hammered after declaring intent (yes, that is true), but without giving Mutant a chance to respond. In Day 2, wouldn't you put in 3 of the biggest town reads into the nomination pool just to sack one of them off? Even numbered days are glorified night kills to an extent, so why did scum go with these 3 in particular? Especially one that has been inactive with only 2 posts, neither of which holding that much substance. That's implying of course, that all three of them are town.

If one of them wasn't, then why would they put their lives on the line when simply put, they don't have to?

These are the questions that I have, and I want to work together with everyone to figure them out. The reason I suspect Norway of being Mafia, is because of the selfish decision to hammer without giving Mutant a chance to defend after declaring intent. If there was any particular reason for him to do this as Town, then he would have mentioned it during twilight, but he didn't. What reason as Town do you have to declare intent to hammer only to not give the person you're hammering the ability to defend his case? It's a scummy tactic in my mind, and sure, it works differently than most, but I still don't like it nonetheless.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Why did Mafia put scum-read players on the chopping block instead of prominent town players?

This sounds like the sort of question scum pretending to be town would ask in this game.
Do you Townread Titus?

[GuiltyLion]

alright I've read up, sorry for not posting last night I got a wee bit drunker than I anticipated

I think Menalque/Joey/Awoo are town. I'm on board with scum!Titus - the sequence of posts where she just ripped into Mutant's reads vibed to me like scum securing the mislynch, there was no town incentive to rail so hard for the lynch there on an obviously bad wagon. Also think PM is scummy-looking and I agree with 465, though I'm not sure that necessarily means they are scum together

also this was a noteworthy scum post from Dong that I don't think anyone called out:

Dont really get your townread on me though mutant, i ascertain that i havent done much to earn that so far, and my activity has been lacking

this was his only post in twilight and it's to argue with an already lynched player about why he shouldn't be townread. There's no game solving purpose at all it's purely a LAMIST post.

[GuiltyLion]

pisskop why did you unvote Titus when I replaced in?

[GuiltyLion]

Does anybody strongly think scum!Norwegian boy would also nom himself with scum!Titus against a lurk slot? I agree the intent-hammer sequence was bad and the way he pivoted from voting my slot to voting Titus didn't feel super real but end of the day I have to think it's most likely that there's two town in this first pool

[Menalque]

Does anybody strongly think scum!Norwegian boy would also nom himself with scum!Titus against a lurk slot? I agree the intent-hammer sequence was bad and the way he pivoted from voting my slot to voting Titus didn't feel super real but end of the day I have to think it's most likely that there's two town in this first pool

I mean, not strongly but I've considered it

like they figure they can both push the inactive and do some distancing, but that worst case scenario Norwegian prob goes over Titus bc of the hammer and then Titus gets locktowned by everyone because ScUm WoULdn'T PuT tWo PeOpLe iN tHe lYnChpOoL

[Menalque]

also I mixed your replacement up with suji's lol