Sell me on them! Do you think what I posted wrt their argument was wrong?In post 351, Chemist1422 wrote:I'm pretty comfortable with both of my votes so far tbh
The threshold is significantly more likely not absolutely guaranteedIn post 348, Nachomamma8 wrote:In the meantime, Chennis and Elements both seem like they're grating each other but I don't think either are significantly likelier to be scum as a result. The meat of chennis's push seems to be "he's asking questions in the same way as last game" and the meat of Elements's push seems to be "he wouldn't be fucking up this bad if he were town".
To Chennis, I think that you might be conflating "playstyle" with "meta-relevant scumposting". As scum, Elements is probably going to try to mimic his normal playstyle (as most people do) and dig at angles that they believe they will take as town. You might not like his questions here (and you might have disliked his questions in his scum game), but why is it out of the question for him to ask questions that you dislike as town?
To Elements, I think that people overestimate how well others can read them, and playing with someone frequently doesn't necessarily mean that you're able to read them instantly. We are also hyper-aware of what makes us town or scum, but that doesn't necessarily mean that anyone else is going to pick up on it. And chennis, after you stomped him in the last game, is likely to be HYPERVIGILANT in attempting to catch you as scum in this game. Do you really think that he's likely to be scum here based on misreading you alone?
In post 340, Elements wrote:do it
In post 343, Elements wrote:akaIn post 342, Ginngie wrote:I mean the energy of the crowd is that we're all waiting on mastina and Nacho to post
at least that is what it feels like
So go off
do it
In post 333, Elements wrote:Thank you. I aim to amuse.In post 332, chennisden wrote:this is kinda funny elements
In post 70, Elements wrote:can you obvtown as scum?In post 69, Oversoul wrote:It’s ok. Becoming obvtown is the only thing I can do. I can’t play scum, I can’t scumhunt, but I can obvtownIn post 61, Elements wrote:I don't understand how apparently eveyone except me can be obvtown. My scum game is so obvious to see. I'm so much more passive and less erratic.
In post 61, Elements wrote:I don't understand how apparently eveyone except me can be obvtown. My scum game is so obvious to see. I'm so much more passive and less erratic.
You posted nothing that directly contradicts either of my readsIn post 377, Nachomamma8 wrote:Sell me on them! Do you think what I posted wrt their argument was wrong?In post 351, Chemist1422 wrote:I'm pretty comfortable with both of my votes so far tbh
What's wrong with his progression on Oversoul? He healed him then hurt him within the first 4 pages and then asked him questions, unless I'm missing something here.In post 384, Chemist1422 wrote:I didn't like Elements' progression on Oversoul, and I'm townreading chennis for meta
It's not my expectation that you get anything from my entry posts; as I alluded to before, was posting distracted but also trying to post period so I wasn't just a ball of nothingness. If you get nothing from my full catch-up, then maybe it's time to panic.In post 388, Xayah wrote:Anyone else get nothing from the Mastina and Nacho posts or is it just me
@Elements:In post 44, Elements wrote:as I said, I'm feeling volatileIn post 40, chennisden wrote:That was not a towny reaction Elements
I liked this post a lot, and took a quick skim of the other Undertale game since it's been brought up to see if this is something be might post as scum, and I really don't think it is? His scum play in Undertale 1.0 was fine, but it feels like he's interacting with people in a much more genuine and nuanced way here than he was there.In post 49, Elements wrote:Why are you feeling I'm town?
normally when I play this way I'm universally scum read
Would most certainly agree with your assessment here.In post 61, Elements wrote:I don't understand how apparently eveyone except me can be obvtown. My scum game is so obvious to see. I'm so much more passive and less erratic.
its not just you.In post 388, Xayah wrote:Anyone else get nothing from the Mastina and Nacho posts or is it just me
Oh. And we identify 7 townies and win because there are night kills in this game. We also do so without flips and without the possibility of people getting lynched, which makes it a considerably harder win condition to meet than it would be in a normal game. Which is what I think people messed up last time.In post 11, Wisdom wrote:We identify four townies and win. Townhunting is better than scumhunting and this playerlist is good for application
...he says as he gets paranoid of towncho and with the knowledge that scumcho has fooled him multiple times in the past.In post 87, Wisdom wrote:nacho is easy to readIn post 82, Nymph wrote:I just like your thought process.In post 77, Wisdom wrote:I think youre echoing me.
mastina sure its hard for me too
Not sure yet! I'm still catching up.In post 396, Wisdom wrote:so who is scum, nacho?
I think that Oversoul has low enough confidence in his scum game that immediately declaring himself obvtown without doing anything would be out of his wheelhouse, simply because he knows he'd get static for it and he'd be afraid of that snowballing out of control and burying him.In post 102, Ginngie wrote:So first question is your thoughts on souls boldness of claiming obvtown when doing nothing in particular to make it obv. It's small in significance but hilariously enough, that's almost exactly how I planned on entering the game saying lol cool i'm town and focus on sorting you and mastina. idk like a look in the mirror type feeling.