Large Normal 223 | New Beginnings | GAME OVER

[profii]

JJD if I gifted you a day vig shot right now who would you shoot and why?

[profii]

It's interesting to note in the neighbourhood, we noted somewhat unusually that there isnt a player list of neighbours

So technically there could be a 3rd neighbour who has lurked the entire game (ps hope you are enjoying my stream of consciousness in there )

[Garmr]

It's interesting to note in the neighbourhood, we noted somewhat unusually that there isnt a player list of neighbours

So technically there could be a 3rd neighbour who has lurked the entire game (ps hope you are enjoying my stream of consciousness in there )

Be interesting if there was a 3rd person who was scum and read your convo believing that he was a gunsmith.

[profii]

It's interesting to note in the neighbourhood, we noted somewhat unusually that there isnt a player list of neighbours

So technically there could be a 3rd neighbour who has lurked the entire game (ps hope you are enjoying my stream of consciousness in there )

Be interesting if there was a 3rd person who was scum and read your convo believing that he was a gunsmith.

Why do you assume that makes them scum, opposed to me scum them town

[Garmr]

It's interesting to note in the neighbourhood, we noted somewhat unusually that there isnt a player list of neighbours

So technically there could be a 3rd neighbour who has lurked the entire game (ps hope you are enjoying my stream of consciousness in there )

Be interesting if there was a 3rd person who was scum and read your convo believing that he was a gunsmith.

Why do you assume that makes them scum, opposed to me scum them town

Couple of factors, How i'm reading you,your claim,the fact you would even bring it up, if the thread was just you two talking then I think gobble would of outed his role as traitor to you since he would know your alignment.

You know like common sense stuff.

[Cliff Booth]

catching up.

VOTE: Rick Dalton

Its either this or someone's trying to frame you.

what do you mean by this? why did alonzo claim doc? wtf is going on

I feel like alonzo was just gamethrowing tbh

[Cliff Booth]

How big is the neighbourhood cliff? Probably looking at some town in there.

Kop can you give a reads list with enough detail that I can have any confidence you've caught up?

I'll post sometime after work.

-hop

I truthfully do not understand what the fuck you're asking me here. Like I know what a neighborhood is and I know gobble was in one but I don't understand why a traitor would be in a neighborhood (like would it be with town or scum?) or why this somehow implies me to be in one?

[EeveeLution Army]

Hmm....a traitor in a neighbourhood with a scum can actually be interesting. But that only works if neither knows the other is scum. Which someone pointed out isnt the case. Unless its a traitor and a sk.

[Cliff Booth]

See how he voted for titus then never realy did anything after that.

Makes me think he wanted to avoid lynching alonzo as he migth thought he was teh traitor. see how teh entire time he was probbing set ups rather than scum hunting

what are you talking about...? idt scum would know a traitor even exists. also ela is an easier way to shorten my name. (sidenote the "teh" procs my ocd. idk why you always type the like that)

I'm pretty sure that scum didn't know about the traitor or they surely would have caught Gook's crumb.

if I was scum I wouldn't have caught it.
I can say this with 100% confidence because you pointed it out and I still don't see it

[Cliff Booth]

I'm just going to claim

I was the other neighbour. There is no one else. Gook claimed he gunsmithed me on N1 and he was 99% sure I was town (or a scum doctor) he said he would gunsmith someone tonight, but not sure if he was going to fake the result or not. I dont need to reveal that just yet.

I will go dig through the other thread for some reads, I assume I can't quote verbatim so I will paraphrase what I find

Also, for clarity and to pre-empt questions, I'm a neighbor backup tracker. That is my full and final claim.

gunsmithed? idk what that means either

[EeveeLution Army]

Gunsmith is an investigation role thats flavour is gun/not gun.

[EeveeLution Army]

On my home site its also common as a role that grants a dayvig/vig shot but it expires at the end of the phase

[Cliff Booth]

Is a Town Macho a normal role?... I still don't get why he claimed doctor.

[Cliff Booth]

claiming masons?

It sure looks like it, and the start of Hopkirk ISO confirms it.

I don't buy it. Wayyy too fucking coincidental for 2 irl friends to get masons together. Hopkirk already claimed to be using trust tells so yeah

[Cliff Booth]

Cliff Booth, what are your reads on JJD and Billy Pilgrim?

scumlean on jjd from what I understand of what's going on, although I definitely need to do some research to determine if I really feel that way.

townreading billy for reasons u'm interested talking more about later maybe

[Cliff Booth]

The fact that I wasn't killed last night makes me suspect JJD and Eevee believe it or not. And Cliff is unfortunately being cleared of suspicion in my eyes.

why? to all of it

[Cliff Booth]

Ngl I'm actually surprised scum didn't go for you. gobbled seemed like a weird choice to me with all the claimed PRs in the game. But hey if scum wants to kill their own traitor then that works for me.

Maybe they'd rather keep conftown alive than loose someone who's this fun to play with ;D

VOTE: Judge Joseph Dredd Solid wagon ho!

just because you SR him doesn't mean you need to call him names

[Cliff Booth]

Or maybe..... Tchill....

[Tchill, Judge Joseph Dredd, Cliff Booth]

ONE of these are scum and the other two are town. Take your picks folks.

why again? btw I think it's tchill and jjd

[Cliff Booth]

Who knows titus well enough to answer this:

The theory that I could be scum in a hood with the traitor is pretty out there - I am sure most would agree.

So do we think Titus is posting this because she is considering a crazy mechanic or has some paranoia over my very close to conf-town status

Or

Is titus the sort of player to raise a crazy theory to appear paranoid, ie does Titus, as town, usually come over a bit more rational with these sorts of theories?


Personally, I think this is town motivated paranoia but I haven't played much and I dont recall playing with Titus (sorry if we have played before!)

well it makes no sense for gobbledygook to NOT claim to scum!you like immediately there since he would know you're scum.
and if it's true that in normal games scum knows there is a traitor then there's NO reason scum!you guys should shoot him, especially so early.
The only thing that would possibly even make the last sentence make sense is if somehow scum!your team thought that gobbledygook was a non-traitor that was informed that there was a traitor and even then how fucking ballsy would he have to be to come into the neighborhood like "yo whats up I know you're scum" when he wouldn't know that?

as far as reading titus on this goes I have

no clue

other than it doesn't make sense for you to be scum if it was just you two in the neighborhood.

[Cliff Booth]

y'all should take a solid second and deeply consider the normal guidelines before hanging someone up as conftown.

again, explain pls. I have a small brain

[Cliff Booth]

I feel like you don't want us talking about the Cliff wagon here Bob.

it would be a dumb wagon

[Cliff Booth]

Who knows titus well enough to answer this:

The theory that I could be scum in a hood with the traitor is pretty out there - I am sure most would agree.

So do we think Titus is posting this because she is considering a crazy mechanic or has some paranoia over my very close to conf-town status

Or

Is titus the sort of player to raise a crazy theory to appear paranoid, ie does Titus, as town, usually come over a bit more rational with these sorts of theories?


Personally, I think this is town motivated paranoia but I haven't played much and I dont recall playing with Titus (sorry if we have played before!)

well it makes no sense for gobbledygook to NOT claim to scum!you like immediately there since he would know you're scum.
and if it's true that in normal games scum knows there is a traitor then there's NO reason scum!you guys should shoot him, especially so early.
The only thing that would possibly even make the last sentence make sense is if somehow scum!your team thought that gobbledygook was a non-traitor that was informed that there was a traitor and even then how fucking ballsy would he have to be to come into the neighborhood like "yo whats up I know you're scum" when he wouldn't know that?

as far as reading titus on this goes I have

no clue

other than it doesn't make sense for you to be scum if it was just you two in the neighborhood.

idk how much this matters now that profii brough up that there potentially could have been more people in the neighborhood. Although I don't think there were other people in it.

[Cliff Booth]

I'm voting JJD when I see a VC that tells me I'm not putting him to L-1

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Ngl I'm actually surprised scum didn't go for you. gobbled seemed like a weird choice to me with all the claimed PRs in the game. But hey if scum wants to kill their own traitor then that works for me.

Maybe they'd rather keep conftown alive than loose someone who's this fun to play with ;D

VOTE: Judge Joseph Dredd Solid wagon ho!

Spoiler:

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Who knows titus well enough to answer this:

The theory that I could be scum in a hood with the traitor is pretty out there - I am sure most would agree.

So do we think Titus is posting this because she is considering a crazy mechanic or has some paranoia over my very close to conf-town status

Or

Is titus the sort of player to raise a crazy theory to appear paranoid, ie does Titus, as town, usually come over a bit more rational with these sorts of theories?


Personally, I think this is town motivated paranoia but I haven't played much and I dont recall playing with Titus (sorry if we have played before!)

Titus is the

Queen if moonlogic

. I'm a novice compared to her in that field.