Open 767: Nomination Mafia [Day 7]

[Menalque]

Is it possible that we had an all-town wagon on TSE do you think?

[Joey_]

I don't get why scum!pk would either. Strategic replace-out are officially against the rules so i prefer to believe he's an honest player and that he left because he was seriously pissed in being fosed by his you and the town

like I think the frustration was more at the cumulative problem of Menalque not looking scummy enough to be mislynchable and then getting voted for his efforts trying to shade Menalque

just gonna repeat this (genuine and unique) point

1952 is textbook NAI but yes it sounds genuine. What i meant was genuine town content, not you describing a frustration from a 3 person view in a neutral way

[Menalque]

Oh hey I got 2000 neat

[Menalque]

I feel like this is another game where I get 1-2 scum and completely miss the last one, only this time there’s no vig around to get the last one

It’s literally happened twice before to me

[Menalque]

Although again, I think this game probably solves with 1 more scum flip

[GuiltyLion]

A town mindset; You are being lynched if you don't do anything and lynching anyone else is better than letting yourself lynched

if my Lynch leads directly to pisskop's, and at this point I'm sure it will, it doesn't really matter

I also still don't think I'm the Lynch today unless Menalque/Suji/Norway changes their mind

the wagon on TSE was definitely not all town as it went through even without my vote despite me being on it when it first hit L-1. Scum definitely hopped on

[Joey_]

like reread pisskop v Menalque, especially yesterday when Menalque was in the pool

it's pretty clear pisskop wanted to set up a Lynch on Menalque at some point this game

I disagree, i think pk was frustrated town who townread menalque and it pissed him off. Its a strat to "fos" someone you tr who foses so, just so you give them less power. IMO the replace-out is always done when you are being fosed by someone you TR, not someone you SR

Also the "like reread pisskop v Menalque, especially yesterday when Menalque was in the pool" fits into a classic S tell of mine

[Joey_]

Is it possible that we had an all-town wagon on TSE do you think?

Does it really matter, especially if it was all town pool? Scum will do what they have to do

[GuiltyLion]

(b) are getting lynched tomorrow yourself

come at me bro

VOTE: melan

ftr i think awoo is statistically more likely to be scum here.

I think it's very unlikely that we don't hit scum between (suji, pk, TSE)

ewww, this is actually absolute garbage. what do you mean its unlikely we wouldnt hit scum between the simple majority of players alive in the game?

I think my vote is good on melanthrope

I think suji's effort is more real than melan's melan is trying to wrangle lynches and hammer out a plan, and thats soo much less towny than the pedantic debating im seeing.

I think awoo is the best lynch for the day.

melan isnt too bad though

Tomorrow we do vca and Lynch the lunchboxes that are trying to railroad lynches

dude, you tried to railroad lynches, you pushed tse _as_ scum, and the only reason im not stringing you up is because of your titus interactions. The same ones tse townread me for.

expresses interest in the Menalque Lynch, switches to Awoo, but then leaves himself room to go back to Menalque after I'm lynched today

[Joey_]

Misrep, he obviously voted melan for power struggle.

My point is backed when he said "ftr i think awoo is statistically more likely to be scum here", meaning he voted someone who wasn't the most likely to flip scum. Do you think that scum has this kind of nuance in their vote? Why would he feel obligated to point out that "FTR" he wasn't voting for his top sr?

[Joey_]

Menalque you owe me a flip and I am picking gl

[GuiltyLion]

sure scum would say that, it makes him look better if/when Menalque flips green. Might even leave Awoo open as a future lynch too if it serves him

Joey will you vote pisskop slot on D7 ? That's all I need rn

[GuiltyLion]

Lets just focus on the best lynch for today. We should not be brokering votes.

you wont vote tse because you feel they are obvious town. So you vote awoo instead.
tomorrow why dont you vote for your most suspicious player instead of trying to broker votes onto suboptimal lynches.

Brokering is bad for business because it leads to compromise lynches and it allows scum to play on wifom.

In these two posts he even explicitly acknowledges that compromise lynches are bad which debunks your "power struggle" explanation for his Menalque vote

[Menalque]

(prodding Correspondence)

STOP! IT'S HAMMERTIME

VC 1.5:

Mutantdevle (6)	pisskop 37, Titus 42, Correspondence 108, Menalque 124, Awoo 128, NorwegianboyEE 220
Titus (1)	Dongempire 63
PMysterious (1)	Joey_ 217
Not Voting (3)	Creature, mutantdevle 75, PMysterious 118

The enraged town was fully and absolutely convinced of Mutantdevle's guilt.

"You're the killer!" one enraged townie yelled.

"I swear, I'm innocent!" Mutantdevle was begging for his life, pleading to be spared.

"Relax," said the cops. "We'll search him for evidence."

As they said that, a raisin cookie fell out of his pocket!

"You see? He's evil! He has a

raisin cookie

!" yelled another townsperson. "You know what? I'm sick of this. You are the incarnation of evil." With that, Mutantdevle was shot thrice - once for each member of the scumteam.

"You idiots," Mutantdevle gasped with his final breath, "I was headed towards the dumpster to throw this away!" And with that he died.

Mutantdevle was a Vanilla Townie.

D2 in (expired on 2019-10-04 18:44:55).

VC 2.10:

Titus (6)	Menalque 391, NorwegianboyEE 479, Sujimichi 709, pisskop 818, GuiltyLion 882, Awoo 891
NorwegianboyEE (4)	PMysterious, 492, Titus 474, Creature 804, Joey_ 834
GuiltyLion (0)
Not Voting (0)

The coroner did a DNA test on mutantdevle, and found out that Titus had wrongly framed him!

"You murderer!" screamed a friend of mutantdevle. "You're a member of the Mafia!"

"What - what could you be talking about?"

"We have evidence!" they screamed. "Look at this!" They show Titus the gun she used yesterday to kill mutantdevle.

"Wait - wait," she said, "If you spare me I'll tell you who the other mafia are!"

At that moment two simultaneous gunshots rung out from the crowd. Nobody knew who they came from, but Titus dropped dead nonetheless.

Titus was a member of the Mafia!

I think this is a hamemr lemme count

VC 3.3

PMysterious (5)	Sujimichi 905, GuiltyLion 1114, NorwegianboyEE 1137, Joey 1179, Awoo 1195
Sujimichi (3)	pisskop 1078, Menalque 1080, TrueSoulEnergy 1149
Not Voting (1)	PMysterious

PMysterious was town

Hi lock

TSE (5): Awoo, Menalque, Norwegian, Sujimichi, Joey_
Awoo (2): TrueSoulEnergy, Pisskop
Menalque (0)
Not Voting (1): GuiltyLion

TSE is town

Sleeping just putting this here for easy reference tomorrow

[Joey_]

Lets just focus on the best lynch for today. We should not be brokering votes.

you wont vote tse because you feel they are obvious town. So you vote awoo instead.
tomorrow why dont you vote for your most suspicious player instead of trying to broker votes onto suboptimal lynches.

Brokering is bad for business because it leads to compromise lynches and it allows scum to play on wifom.

In these two posts he even explicitly acknowledges that compromise lynches are bad which debunks your "power struggle" explanation for his Menalque vote

He never meant to lynch menalque, he tried to show him he was town

[GuiltyLion]

Joey will you vote pisskop slot on D7 ? That's all I need rn

Joey do you agree me v pisskop is likely TvS yes or no

[Joey_]

I agree it's not SvS and most likely one of you are mefia

[Awoo]

p. sure GL's attitude where he's okay being lynched isn't towny since when I was in the legit consideration VS. TSE I fought him down and he fought me down

[Menalque]

VC 1.5:

Mutantdevle (6)	pisskop 37, Titus 42, Correspondence 108, Menalque 124, Awoo 128, NorwegianboyEE 220
Titus (1)	Dongempire 63
PMysterious (1)	Joey_ 217
Not Voting (3)	Creature , mutantdevle 75, PMysterious 118

VC 2.10:

Titus (6)	Menalque 391, NorwegianboyEE 479, Sujimichi 709, pisskop 818, GuiltyLion 882, Awoo 891
NorwegianboyEE (4)	PMysterious , 492, Titus 474, Creature 804, Joey_ 834
GuiltyLion (0)
Not Voting (0)

VC 3.3

PMysterious (5)	Sujimichi 905, GuiltyLion 1114, NorwegianboyEE 1137, Joey 1179, Awoo 1195
Sujimichi (3)	pisskop 1078, Menalque 1080, TrueSoulEnergy 1149
Not Voting (1)	PMysterious

TSE (5): Awoo,

Menalque

, Norwegian, Sujimichi, Joey_
Awoo (2):

TrueSoulEnergy

, Pisskop
Menalque (0)
Not Voting (1): GuiltyLion

[Menalque]

ffs

[Menalque]

VC 1.5:

Mutantdevle (6)	pisskop 37, Titus 42, Correspondence 108, Menalque 124, Awoo 128, NorwegianboyEE 220
Titus (1)	Dongempire 63
PMysterious (1)	Joey_ 217
Not Voting (3)	Creature , mutantdevle 75, PMysterious 118

VC 2.10:

Titus (6)	Menalque 391, NorwegianboyEE 479, Sujimichi 709, pisskop 818, GuiltyLion 882, Awoo 891
NorwegianboyEE (4)	PMysterious , 492, Titus 474, Creature 804, Joey_ 834
GuiltyLion (0)
Not Voting (0)

VC 3.3

PMysterious (5)	Sujimichi 905, GuiltyLion 1114, NorwegianboyEE 1137, Joey 1179, Awoo 1195
Sujimichi (3)	pisskop 1078, Menalque 1080, TrueSoulEnergy 1149
Not Voting (1)	PMysterious

TSE

(5): Awoo,

Menalque

, Norwegian, Sujimichi, Joey_
Awoo (2):

TrueSoulEnergy

, Pisskop
Menalque (0)
Not Voting (1): GuiltyLion

[Menalque]

I'm basically waiting for a pk replacement before I effort this game again, sorry

[chennisden]

GuiltyLion (2), pisskop, Joey_
Pisskop (2): NorwegianboyEE_, GuiltyLion

[Joey_]

GL still shines by his lack of content

[GuiltyLion]

you can keep repeating that it, it doesn't make it true, I contributed a lot over the past couple of pages (including completely taking down your weak excuse for pisskop's shitty Menalque vote) and I'm not really inclined to tryhard unless it's needed if/when Menalque or Suji comes here and wants to talk about more stuff or we get a replacement