Open 767: Nomination Mafia [Day 7]

[DrCirno]

Now 90.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Now the biggest question is: how much of this 89 pages do I have to read?

E V E R Y T H I N G !

[DrCirno]

Oh also who died so far?
The OP isn't updated.

[DrCirno]

Mutant D1 Town
Titus D2 Mafia
Creature slot D3 Town
PMystetious D4 Town

[DrCirno]

Is it bad if I I townread someone from #2226 alone

[DrCirno]

(flavor incoming)

Titus, NorwegianboyEE, and Correspondence have been nominated!

I doubt they put more than 1 scum in nomination.
Norwegian and Correspondence can be town

[Menalque]

Mutant D1 Town
Titus D2 Mafia
Creature slot D3 Town
PMystetious D4 Town

TSE and PM are the other way around on D3/D4

[Menalque]

Is it bad if I I townread someone from #2226 alone

Yes

[DrCirno]

5. NorwegianboyEE
6. GuiltyLion

1. RC
3. Joey_
8. Sujimichi
9. Menalque

10. PMysterious - Town
11. pisskop (This is me!) - Town
7. Creature - Town
4. mutantdevle - Town
2. Titus - Scum

I only read modpost so far and here I am with this glorious glorious reads

[NorwegianboyEE]

No offense, but those reads are hilariously surface level. I mean i'm glad you're townreading me, but you should probably put a little bit more effort into it before TR or SR someone?

[DrCirno]

Why would scum put more than one of them in nomination?

[NorwegianboyEE]

I mean they MIGHT have put 2 scum in there to make the other one seem town if one of the scum is flipped.

[DrCirno]

No offense, but those reads are hilariously surface level. I mean i'm glad you're townreading me, but you should probably put a little bit more effort into it before TR or SR someone?

Surface level reads are best reads.

[DrCirno]

Anyway, I'll be back later this evening.
Surface level or not, I apparently only have 6 people to sort and that's welcoming.

[RadiantCowbells]

Joey you gotta see that that response to my replace in is scum lol

[Menalque]

Oh cool so you are just scum then

[RadiantCowbells]

GL I await your response.

[Menalque]

Possibilities on RC:

If RC is town, his reads are more likely than not correct

RC scumreads me:

(1) RC is actually scumresding me incorrectly

(2) RC is reaction testing

(3) RC is scum faking the read

We can rule out (2) because it looks like RC is committing to his read on me. Now, I think RC is familiar enough with me that he should see my scumgame as quite clearly separate from my town!game. As mentioned, he got me in Ruby very early on but then got distracted by FB.

Here, I’m town. I have done things that are entirely inconsistent with my scumgame (lynch titus, reconsider on numerous slots). I will make this as clear as possible but I think most of you could already see it before RC repped in.

So the question for you becomes: is RC honestly blind enough as town that he thinks I’m scum here, and you should have enough faith in his reads to just take them over your own? Or is it that RC is trying to shift the lynch onto someone who was going to be permanently a problem for scum because of how hard it would be to lynch me?

This probably also spews Joey town because otherwise I think RC knows that the strat I lined out was winning.

[RadiantCowbells]

lol

I'm not responding to Menalque right now because I want to see how GL responds because I think they he can easily be scum as well and it is probably an easier lynch progression the other way.

But this is all transparently fake

[Menalque]

It’s not and I’d expect town you to have maybe an ounce more humility after being wrong twice in a row and losing the game in baton pass

[RadiantCowbells]

You mean to the person whom I said D1 was scum and everyone told me I was wrong, same was said at the start at D2 everyone agreed, D3 everyone tried to baton pass Volke.

I was literally the only person who scumread the scum slot that game outside of half of the bitgif hydra. My opinions haven't changed.

[NorwegianboyEE]

So you're openly admitting that there is an high amount of bias in your read on Menalque?

[RadiantCowbells]

In the end I hammered who I did in lylo because of the collective reads of dead townies. Same reason I lynched Oh. I lynched Oka because of my Hydra partner.

I was the strongest townie In a game full of strong townies and trashing me for that game is a hilarious meme; every single scum was a strong D1 scumread for me and my only wrong scumread was Ceph

[Menalque]

No I mean the toxic shitshow that was you and ank, and then you voting OS in lylo

But anyway, that would presuppose your reads coming from a world in which you’re town, and this ain’t that world

[Menalque]

Point remains: I don’t think town!you misreads me this badly here, because I do believe that your reads as town are pretty good. I would also expect town!you to have a bit more humility after BP.

However, I think there are significant advantages to scum!you trying to get me lynched here. Namely the fact that without a player such as yourself coming in and hard pushing me, this was probably losing for scum. (Your play makes me think I know who the partner is but I’m n not saying until tomorrow/until after my lynch today if you manage to successfully bully people into following you.)