Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[Creature]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=74286

[Bingle]

Creature, do you smell toast right now?

[Nero Cain]

Are... are all games like this now?

in a bad playerlist, yes

[Creature]

Creature, do you smell toast right now?

No, it's not moaning yet

[Creature]

I’m going to design a game with a shitpost vig that can only shoot shitposters. Inspired by this game.

do you want a serious answer for this?

Yes

its because she comes from a time period where games were slower and more managable.
Mafia was a different game back then.
Now its more shitposty and more spammy and most people who are like "GUYS STOP FLUFFPOSTING" are like that because they were just from a different time period.

Are... are all games like this now?

You haven't seen 2017

[Creature]

Civilization mafia mainly

[Bingle]

You see, now I'm very confused because Pine is straight up not in that game.

[Creature]

I think no game will ever beat Civilization

even if we actively try to spam up this game

[Creature]

You see, now I'm very confused because Pine is straight up not in that game.

Oh shit I think I took the wrong game

[Creature]

Here is the right one: https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=80102

[Creature]

Anyone remembers this: https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=79906

[Creature]

Is it possible we have another PP role?

[Bingle]

I don't see how that nullifies the read either.

It's not a game where there was a significant amount of spam or anything Pine needed to address to pull of a clean win instead of a cheap, hollow one.

I'm not saying he can't lurk as scum (he can) I'm saying his not cautioning the thread about being nice and readable is slight townpoints.

[Bingle]

Is it possible we have another PP role?

Very unlikely. The setup was designed 7 years ago iirc.

[Bingle]

Reviewers: RichardGHP, Nachomamma8, and JacobSavage [2013]

6 years ago.

[InsideJob711]

I’m going to design a game with a shitpost vig that can only shoot shitposters. Inspired by this game.

do you want a serious answer for this?

Yes

its because she comes from a time period where games were slower and more managable.
Mafia was a different game back then.
Now its more shitposty and more spammy and most people who are like "GUYS STOP FLUFFPOSTING" are like that because they were just from a different time period.

Are... are all games like this now?

just avoid larges like the plague
minis it can happen but its way more easier to keep up with

[InsideJob711]

I think no game will ever beat Civilization

even if we actively try to spam up this game

AvP woulda beat civ if you were there tbh

[InsideJob711]

not sure why we didn't invite you exactly tbh

[Nero Cain]

you think its scummy that I'm anti-spam? lol Dude is just grasping at straws.

Just b/c YOU don't think I'm an easy read doesn't mean I have to think the same thing as you.

Also, I've been calling you scum forever so not that you are calling me scum (for weak reasons) just comes across as OMGUSY and vengeful. You're also whiteknighting Gamma here wich is yuck.

1. Being anti-spam isn't scummy. The way you're going about being anti spam is scummy.

2. I'm not saying I don't think you're an easy read. I'm saying you're routinely in everyone's POE in the endgame and the only person I can ever remember saying you were an easy read was wrongly townreading scum you. I also don't think I've ever seen you say you're an easy read before. As such, the fact that you're saying you're an easy read is scummy. If I'm wrong, you're in a unique position to show me where you've been accurately read by people in so many games before.

3. Yes, you were in my nullscum group for weak reasons. Congratulations?

4. The OMGUS accusation is kinda funny. If you think I'm wrong about Gamma town, maybe engage me about my Gamma read. It was in that same wall post where I Omgused you by posting reads of all the slots.

5. Serious question here: Have you read the rest of my post, or are you just responding to something that said your name because it said your name?

1. How?
2. It depends on the playerlist. There's been plenty of games where I was town read straight out of the gate. True, there are games where I'm not town read either the whole game or @ the very end.

"If I'm wrong, you're in a unique position to show me where you've been accurately read by people in so many games before."

this is just busywork. You can easily ISO my topics list and see that I'm not scum read all the time as you seem to imply.

The player that you are talking about is Nancy Drew (I think). Yes, in THAT game she read me wrong but how many other times has she (and others) correctly town read why. Why is her one time she was wrong more important than all the times she was right?

mean, and I know your gonna say that I'm backpeddling or w/e but yes, I'm often scum read by players not familiar with me or generally bad at this game. Also, remember that scum can easily manipulate town...so maybe I'm not an easy read for most players but that does not negate my belief that I am an easy read.

3. ??? ok?
4. What does Gamma have to do with my accusation that you were OMGUS light scum reading me? Yes, I accused you of whiteknighting Gamma but the whiteknight and OMGUS are two different accusations. Do you not know what those terms mean or are you intentionally dumbtelling?

Here im scumreading you

good d2 lynches are

bingle

gamma
icon
wopper

and my reasoning was

So why, would cultwooper be so insistent on finding out what the not a player did N0 when he knows the not a player is not a player by virtue of the fact that he's not in the cultwooper's pt?

this post is weird.

There is a cult.

They start with a leader

, recruiting once per night; however, scum recruit attempts end in death of the cult leader.

So there's only a cult leader right now and your instance that wooper hasn't been culted makes 0 sense.

We are currently at 7/40 confirmations.
As a reminder, the election doesn't start until 21/40 confirmations.
I will consider simply posting in this thread at all (instead of posting /confirm) a confirmation.

apparently the game hadn't started yet so maybe it was just a troll post but still

Now, its quite possible that this was just trolling and it's null (b/c trolling really does throw me off) but you brought this up again when EP asked for a catchup. So its either something you believe in or you are doubling down on the trolling. You've also avoided commenting on this.

And a thousand post later (1377) you are light scumreading me for what I feel oare very weak reasons. I think you are scum but for the sake of the argument... it's is certainly possible to develop a scum read later on BUT the weak reasoning feels like grasping at straws and OMGUS. And Gamma has like 0% to do with that.

But sure we can talk about him.

Gamma Emerald- Probably the most actively solve-y

is your reasoning for town reading him.

and here

Argumentative in a way that is unlikely to earn him any real ire, but is likely to make people think "Oh, that's Nero being Nero".

and here

but that the specific arguments you're picking are against Gamma (who is low impact and unlikely to be able to 1v1 you in a 40p list

are your posts chiding me over attacking Gamma. That's your whiteknight, bro.

Firstly, everything is just vague. How is Gamma being solvy? (I don't agree btw) What's wrong with my arguments with Gamma? If part of the reason you are scumreading me is for attacking Gamma what do you feel that comes from scum Nero and not town Nero?

5. I am reading your posts yes. Why do you feel this is an important question?

[chennisden]

Creature is town?

And also stop voting for gov. Just stop

[chennisden]

Just vote no gov seriously it's NOT that hard

[Formerfish]

Where are we at, i skipped the last 15 pages?

[TrueSoulEnergy]

Just vote no gov seriously it's NOT that hard

DO YOU READ?!!!!?

Scum probably has roles that harm us if we don’t have a Governor.
Given the fact that I’m Town that has an opposite Governor ability.

[EspressoPatronum]

Where are we at, i skipped the last 15 pages?

You haven't missed too much.

Still talking about gov/no gov. FL seems to be the frontrunner for gov contenders, but I think no gov is still leading.

Lots of back and forth between Gamma and NC.

[TrueSoulEnergy]

Where are we at, i skipped the last 15 pages?

You haven't missed too much.

Still talking about gov/no gov. FL seems to be the frontrunner for gov contenders, but I think no gov is still leading.

Lots of back and forth between Gamma and NC.

You forgot about me

I feel left out....