No.In post 1647, Gentleman 4 wrote:I'd like a counter for the number of players Lady 6 thinks are scum. Right now we're at 7 and rising.
Lady 6 your approach to the game is and has been a bit ridiculous. Please re-examine.
So you don't think Lady 7 is Gentleman 8's partner?In post 1650, Lady 6 wrote:No.In post 1647, Gentleman 4 wrote:I'd like a counter for the number of players Lady 6 thinks are scum. Right now we're at 7 and rising.
Lady 6 your approach to the game is and has been a bit ridiculous. Please re-examine.
G4 L4 L3 L1 G1 and G8 is my scumpool. We're at 6 and falling. I eliminated L5.
Also, we were at 6 the last time we talked, and this new list doesn't include Lady 7. We're either at 7 and rising or 6 and stable (stable in the sense that the number is constant but the players in it is changing).In post 1650, Lady 6 wrote:No.In post 1647, Gentleman 4 wrote:I'd like a counter for the number of players Lady 6 thinks are scum. Right now we're at 7 and rising.
Lady 6 your approach to the game is and has been a bit ridiculous. Please re-examine.
G4 L4 L3 L1 G1 and G8 is my scumpool. We're at 6 and falling. I eliminated L5.
No. This is a good read.In post 1324, Gentleman 6 wrote:I think that L6 is one of my top townreads. Do you think that's hasty?
Why?In post 1327, Lady 7 wrote:In post 1324, Gentleman 6 wrote:I think that L6 is one of my top townreads. Do you think that's hasty?
Absolutely 100% yes i do.
And now I know exactly who you are and glad we can pair.In post 1365, Gentleman 6 wrote:Bad question.In post 1363, Lady 5 wrote:Are you actually female?In post 1343, Gentleman 3 wrote:I shouldn't have signed up as a gentleman honestly, if I play again I won't.
I don't see what the rush is?
No.In post 1651, Gentleman 4 wrote:So you don't think Lady 7 is Gentleman 8's partner?In post 1650, Lady 6 wrote:No.In post 1647, Gentleman 4 wrote:I'd like a counter for the number of players Lady 6 thinks are scum. Right now we're at 7 and rising.
Lady 6 your approach to the game is and has been a bit ridiculous. Please re-examine.
G4 L4 L3 L1 G1 and G8 is my scumpool. We're at 6 and falling. I eliminated L5.
I wonder.In post 1647, Gentleman 4 wrote:I'd like a counter for the number of players Lady 6 thinks are scum. Right now we're at 7 and rising.
Lady 6 your approach to the game is and has been a bit ridiculous. Please re-examine.
Not really, I've been pretty straight forward on my reads and have taken positions that's really not feasible if I was scum. Try again.In post 1399, Lady 3 wrote:Look I'll reread Lady 7 before end of pre dance and see if I can grasp at what I didn't like about her earlier
But I really really think you need to read Lady 8 closer because she's been a shifty girl.
In post 1638, Lady 6 wrote:If G8 is randomly picking, why not just pick the first single lady. She's his partner.
I am really liking Jackpot's approach to solving at this point. I'd call her a solid town read.In post 567, Lady 7 wrote:Not necessarily. Could just be a personality quirk, but the discussion over "sure" felt a bit pedantic, and I really don't want to get that discussion started again at all. If you had scum read him while having that discussion I'd be looking at you with a lot more squinty faces because that could be scum indicative. The fact that you town read him and said it was for clarification means that it could just be communication/personality clash. It stood out to me as a "not quite sure what to do with this" though.In post 564, Gentleman 3 wrote:What can I say, semantics are important. Do you think my wanting people to say exactly what they mean reflects badly on me?In post 560, Lady 7 wrote:Tonally G3 feels fine most of the time, but his discussion with G6 felt a bit too much based on semantics.
I am interested in how you plan to implement your suggested approach. You say you plan to base your conclusions of of the flip of the person you pair with. How do you intend to have that work out? I feel like logistically there is something amiss.In post 569, Gentleman 2 wrote:Also if I am reading everything correctly, I get two 'lynches' worth of time / another 8 days before mafia get a 'kill' if I have matched a townie lady. So I think that is ample time to get some serious game solve happening.
I think an important question is to the ladies, given what I have said of my approach, who among you feels they are a strong hydra player / feels comfortable with me probably posting close to exclusively in the PT? I intend to lean heavily on my partner to help me parse the game and then form conclusions based on both an inevitable flip of either town or scum from my partner.
How many of these games have you played before? This has been suggested often, but no solid method of executing this idea has ever been suggested.In post 572, Gentleman 7 wrote:Actually, am I missing something?
When I think about it, isn't this just a case of finding one town lady to pair with the IC, and then...just no one else pairs up at all (Ideally we'd come up with backup pairs to organize at the last second in case scum tries to make a S/S pairing in the last minute). Although this sounds like it's starting to get really unfun.
Could it have been for what Dawn is proposing in some way?In post 574, Gentleman 6 wrote:To be honest I want to pair with L9 for reasons that aren't really related to mathematically optimizing the setup. I think it's probably a suboptimal pairing, but I don't really care.
Uh, because I was already pretty insistent that I wanted to pair with G6 since like the start of the game?In post 1443, Gentleman 5 wrote:Add to that L8 - why did you accept that so fast?In post 1441, Gentleman 5 wrote:That was fast. In fact thats the first thing L8 mentions: making sure shes going to the next round.In post 1270, Lady 8 wrote:I'm reading. I'm trying to commit to at least one catchup a day.
In post 1005, Gentleman 6 wrote:Whatever disregard correct play dance with the hottest girl.
Lady 8, will you dance with me?I accept.
G6: You mentioned it after you made the proposal but Id like to ask you again - do you think your pairing is T-T?
Drop thr nicknames, pleaseIn post 1658, Gentleman 1 wrote:I am really liking Jackpot's approach to solving at this point. I'd call her a solid town read.In post 567, Lady 7 wrote:Not necessarily. Could just be a personality quirk, but the discussion over "sure" felt a bit pedantic, and I really don't want to get that discussion started again at all. If you had scum read him while having that discussion I'd be looking at you with a lot more squinty faces because that could be scum indicative. The fact that you town read him and said it was for clarification means that it could just be communication/personality clash. It stood out to me as a "not quite sure what to do with this" though.In post 564, Gentleman 3 wrote:What can I say, semantics are important. Do you think my wanting people to say exactly what they mean reflects badly on me?In post 560, Lady 7 wrote:Tonally G3 feels fine most of the time, but his discussion with G6 felt a bit too much based on semantics.
My goal right now is to have a functional read list by the time I am caught up, and be ready to send a missive to my Lady of choice at that time as well.I am interested in how you plan to implement your suggested approach. You say you plan to base your conclusions of of the flip of the person you pair with. How do you intend to have that work out? I feel like logistically there is something amiss.In post 569, Gentleman 2 wrote:Also if I am reading everything correctly, I get two 'lynches' worth of time / another 8 days before mafia get a 'kill' if I have matched a townie lady. So I think that is ample time to get some serious game solve happening.
I think an important question is to the ladies, given what I have said of my approach, who among you feels they are a strong hydra player / feels comfortable with me probably posting close to exclusively in the PT? I intend to lean heavily on my partner to help me parse the game and then form conclusions based on both an inevitable flip of either town or scum from my partner.How many of these games have you played before? This has been suggested often, but no solid method of executing this idea has ever been suggested.In post 572, Gentleman 7 wrote:Actually, am I missing something?
When I think about it, isn't this just a case of finding one town lady to pair with the IC, and then...just no one else pairs up at all (Ideally we'd come up with backup pairs to organize at the last second in case scum tries to make a S/S pairing in the last minute). Although this sounds like it's starting to get really unfun.Could it have been for what Dawn is proposing in some way?In post 574, Gentleman 6 wrote:To be honest I want to pair with L9 for reasons that aren't really related to mathematically optimizing the setup. I think it's probably a suboptimal pairing, but I don't really care.
No it's most likely town who leaves. I've never seen scum leave in any of these dance games.In post 1484, Gentleman 4 wrote:I think fearing someone else leaving is much more real for scum than town, and even if you disagree with me on this, why is this a fear that scum would have to fake? You're proposing my approach to your dilemma as one with only two options, but I think one of these isn't even close to one of the most likely probabilities.In post 1482, Gentleman 3 wrote:Why is that something I might fake concern for as scum, but for which I'd be less likely to really have concern for as town?
What are the odds that I don't think leaving is REALLY a big issue for town, but I'm scum and I'm pretending I do, because I think it will bring me some advantage?
I think you probably should of paired with L6. She has >rand town chance.In post 1495, Gentleman 8 wrote:Hello again, good citizens!
The volume of communication here is simply staggering, and I struggle to keep up, particularly while wearing this excellent and most efficacious mask, which, while handsome, leaves much to be desired for eye-holes.
I am entirely flexible with regard to a partner. I find most of the judgments discussed here premature. Either I am paired with a good and talented dancer, in which case I shall be delighted to waltz the night away, or I shall be paired with one who steps on toes and uses the wrong fork at dinner. In the latter case, I will be delighted to do the company a service and leave the dance with her. To wit, based on Gentleman 4's list,
Lady Lucky #7, will you dance with me?
That's not what I'm getting at.In post 1661, Lady 8 wrote:No it's most likely town who leaves. I've never seen scum leave in any of these dance games.In post 1484, Gentleman 4 wrote:I think fearing someone else leaving is much more real for scum than town, and even if you disagree with me on this, why is this a fear that scum would have to fake? You're proposing my approach to your dilemma as one with only two options, but I think one of these isn't even close to one of the most likely probabilities.In post 1482, Gentleman 3 wrote:Why is that something I might fake concern for as scum, but for which I'd be less likely to really have concern for as town?
What are the odds that I don't think leaving is REALLY a big issue for town, but I'm scum and I'm pretending I do, because I think it will bring me some advantage?
Agreed. G8 doesn't look good here.In post 1507, Gentleman 5 wrote:I dont like thisIn post 1495, Gentleman 8 wrote:Hello again, good citizens!
The volume of communication here is simply staggering, and I struggle to keep up, particularly while wearing this excellent and most efficacious mask, which, while handsome, leaves much to be desired for eye-holes.
I am entirely flexible with regard to a partner. I find most of the judgments discussed here premature. Either I am paired with a good and talented dancer, in which case I shall be delighted to waltz the night away, or I shall be paired with one who steps on toes and uses the wrong fork at dinner. In the latter case, I will be delighted to do the company a service and leave the dance with her. To wit, based on Gentleman 4's list,
Lady Lucky #7, will you dance with me?
This is your second time saying this, which I don't object to much but I am curious what gave you the impression Orange is a town powerhouse at this time. I would say Jackpot is a better pick for a town powerhouseIn post 581, Lady 5 wrote:If both Gent 1 and Lady 8 are town.
They will by far be the power house town needs to win.
The reason Gent 2 should go with Lady 7 is because Lady 7 is feel could be the most possible Deep Wolf so making the confirmed Town partners with them could help in the long run.
As for Gent 5 with Gent 2 I also feel another power house town can be made.
With both their play style’s together it can make with some good late game solving
I’ll now be gone for the day.
Cya.
I would have asked about this but I read the mod's posts and it seems like it would not do much. Also, I don't know who the person in G2's current avatar is, but he looks like Adam from the show Adam Ruins Everything so that's what I am going to call him now.In post 586, Gentleman 2 wrote:F - But tbh I am actually kinda ok with this one.
I have been maintaining my stability by writing my posts here in a way that I feel is contrary to my standard posting style, as well as avoiding mixing up which account I am using to check on the game. I am using my main account to just make cursory checks and using this one when I actually am trying to be involved.In post 596, Gentleman 2 wrote:There's a solution G7. Which is for people to not fuck up.
Like I am only playing this game in an incognito tab and not opening it or tracking it on any other account.
In post 1540, Lady 5 wrote:What’s everyone’s Reads on me exactly?
These two posts are scummy.
Oh, I misread that entirely. M' bad.In post 1664, Gentleman 4 wrote:That's not what I'm getting at.In post 1661, Lady 8 wrote:No it's most likely town who leaves. I've never seen scum leave in any of these dance games.In post 1484, Gentleman 4 wrote:I think fearing someone else leaving is much more real for scum than town, and even if you disagree with me on this, why is this a fear that scum would have to fake? You're proposing my approach to your dilemma as one with only two options, but I think one of these isn't even close to one of the most likely probabilities.In post 1482, Gentleman 3 wrote:Why is that something I might fake concern for as scum, but for which I'd be less likely to really have concern for as town?
What are the odds that I don't think leaving is REALLY a big issue for town, but I'm scum and I'm pretending I do, because I think it will bring me some advantage?
Why is he proposing that only a town player would be concerned with their partner leaving?
Based on previous experiences, this is incorrect.In post 1545, Lady 5 wrote:If I was scum I would have instantly accepted Gent 5’s proposal. Did you think of that?
In post 1593, Lady 5 wrote:@Mod
Is it possible to replace Out and grab someone to replace in?
That way no one will know I replaced out, and I’ll find someone who’s so good you wouldn’t even notice the replace out but they play better.
Also someone who keeps the PFP and Town reads Gent 3.
Are you new to mafia? Please stop.In post 1595, Lady 5 wrote:If I can I’ll get an actual lady to sub into this slot.
Or even
@Mod
Is Hydra allowed?
I can, but I'll probably be out for a few hours to get some food with friends.In post 1671, Lady 3 wrote:Lady 8 wanna chat over some coffee and bagels
