Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[InsideJob711]

I will hang around for just a bit longer before I log off this acc for a bit
So if people want to talk to me about actual game stuff, we can talk actual game stuff

Yes, let’s. What are your reads? Have you shared any?

If you listed a name I could give you my read on them.
Like, I have a ton of townreads.
I think that this is probably town nero but he's acting pretty scummy.
I think ur town, I think bbmolla is town
I think Bingle is good enough to give a d1 pass too

I have like, a lot more, and if you gave me a couple of names, I could give you a read on them.

I don’t really want to coach you into reads.

don't.
List a name, we'll have a conversation.

Firebringer.

i'll iso it now

[Amrun]

Whos gov

This moron is probably town or he’d have asked this in his scum PT.

[Donempire]

We dont have cyrus to spam

I was top poster in that game by far bruh

If cyrus didnt lose interest near the end and got confused by me he'd definitely be shitting the thread up more
And half your posts were music videos

[InsideJob711]

not super impressive definitely not a townread

[InsideJob711]

I remember hearing you putting out a case for that
I'll try to find it and check it out

[Donempire]

Whos gov

This moron is probably town or he’d have asked this in his scum PT.

Lmfao XDXD you got me good fella

Thanks for your insight

[InsideJob711]

I don't really feel like fire or Mel are all that scummy. Did you read my wooper case?

I did. To be honest I didn’t find it that compelling but I took note of it. It’s probably a better lynch than Creature, though.

Firebringer I actually think is scum.

Have you made a case?

In my opinion, yes. You can ISO me. I think he slipped and spoke from a place of knowledge that BBmolla is town. Others didn’t see it the same way, and it’s certainly not bulletproof, but I have seen nothing more lynchworthy yet.

this isn't something I buy persay but like
you do you

I don't buy it mostly because "They're classic X" is something Fire says decently often.

[Formerfish]

We dont have cyrus to spam

I was top poster in that game by far bruh

If cyrus didnt lose interest near the end and got confused by me he'd definitely be shitting the thread up more
And half your posts were music videos

How dare you. I will have you know I'm about to break onto the first page for posts made in games...

Its a big deal for me. i feel like ive accomplished something and nothing at all. Very trippy.

[Firebringer]

I don't buy it mostly because "They're classic X" is something Fire says decently often.

shut up alisae im obvi scum

[Amrun]

Bbmolla is acting scummy (for him)

nope, this is pretty standard bbmolla

I’ve played mafia with him in person and many times.

Obviously, it’s not a terribly reliable read given his what, ONE post? But it’s my first impression. This is kind of a bizarre response to it.

thats nice, your still wrong.

I’m perfectly aware he’s prone to goofing off as any alignment. Why, then, would you insist I’m “wrong” to say he is scummy?I take it back... bbmolla is not scum with Firebringer, who is scum.

because I like pointing out incorrect things.

also congrats on being more right! proud of u

It was more these posts that bothered me than the initial “standard” post. But the whole idea behind it - I am “wrong” for calling bbmolla scummy because it is “standard” behavior? To say it’s not a tell is one thing, but that is NOT how he phrased it. That’s what he was going for, maybe, but that IS NOT what he said.

im fine with lynching creature

VOTE: creature

This is also the only thing he said or did that had any substance whatsoever, and it was just to join a wagon for a spam policy lynch.

He repeatedly has said we should elect a governor with no reasoning, and more importantly, no case for who he thinks we should elect! He token voted himself, with no effort, and then joined a mini wagon on flavorleaf with no reason simply because it had a little momentum. If he thought that we, as a town, should use the governor, he should want to have an influence on who the governor is and how it is used, but he clearly could not give a rat’s ass.

He has managed to stay active without commenting on ANY SINGLE THING of significance in the entire game.

He could just be a bad, uncaring player. I don’t know him. There are a lot of those in this game, but he’s the one that strikes me as scummy because his collection of posts seem calculated to stay under the radar.

[KidAmn]

Whos gov

This moron is probably town or he’d have asked this in his scum PT.

Or you're scum with him and coaching him to ask questions like this in your scum PT next time

[Amrun]

Whos gov

This moron is probably town or he’d have asked this in his scum PT.

Or you're scum with him and coaching him to ask questions like this in your scum PT next time

If that was true I would do it in the scum PT. Is this your idea of content?

[Firebringer]

but he clearly could not give a rat’s ass.

this is accurate

[BBmolla]

firebringer is probably a lyncher or some shit

[InsideJob711]

Bbmolla is acting scummy (for him)

nope, this is pretty standard bbmolla

I’ve played mafia with him in person and many times.

Obviously, it’s not a terribly reliable read given his what, ONE post? But it’s my first impression. This is kind of a bizarre response to it.

thats nice, your still wrong.

I’m perfectly aware he’s prone to goofing off as any alignment. Why, then, would you insist I’m “wrong” to say he is scummy?I take it back... bbmolla is not scum with Firebringer, who is scum.

because I like pointing out incorrect things.

also congrats on being more right! proud of u

It was more these posts that bothered me than the initial “standard” post. But the whole idea behind it - I am “wrong” for calling bbmolla scummy because it is “standard” behavior? To say it’s not a tell is one thing, but that is NOT how he phrased it. That’s what he was going for, maybe, but that IS NOT what he said.

im fine with lynching creature

VOTE: creature

This is also the only thing he said or did that had any substance whatsoever, and it was just to join a wagon for a spam policy lynch.

He repeatedly has said we should elect a governor with no reasoning, and more importantly, no case for who he thinks we should elect! He token voted himself, with no effort, and then joined a mini wagon on flavorleaf with no reason simply because it had a little momentum. If he thought that we, as a town, should use the governor, he should want to have an influence on who the governor is and how it is used, but he clearly could not give a rat’s ass.

He has managed to stay active without commenting on ANY SINGLE THING of significance in the entire game.

He could just be a bad, uncaring player. I don’t know him. There are a lot of those in this game, but he’s the one that strikes me as scummy because his collection of posts seem calculated to stay under the radar.

I mean
for the first point, thats kind of just how Firebringer plays.
For the second point, thats assuming that a town!Firebringer is going to play optimally.

Like, what you are describing to me sounds like Firebringer.
You could go into his ego and look a recently completed game he was in, and probably see the same traits you're describing to me.

[InsideJob711]

but he clearly could not give a rat’s ass.

this is accurate

yeah
pretty much this is everything I could say about that slot

[Firebringer]

firebringer is probably a lyncher or some shit

who is my lyncher target

[Donempire]

My dick

[Firebringer]

My dick

lol

[Amrun]

Bbmolla is acting scummy (for him)

nope, this is pretty standard bbmolla

I’ve played mafia with him in person and many times.

Obviously, it’s not a terribly reliable read given his what, ONE post? But it’s my first impression. This is kind of a bizarre response to it.

thats nice, your still wrong.

I’m perfectly aware he’s prone to goofing off as any alignment. Why, then, would you insist I’m “wrong” to say he is scummy?I take it back... bbmolla is not scum with Firebringer, who is scum.

because I like pointing out incorrect things.

also congrats on being more right! proud of u

It was more these posts that bothered me than the initial “standard” post. But the whole idea behind it - I am “wrong” for calling bbmolla scummy because it is “standard” behavior? To say it’s not a tell is one thing, but that is NOT how he phrased it. That’s what he was going for, maybe, but that IS NOT what he said.

im fine with lynching creature

VOTE: creature

This is also the only thing he said or did that had any substance whatsoever, and it was just to join a wagon for a spam policy lynch.

He repeatedly has said we should elect a governor with no reasoning, and more importantly, no case for who he thinks we should elect! He token voted himself, with no effort, and then joined a mini wagon on flavorleaf with no reason simply because it had a little momentum. If he thought that we, as a town, should use the governor, he should want to have an influence on who the governor is and how it is used, but he clearly could not give a rat’s ass.

He has managed to stay active without commenting on ANY SINGLE THING of significance in the entire game.

He could just be a bad, uncaring player. I don’t know him. There are a lot of those in this game, but he’s the one that strikes me as scummy because his collection of posts seem calculated to stay under the radar.

I mean
for the first point, thats kind of just how Firebringer plays.
For the second point, thats assuming that a town!Firebringer is going to play optimally.

Like, what you are describing to me sounds like Firebringer.
You could go into his ego and look a recently completed game he was in, and probably see the same traits you're describing to me.

There are plenty of genuine lurkers/uninvested players in this game so far. He’s the only one that strikes me as someone who is actively avoiding all relevant content.

The Fonz has posted like 1 time or something, and likely hasn’t read much of the thread, but when he puts in his token effort, it’s not just hot air, it has meaning. Xofelf hasn’t said much of value but what she has said seems genuine. Creature has spammed constantly, but it’s null. There are many ways to play suboptimally that aren’t scummy. Of course, playing with someone many times helps you to sort out the trash from the recycling, but at the same time, I’m going to trust my own reads over all.

[InsideJob711]

Bbmolla is acting scummy (for him)

nope, this is pretty standard bbmolla

I’ve played mafia with him in person and many times.

Obviously, it’s not a terribly reliable read given his what, ONE post? But it’s my first impression. This is kind of a bizarre response to it.

thats nice, your still wrong.

I’m perfectly aware he’s prone to goofing off as any alignment. Why, then, would you insist I’m “wrong” to say he is scummy?I take it back... bbmolla is not scum with Firebringer, who is scum.

because I like pointing out incorrect things.

also congrats on being more right! proud of u

It was more these posts that bothered me than the initial “standard” post. But the whole idea behind it - I am “wrong” for calling bbmolla scummy because it is “standard” behavior? To say it’s not a tell is one thing, but that is NOT how he phrased it. That’s what he was going for, maybe, but that IS NOT what he said.

im fine with lynching creature

VOTE: creature

This is also the only thing he said or did that had any substance whatsoever, and it was just to join a wagon for a spam policy lynch.

He repeatedly has said we should elect a governor with no reasoning, and more importantly, no case for who he thinks we should elect! He token voted himself, with no effort, and then joined a mini wagon on flavorleaf with no reason simply because it had a little momentum. If he thought that we, as a town, should use the governor, he should want to have an influence on who the governor is and how it is used, but he clearly could not give a rat’s ass.

He has managed to stay active without commenting on ANY SINGLE THING of significance in the entire game.

He could just be a bad, uncaring player. I don’t know him. There are a lot of those in this game, but he’s the one that strikes me as scummy because his collection of posts seem calculated to stay under the radar.

I mean
for the first point, thats kind of just how Firebringer plays.
For the second point, thats assuming that a town!Firebringer is going to play optimally.

Like, what you are describing to me sounds like Firebringer.
You could go into his ego and look a recently completed game he was in, and probably see the same traits you're describing to me.

There are plenty of genuine lurkers/uninvested players in this game so far. He’s the only one that strikes me as someone who is actively avoiding all relevant content.

The Fonz has posted like 1 time or something, and likely hasn’t read much of the thread, but when he puts in his token effort, it’s not just hot air, it has meaning. Xofelf hasn’t said much of value but what she has said seems genuine. Creature has spammed constantly, but it’s null. There are many ways to play suboptimally that aren’t scummy. Of course, playing with someone many times helps you to sort out the trash from the recycling, but at the same time, I’m going to trust my own reads over all.

I uh
don't actually like The Fonz's Miller Mason comment.

[InsideJob711]

Again, you can pressure Firebringer, I'm not going to stop you there.
I doubt you'll get anything out of it that'll make you want to lynch him less (because thats just how he works).
If anything, it should be easier to read him later, I'm just bad at reading him, but I FEEL like he's an easy read mid/late.

[InsideJob711]

What do you think of Davesaz?

[InsideJob711]

to me davesaz comes off as a slot that seems like kinda natural so I like it.

[Amrun]

I uh
don't actually like The Fonz's Miller Mason comment.

I did. It shows he was skimming while on v/la and hunting for actual content in the piles of shitposting. If a miller mason had claimed, that would have been important.

What do you think of Davesaz?

Nothing has struck me as explicitly scummy that I can remember. Like... town leaning.