Perfect Masquerade [Game Over]

[Lady 5]

when i mean someone i mean @g6@g6@g6

Ok, fine.

[Gentleman 5]

Town G8 doesn’t choose L2.
Scum G8 chooses Town L2.
Scum G8 doesn’t choose Scum L2.

There!
It’s more clear now!

if you believe that

vote me

Depending on what G5/L4 flips I might.

Are you trying to drive me away from them?
If so, why exactly?

If I cared more, Id argue this is what I like to call a “bus”

[Lady 2]

Town G8 doesn’t choose L2.
Scum G8 chooses Town L2.
Scum G8 doesn’t choose Scum L2.

There!
It’s more clear now!

if you believe that

vote me

Depending on what G5/L4 flips I might.

Are you trying to drive me away from them?
If so, why exactly?

Lol not likely given I'm still voting them.

I'm just saying, by your logic, I'm scum, case closed, right? That's the only reason G8 wouldn't have invited me there, right?

Look I really don't want to engage with you because you have a talent of making every attempt to communicate with you pointless and futile.

PEDIT: ... okay yeah G5 is a great lynch today not a doubt in my mind

[Gentleman 5]

im really lazy can someone make one cohesive post on why g5 is scum other than being hooked on a feeling

Constant Shade and he’s Thunderdoming with the G6/L8 Pair.

God please dont tell me Thunderdoming is the new term for 1v1.

[Gentleman 5]

@L2 - K

[Lady 5]

Town G8 doesn’t choose L2.
Scum G8 chooses Town L2.
Scum G8 doesn’t choose Scum L2.

There!
It’s more clear now!

if you believe that

vote me

Depending on what G5/L4 flips I might.

Are you trying to drive me away from them?
If so, why exactly?

Lol not likely given I'm still voting them.

I'm just saying, by your logic, I'm scum, case closed, right? That's the only reason G8 wouldn't have invited me there, right?

Look I really don't want to engage with you because you have a talent of making every attempt to communicate with you pointless and futile.

PEDIT: ... okay yeah G5 is a great lynch today not a doubt in my mind

I think your not quite understanding me.
If G8 is Scum then your probably scum.
That’s what I’m saying.
If your Town then G8 is probably Town.

That’s what I’m getting at.

[Lady 5]

im really lazy can someone make one cohesive post on why g5 is scum other than being hooked on a feeling

Constant Shade and he’s Thunderdoming with the G6/L8 Pair.

God please dont tell me Thunderdoming is the new term for 1v1.

Thunderdoming is when 2 people vote each other and keep
Pushing each other and refuse to vote anyone else.

[Gentleman 5]

So a 1v1

[Lady 2]

Town G8 doesn’t choose L2.
Scum G8 chooses Town L2.
Scum G8 doesn’t choose Scum L2.

There!
It’s more clear now!

if you believe that

vote me

Depending on what G5/L4 flips I might.

Are you trying to drive me away from them?
If so, why exactly?

Lol not likely given I'm still voting them.

I'm just saying, by your logic, I'm scum, case closed, right? That's the only reason G8 wouldn't have invited me there, right?

Look I really don't want to engage with you because you have a talent of making every attempt to communicate with you pointless and futile.

PEDIT: ... okay yeah G5 is a great lynch today not a doubt in my mind

I think your not quite understanding me.
If G8 is Scum then your probably scum.
That’s what I’m saying.
If your Town then G8 is probably Town.

That’s what I’m getting at.

Huh I misread you there, I thought you had ruled out Town G8 inviting as he did (leaving only the possibility of scum G8/scum L2). Apologies for that.

[Lady 7]

Alright, let's discuss it after the game, then!

I think as scum I'd rather let my partner stand on her own - if she can't really convince someone to partner with her, she's likely to be a liability, and the jump on Lady 5 seemed like an attempt to avoid association with Lady 2. That's just a narrative that seems to fit pretty well as far as I'm concerned, but you bring up some good points counter to that, so I'll definitely consider that at the very least.

But lady 5 is the biggest liability here. If scum 8 partnered with l2 at least they’d have a fighting chance, you know because you never know what’s going to happen once in the dance. Some of my funniest scum wins were ones I didn’t deserve because town imploded, and there’s always that chance. I guess if I were scum 8, I’d rather dance with scum2, who was picking up some moderate town reads, and allow us to fight rather than let scum 2 leave the dance bringing us down one, dance with the biggest liability in the game that’s very likely to get lynched, andlet my last partner stick it out to the end.

I mean rip me if they are scum, but I’d be surprised if they both are.

[Lady 4]

This g8 scum = l2 scum narrative is bullshit and probably being spread by scun to get something out of their worthless g8 slot

[Gentleman 4]

This g8 scum = l2 scum narrative is bullshit and probably being spread by scun to get something out of their worthless g8 slot

Lady 1 was town and she was the first one to say anything about it.
I'm also saying it's at least a possibility.

Would you like to point to what posts make you think Lady 2 is specifically town?
Or even just talk about the players that are spreading this information that are likely scum?

[Lady 7]

This g8 scum = l2 scum narrative is bullshit and probably being spread by scun to get something out of their worthless g8 slot

Lady 1 was town and she was the first one to say anything about it.
I'm also saying it's at least a possibility.

Would you like to point to what posts make you think Lady 2 is specifically town?
Or even just talk about the players that are spreading this information that are likely scum?

Actually lady 6 used lady 1 being the scum who was skipped over as the reason why lady 1 should be left out. Lady 1 just then used the same theory to apply it to lady 2.

[Gentleman 5]

This g8 scum = l2 scum narrative is bullshit and probably being spread by scun to get something out of their worthless g8 slot

Wanna vote L5 cause fuck it?

[Gentleman 4]

This g8 scum = l2 scum narrative is bullshit and probably being spread by scun to get something out of their worthless g8 slot

Lady 1 was town and she was the first one to say anything about it.
I'm also saying it's at least a possibility.

Would you like to point to what posts make you think Lady 2 is specifically town?
Or even just talk about the players that are spreading this information that are likely scum?

Actually lady 6 used lady 1 being the scum who was skipped over as the reason why lady 1 should be left out. Lady 1 just then used the same theory to apply it to lady 2.

I could see Lady 6 being scum, Gentleman 3 is really bringing that pairing up in my rankings anyways.

[Gentleman 4]

This g8 scum = l2 scum narrative is bullshit and probably being spread by scun to get something out of their worthless g8 slot

Lady 1 was town and she was the first one to say anything about it.
I'm also saying it's at least a possibility.

Would you like to point to what posts make you think Lady 2 is specifically town?
Or even just talk about the players that are spreading this information that are likely scum?

Actually lady 6 used lady 1 being the scum who was skipped over as the reason why lady 1 should be left out. Lady 1 just then used the same theory to apply it to lady 2.

I could see Lady 6 being scum, Gentleman 3 is

not

really bringing that pairing up in my rankings anyways.

EBWOP

[Gentleman 7]

Okay, I'm only 20 pages behind this time.

Glad I'm not busy today.

[Lady 3]

Has Lady 7 given you a catchup? Cuz you should ask one from her as well

[Gentleman 7]

For people who’ve played before - does mafia usually have a chat during precancerous? I’m guessing yes.

*predance

Nah, I think precancerous is pretty accurate at this rate.

Am I the only person who thinks G5 is scum

Because if so I'll just leave and wash my hands of the game

Okay, I'm going to look at him after I catch up. I'd kind of just felt like 'he was town' and sort of just ignored him for a while.

Why lady 5?

Why not?

This needs to get lynched at some point and I think that time is now.

[Gentleman 7]

Also, if anyone's asking me questions at the end of the thread, I won't be answering them for probably at least another half hour, depends when I catch up. If it's vitally important I'll refresh my pt with L7 every few minutes so she can let me know if there's something.

[Gentleman 7]

Lady 5, as your designated town leader I command you to stop posting

I didn't like you at first but I actually wish you'd be someone people listened to now.

[Gentleman 1]

I hate when people refer to others as VIs

Sorry. Should I use "unporposefully/unknowingly severely anti-town but likely town" instead?

No, and I know how frustrating playing with antitown people are, but it does hurt people’s feelings and I’m a big ole softie and feel bad for them.

In that case, how would you opt to refer to those types of players?

I am not quite in the mood to deal with this game just now but I will be giving input on some things soon.

My honest feeling is that I did not miss much at this point. Still have more to read though.

Also sadly I will be dropping nicknames at this point. The amount of catching up I have to do, along with the situation with having to track who has been changing appearances, just makes it seem like something I do not want to put up with, and I don’t want to put you through it either.

[Gentleman 1]

I'm actually townreading your posts now if it helps.

Not really no. I don’t want to be townread because I whined about not being interacted with. I’m a crazy person don’t mind me.

L7 continues to post things that I find towny.

Lady 3 was my other tentative townread, given that I'm also tentatively townreading G4 I think that I'm fine with that pairing in general.

Still townreading L9. Not going to bother saying more?

Would greatly appreciate it if new G5, L6, etc., came in and played since I am starting to feel like we'll win with just a few more townreads.

Anyone can make Town reads.

What are you getting at with this comment. Also, I see your point about possible lack of randomization, but I think FakeGod is not juvenile enough to deliberately make that reference. My impression of him is actually that he is rather uptight, if I may be blunt.
Also I believe I am experiencing the same issues with our communications hub as many others have noted, as delays in my ability to post have resulted in mild interruptions twice in a row now.

Who’s FakeGod?

Did you just seriously ask me who the FakeGod is? He is the person running this game. How clueless can you be? My instinct is that this is an act, no one can be as dense as you.

[Gentleman 7]

Okay, so the next little bit is pretty much the same thing.

Can we lynch G8/L5 first?
1. They're both pretty scummy and I feel fairly confident at least 1 will flip scum (probably not both, though).
2. They're going to be lynched anyways and we might as well do it now. I'd rather have more information from that lynch first.
3. This will give me time to read and try to make an informed opinion that lets me sort through the noise a bit better?
4. This lets other people in thread cool their heads.

VOTE: Gentleman 8

[Gentleman 1]

I am not quite in the mood to deal with this game just now but I will be giving input on some things soon.

Hopefully you weren’t the slot that replaced out.
Gent 1 Slot was strong town.

I have been preoccupied, but I have not been replaced at all.
I guess it might be interesting to see how sentiment towards me has shifted as I have been absent.

I mean that's very little of the reason that I townread you.

I'm still happy with 5 being removed, even if she's town her contributions are... limited.

6? 1? Me?

I assume these questions are asking about G6’s reads on those slots?

Gent 5 should always be with Lady 2 IMO.

What do you make of my pairing currently? It is the gentleman from one of your powerhouse pairing with the lady from the other. So I wonder what you’re thinking as of now.

I strongly think L2 and T6 is an incredibly useful pairing as I have already mentioned.

I am warming to G1/L5 as a pairing as I think L5, if town, is going to be somewhat similar to me come actual game days.

Why did you think L5 was a match for me? How do you feel they are similar to you, and how did that factor in to your preference?