Perfect Masquerade [Game Over]

[Lady 5]

The purpose of this selective recall, in my opinion, is to generate a plausible deniability to ignore anything at will in the future.

I don’t ignore stuff.
Point of why I ask about questions or concerns.

[Lady 5]

I just don’t catch up all the time.

[Lady 5]

I think G3 and L6 should pair.

What chemistry did you see in those two?

I am only responding to this because I am feeling rather worn out, I feel like I have made a modicum of progress, hopefully the thread doesn’t just swell in size again to kill my good feeling. In addition it seems like L2 is not on currently, and the biggest thing I wanted to do was talk with her in the PT a little. We did manage to talk to make that clear, but since she seems to have left me being around currently isn’t as important.

She was complaining about you before so what’s exactly going on between you two?

She had asked me some questions and I was being slow on answering them. I feel like that issue should be cleared up now, and we can start a proper back and forth soon.

We’re you just busy reading?
Or were you hesitant on the questions?

[Lady 5]

Ah well, I’m going to sleep. GN.

[Gentleman 4]

Who's my main?

Also I don't understand equating Lady 3 to Ariana Grande's God is a Woman?

[Lady 4]

G5 your posting this game has just been bad take after bad take after bad take and it makes me want to lynch you regardless of my read on you and I'm trying to rein that in but it's hard.

Spoiler: G6’s Main

Or maybe Vegeta. That quote could be from either of them

What’s my main?

Spoiler: L5’s Main

This is actually pretty funny.

[Lady 4]

If I had to make a positive comment t about G1's posts I would say that if he were scum his buddies would probably be yelling at him to do literally anything other than what he is currently doing, yet he is still doing it.

[Gentleman 5]

The purpose of this selective recall, in my opinion, is to generate a plausible deniability to ignore anything at will in the future.

I don’t ignore stuff.
Point of why I ask about questions or concerns.

There were questions you ignored.

I expect G1 to find them soon

[Gentleman 5]

G2 got replaced?
Aw that sucks.
Why did you change your PFP G5?

It was Anime before.

This should have been so obvious that Im not even going to give you a sarcastic answer

[Gentleman 5]

If I had to make a positive comment t about G1's posts I would say that if he were scum his buddies would probably be yelling at him to do literally anything other than what he is currently doing, yet he is still doing it.

G1:

theres a post somewhere down the line where I ask G6 why hes been ignoring me. Thats when the game ended. Save yourself the time and dont read past it.

[Gentleman 5]

You doubt that Lady 5 of all people in this game has trouble remembering something?

I feel like I wouldn't be surprised if she forgot her phone number.

To me it seems like she has selective recall. She seems to pick and choose what to remember, and it seems like is consistently choosing to forget rather important things.

She was playing the game, got too behind when the game started getting too fast, requested to replace out and have someone who shared her reads (specifically G3 is locktown) and love of pokemans. When it became obvious the person she wanted to replace in for her was allegedly in this game, she said fuck it and kept playing.

The problem is she kept bringing up replacing out and personally asking someone to take her spot, which is frowned on or against the rules. So people really stopped giving a shit about her.

Shes really just air at this point

[Gentleman 3]

Spoiler: G8’s Main

I chuckled

[Gentleman 3]

I’d like it if you talked about this at some point.

I was wrong, first of all.

I was thinking that L5 would continue to be hyper-interactive and contribute lots of productive reads and discussion. That's what she was doing in the early game.

But instead she just kinda flew off the rails.

As for L2 she about turned out how I expected; solid, reasonable content, readable but not easily so.

[Gentleman 5]

Spoiler: L4's Main

Spoiler: G4's Main

Thats all I got.

Also I don't understand equating Lady 3 to Ariana Grande's God is a Woman?

Spoiler:

BECAUSE SHE IS A GOD AT MAFIA!

Actually IDK.

[Gentleman 2]

I'm alive. Where are we at?

[Gentleman 5]

Reasoning for vote plz

[Gentleman 2]

Reasoning for vote plz

Do I need one?

[Gentleman 4]

@Gentleman 2, request your thoughts on this:

Alright here's the couples I'm considering for today in no particular order:

Lady 5 and Gentleman 8:

Spoiler: I've already covered this, and I think it's a dead horse now, but here's my argument in case you missed it:

I still support a Lady 5 and Gentleman 8 lynch, because it will help me sort Lady 2 and Gentleman 3, it will remove a lot of the spam from the thread, I doubt they will make it much later anyways, neither of them will surprise me with a scum flip, and I think we can get enough agreement on it to get two lynches before intermission.

One point I specifically want to bring up about this pairing is this: a lot of people are having difficulty with too many town reads - Lady 4's reads list included not enough scum and Gentleman 6 recently expressed doubt in several of his scum reads, and this is often indicative of scum being in the lurker pile -> Gentleman 8.

Gentleman 5 and Lady 4: The case against Gentleman 5 is debatable. I've liked what he brought to the table in the past, but Gentleman 1 made a solid point about his Lady 2 "joke." I'm really not certain about this pair, I'd really rather have more time to sort through this, because I've been very much on the fence about both these player's alignments. I think based on Gentleman 5's "joke," flipping this pair might be indicative of Lady 2 scum.

Gentleman 3 and Lady 6: Lady 6 has said very convenient things at convenient times before, and several of her more interesting posts have been noted several times by other players. I will go through these when I get the chance, but I think she's slid significantly under the radar due to her absence. There have been a couple things she's done that have barely any game relevancy but can be indicative of her being town on her main account, though, so this is something to keep in consideration. I have never been a fan of Gentleman 3's posting, it all looks particularly fake and his activity has dropped conveniently after finding a partner - right around the same time everyone else was looking at Gentleman 5 and Lady 4.

Gentleman 1 and Lady 2: Not really a pairing I was considering at the beginning of the day, I like Gentleman 1 for the most part, but Lady 2's flip could help determine the alignment of several other players here and I've been less and less convinced by her posting recently.

[Gentleman 5]

Reasoning for vote plz

Do I need one?

Yes?

Since both you and L9 seem to be blindly voting imo.

[Lady 5]

G2 got replaced?
Aw that sucks.
Why did you change your PFP G5?

It was Anime before.

This should have been so obvious that Im not even going to give you a sarcastic answer

Did you replace into their slot?

[Lady 5]

So was G2, G4 AND G5 all replaced?

[Lady 5]

I’d like it if you talked about this at some point.

I was wrong, first of all.

I was thinking that L5 would continue to be hyper-interactive and contribute lots of productive reads and discussion. That's what she was doing in the early game.

But instead she just kinda flew off the rails.

As for L2 she about turned out how I expected; solid, reasonable content, readable but not easily so.

I am currently waiting for my partner to.
You know.
Actually DO SOMETHING!!!

[Lady 5]

Spoiler: L4's Main

Spoiler: G4's Main

Thats all I got.

Also I don't understand equating Lady 3 to Ariana Grande's God is a Woman?

Spoiler:

BECAUSE SHE IS A GOD AT MAFIA!

Actually IDK.

Ima make a gut read here.
G5 Red = L3 Red

[Lady 5]

I Town read G3 and G4.
So that’s why I want to believe L6 and L3 are Town.
But it’s still possible one of the ladies are scum.
That can be decided in final 3 pairs as L3 and L6 I don’t think are ever both scum here.

[Lady 5]

During my PoE rundown.
There should be scum within G1 and L2.
If “77” contains scum. Then I think G5 and G6 pair’s are both Town.
Though this is a rough PoE and might change.