Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[zoraster]

If we're going to try to start a cw at this point, btw, my money's on Zor. His treatment of UT doesn't read as natural, he's done fuckall with regards to following up on his "early posting AI" and his pl push on creat was easily the worst of the bunch.

I think my post on my current vote is pretty clear. It's not like I have a ton of posts; it shouldn't be that hard to not misrepresent my stuff. I was also serious about my vote on Gamma.

In any event, the Creature "PL push" was in exasperation. To be clear, "hyperposting" is one thing, but he had at one point twice as many posts as any other player in the game and had posted, and had just posted 18, 22, and 15times on subsequent pages (that's 55 out of 75 posts!). It needed to be called out and stopped, and if it didn't stop, it needed to be removed. And I find it pretty disingenuous to cast that in some sort of negative light just because it's convenient for you now because I don't think it was

at all

unclear what was going on there.

[Bingle]

I'm not sure how not bringing up your drew vote (or your gamma vote) as a reason I find you scummy is a misrep, tbh.

[zoraster]

maybe I don't understand what "following up on his early posting AI" means?

[Bingle]

hello there. i wish the game didn't start without a notification PM, but here we are.

Everyone who posted earlier than me is slightly suspect.

This. This was a thing you brought up, people noted as potentially good to look at, and then you promptly never addressed again.

[Cephrir]

UT is the confirmed scum BTW.
He called my lock town read scum and said “Solving is Scum Indicative”
No ones that bad at the game.
UT is Confirmed Scum.

[zoraster]

You mean the post I explained here?

Also, how much stock do you really expect me to put in something like that anyway? It's not null, but it's not exactly going to control my actions entirely (because there had been way too many people who had posted for all to be scum for one thing and for another, there's been roughly 160 pages since then.) Plus, some people felt it was "angelshooting" and while I don't entirely agree, it's also not necessarily a comment I find entirely wrong either.

[Miss Lane]

Alright Formerfish, what are we doing today?

[Miss Lane]

First of all, after I've revealed that I'm a bit of a chaotic neutral, how do you feel about me right now? Am I still as much of an asset as I was before?

I just want someone to tell me I'm smart again. Or that they need me on their team. Or something. That felt super good.

[Untrod Tripod]

UT is the confirmed scum BTW.
He called my lock town read scum and said “Solving is Scum Indicative”
No ones that bad at the game.
UT is Confirmed Scum.

shh. no one cares.

[Bingle]

You mean the post I explained here?

Also, how much stock do you really expect me to put in something like that anyway? It's not null, but it's not exactly going to control my actions entirely (because there had been way too many people who had posted for all to be scum for one thing and for another, there's been roughly 160 pages since then.) Plus, some people felt it was "angelshooting" and while I don't entirely agree, it's also not necessarily a comment I find entirely wrong either.

My issue isn't the thought itself, but the lack of followthrough. For example, I saw no analysis of who would be likely to have seen the thread on their own, no mention of a glance at the signups thread to see who was necessarily aware of the game start because of banter and links there (myself, wooper, Kise, pops, AFrost and Drew all posted in that thread after chk promised to link to this one in it, btw and dong outright asked for a game link there before that happened), no mention of people who showed a lack of awareness being more likely town (creature, for example), no analysis of whether your theory had more or less impact with people like xof who doesn't often play mafia, nothing.

If you thought it worth bringing it up in the first place as AI, I would expect some additional analysis at some point, but by now it's clear that was never going to happen.

[Nero Cain]

i kinda wish TSE would just hammer Drew.

[chkflip]

Day 1 Vote Count 1.6

Cobble was in disarray after the two deaths. Something didn't smell right and it had little to do with the crispy fried townsperson the town guard were moving to the graveyard. They finally began to come together on a lead and were shouting for a head. Not just any head, either, as they circled nearer and nearer to this one.

"

I've been forthright in my abilities with you all; furthermore, certainly you couldn't believe that I could do something so dubious and outside of my element. Neither of these people are particularly bad people nor did I have any reason to have a hand in their demise. Surely you could all just listen and come to your senses.

"

Would they listen? Would they turn their attention again? Or will this person be the first of many to take the blame for the travesty in Cobble? All that is truly known is the thirst for vengeance in this once peaceful town. It's gallows stood firm and barren for years. The cobwebs on the many feet of rope underneath was think and musty. But soon the dust would be no more.

Soon...

Doctor Drew (14) -

Flavor Leaf, Rautherdir, EspressoPatronum, chennisden, AaronFrost, Wooper, Gamma Emerald, Cephrir, Amrun, Untrod Tripod, zoraster, gobbledygook, Menalque, The Fonz

Vorkuta (9) -

Nero Cain, Miss Lynch, davesaz, Bingle, RCEnigma, Creature, Formerfish, BBmolla, Doctor Drew

Amrun -

Dongempire, Iconeum, Hectic

Creature -

Firebringer, Vorkuta

Untrod Tripod -

InsideJob711, TrueSoulEnergy

TrueSoulEnergy -

Chemist1422

Flavor Leaf -

Dr Easy Bake

Rautherdir -

KidAmn

Menalque -

Virgo the Immaculate

Miss Lynch -

Pine

40 alive, 21 majority.
You have (expired on 2019-11-19 22:00:00) left in this phase.
Virgo the Immaculate, Elements, and Pine have been prodded.

[Pink Ball]

VOTE: Virgo the Immaculate

[Flavor Leaf]

i kinda wish TSE would just hammer Drew.

TSE, do it for me!

[Miss Lane]

Why do we want TSE to vote for DrDrew? I thought we were voting for Vorkuta?

[Doctor Drew]

Why do we want TSE to vote for DrDrew? I thought we were voting for Vorkuta?

Apparently we doesn't include you?

[Doctor Drew]

Why do we want TSE to vote for DrDrew? I thought we were voting for Vorkuta?

Apparently we doesn't include you?

Haha nvm.

Thought you were someone else

[Flavor Leaf]

Why do we want TSE to vote for DrDrew? I thought we were voting for Vorkuta?

Why? DD is scum. We’re voting for Drew. You must have missed a big chunk, specifically my casings

[Doctor Drew]

Why do we want TSE to vote for DrDrew? I thought we were voting for Vorkuta?

Why? DD is scum. We’re voting for Drew. You must have missed a big chunk, specifically my casings

Question for the class.

Is Flavor normally a tunnel-y player as town?

[Miss Lane]

Why do we want TSE to vote for DrDrew? I thought we were voting for Vorkuta?

Why? DD is scum. We’re voting for Drew. You must have missed a big chunk, specifically my casings

gimme a minute lemme iso u

[Miss Lane]

Why do we want TSE to vote for DrDrew? I thought we were voting for Vorkuta?

Why? DD is scum. We’re voting for Drew. You must have missed a big chunk, specifically my casings

Question for the class.

Is Flavor normally a tunnel-y player as town?

say the words you mean

tunnel doesn't mean what you think it means

unless it does in which case i'd argue i haven't seen a legitimately tunnel-y play since 2016

[Doctor Drew]

Execute the PGO

Also.

PGO's are almost always town, correct?

[Miss Lane]

ok I've seen enough

i'm currently following formerfish tho so you'll have to convince him

[Miss Lane]

formerfish we should prolly vote drew he's a good lynch today i think

[Nero Cain]

scum pgo is rare but i've seen it