Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[Cephrir]

Sometimes the best way to sort out your thoughts is to just write them down, whatever they may be. I trusted my gut, so I decided to open my notebook and start writing impressions without consulting any of my data. Seemed like as good a place as any to get my head straight.

"01. Pine
Mostly absent.

02. Untrod Tripod
Hasn't actually done much, but I'm fine with most of what he's posted. I agree with the substance of his complaints, though I think there's little point in continuing to post about them and I thought the Elements vote was a bit hyperbolic.

03. Wooper
Who?

04. Firebringer
Oddly, who? Possibly scum purely because I can't remember him making me smile yet.

05. Amrun
Her posting style feels a little detached but I'm chalking it up to old school. Actually trying, which if anything this town is in dire need of. I don't think there's much scum utility in the way she's handled her claim, though I wish she had kept it to herself. If someone can find the scum benefit here by all means tell me.

06. Iconeum
Who? I think I disliked one or two posts.

07. Korina
There is no way to read posts that don't have any content. I wish they would stop whining about quite unlikely events failing to materialize.

08. Rautherdir
I don't like anything they post, including the "look how helpful I am" vote counts. But they've been investigated, so whatever.

09. BBmolla
More or less blatantly not playing until there are fewer people, which I can't really argue with since I've been doing something similar.

11. The Fonz
I think this might be scum.

12. TrueSoulEnergy
I've already posted about this at length. We are unlucky that such a seemingly necessary role was rolled by someone who should really be vigged. I give this a 25% chance of being third party that wins when it executes some number of goblins.

13. Menalque
Town.

14. Titus, who is/replaced Virgo the Immaculate
Possibly town just because their response to a wagon hasn't been trying to get out of it in a way with a high chance of succeeding.

15. Bingle
I'm aware this person is good at scum and I feel they are town anyway.

16. Nero Cain
Disagree with nearly everything this person posts. Not sure if scum or just aggressively bad. Leaning towards the latter.

17. xofelf
xofelf's posts always read tonally scummy to me, but I know that is just her writing style. Probably town for posting at all, honestly.

18. Gamma Emerald
Useless, lean scum.

19. Pink Ball
Who?

20. Vorkuta
The wagon on this person makes no sense to me at all. They were present during the fun part, got bored or something and left. Wow, incredible case guys. And now with a wagon on him he's still not doing anything. What a dangerous mastermind we have on our hands.

21. Dr Easy Bake
Useless. Vig this.

22. Aaron fucking Frost
They contribute sometimes and haven't pinged me yet, so that's fine.

23. RCEnigma
Lean town.

24. davesaz
I remember scumreading this person as town in the past, so I'm just going to let them be for now.

25. Miss Lynch, who is/replaced Enter
See no reason to worry about this at this time.

26. Elements
I should read this person, but I'm pretty sure I'm fine with lynching them.

28. pisskop, who replaced Hectic
Who?

29. zoraster
Gives me the heebie-jeebies. I thought the way zor aligned himself with UT on most issues and then weirdly started to push him when this was pointed out is pretty awkward.

31. Dongempire
Who?

32. gobbledygook
*gobble*

34. chennisden
Light town lean.

35. Creature
I'm just glad it stopped posting. No read.

36. Almost50, who replaced jadesmar
I suck at reading this guy. Neutral.

37. Flavor Leaf
Lean scum. Doesn't feel at all like the town version I witnessed recently. Lifeless.

38. KidAmn
Unmemorable.

39. InsideJob711 (hydra of Kise and Alisae)
I mildly suspect this slot purely because I believe it knows better than to claim hider for no reason. Their blatant crumb was more than sufficient.

40. EspressoPatronum
I agreed with the obvtown reads until the last ~10 pages. I don't like or get what they've been doing more recently."

Satisfied for now, I tucked my pen back into its holster.

[Cephrir]

VOTE: Elements

[Untrod Tripod]

29. zoraster
Gives me the heebie-jeebies. I thought the way zor aligned himself with UT on most issues and then weirdly started to push him when this was pointed out is pretty awkward.

I was hoping to let him paint himself into a corner a little bit more before pointing this out but yeah

[Amrun]

Well, y'all have fun wagoning my buddy. I can't vote for them no matter what, so, I'll just be over here in Flavortown.

why can't you vote for them?

Let’s lynch someone

Who?

VOTE: titus

These are his last 3 posts

Look me in the eye and tell me that titus is more likely scum between the two

Elements is scummy. I’d vote there. I don’t think it makes Titus not scum, especially when dealing with a much higher chance than usual of multiball.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Elements

I think most of us can actually agree on this one.

Can I get a sentence about why before I vote here

[Amrun]

.so you tactically replaced out of your alt into your main because you felt it would make you harder to lynch

Mislynch. Partially. Also, if scum were going to use my weaknesses against me but town didn't have that knowledge, then town is at a disadvantage. I would have been gamethrowing.

If I explained my real life situation, everyone would have known who I was anyway. It was the least confusing, most pragmatic solution. I personally hated it but it gives town the best chance to win.

I am honestly confused about this. Since I was the one who said anything about you, it seems like you are calling me scum who figured out your alt. Yet you haven’t directly called me scum once.

For the record, I had no idea Virgo was you, and while I am happy to play with you, you switching out did nothing to change the slot and probably made it scummier.

You seem to be scumflailing. Perhaps it’s just IRL getting in the way, and I know that’s a lot to deal with, but game wise strictly, you just don’t seem to be playing in a way that is indicative of someone trying to find scum.

Fonz, also kinda lurky AND on my list, on his few posts have seemed to me so far as if he’s trying to use what little time he has to think about the game rather than look town.

[Wooper]

03. Wooper
Who?

[Rautherdir]

VOTE: Elements

I think most of us can actually agree on this one.

Can I get a sentence about why before I vote here

In the post prior to that vote:

-snip-

I am willing to lynch Elements, as in a way they effectively tried to quick-hammer a slot.

[Wooper]

What happened to him?

Every post he made was so mild-mannered, he was very much like something smart and dannflor in that way, actually. err. I don't know if mild-mannered is the right word for something smart, but I hope you get the gist of it?

irrelephant? he got ambushed by irl stuff and had to take a break :{
i sent him well wishes on discord a bit, don't think he's checked that for a bit either

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: Elements

I think most of us can actually agree on this one.

Can I get a sentence about why before I vote here

In the post prior to that vote:

-snip-

I am willing to lynch Elements, as in a way they effectively tried to quick-hammer a slot.

Is that it though? Or is there more?

[Elements]

I am willing to lynch Elements, as in a way they effectively tried to quick-hammer a slot.

A lynch a that point would've looked much worse on Titus than on me.

[RCEnigma]

I am willing to lynch Elements, as in a way they effectively tried to quick-hammer a slot.

A lynch a that point would've looked much worse on Titus than on me.

Huh?

[Elements]

I am willing to lynch Elements, as in a way they effectively tried to quick-hammer a slot.

A lynch a that point would've looked much worse on Titus than on me.

Huh?

I don't mean Titus, I mean whoever the executioner is.

[RCEnigma]

Huh to that too.

[Gamma Emerald]

Yeah what
How does that make sense when you were voting Titus
PEdit: wdym “who the executioner” is, so far we have TSE as executioner, maybe there’s another but they wouldn’t act out now I think. And TSE did at least somewhat position himself to execute Titus

[Elements]

I don't see why my vote is an attempt to quicklynch unless its inrelation to the "one more vote and i can exxecute" post which I have no control over anyway

[RCEnigma]

Like TSE has made it known he'll execute when wagons are put in range for him to activate. So why would you directly making that possible look worse on him than you? And why are you assuming Titus flips town?

[Elements]

[quote="In post 6039, Gamma Emerald"PEdit: wdym “who the executioner” is, so far we have TSE as executioner, maybe there’s another but they wouldn’t act out now I think. And TSE did at least somewhat position himself to execute Titus[/quote]
i meant TSE then

[Elements]

Like TSE has made it known he'll execute when wagons are put in range for him to activate. So why would you directly making that possible look worse on him than you? And why are you assuming Titus flips town?

I'm not assuming Titus flips town. I'm commenting on the point about quick lynching.

[RCEnigma]

On the record if I wasn't voting scum!Vork if vote scum!elements.

[RCEnigma]

I am willing to lynch Elements, as in a way they effectively tried to quick-hammer a slot.

A lynch a that point would've looked much worse on Titus than on me.

A scum flip looks great for either of you. This is assuming a town flip.

[Rautherdir]

I am willing to lynch Elements, as in a way they effectively tried to quick-hammer a slot.

A lynch a that point would've looked much worse on Titus than on me.

... So, are you saying you are bussing? Do you know for sure that Titus will flip scum? Because that seems to be what you're saying.

p-edit
So now you're admitting you knowingly put Titus up in range of execution. That is straight-up hammering in my book. TSE should be expected to execute anyone who isn't himself if able to.

VOTE: Elements

I think most of us can actually agree on this one.

Can I get a sentence about why before I vote here

In the post prior to that vote:

-snip-

I am willing to lynch Elements, as in a way they effectively tried to quick-hammer a slot.

Is that it though? Or is there more?

Elements doesn't have any good content, and I'd like to see what they do under pressure.

[RCEnigma]

Yikes, I'm doing the Shoshin thing.

[Elements]

On the record if I wasn't voting scum!Vork if vote scum!elements.

Why are you scum reading me again?

[Elements]

Like TSE has made it known he'll execute when wagons are put in range for him to activate.

As you may have noticed I'm not following this game particularly closely and did not know that.