Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[Nero Cain]

I’m finding it frustrating because thinking I would intentionally put zor on my list with a hider check on him as mafia is just dumb.

I kind of agree with this though. Like maybe its somewhat rare but I think scum do fake derp tells for town cred. And its also possible that you aren't even paying much attention to the game [as scum] but I guess I'm sort of willing to go "oh this is just an honest mistake"

[davesaz]

I'm gonna answer the question that I expect to come up from 7162 without even refreshing the page, using the quick reply. So I have no idea if anyone has even asked this, but...

I read Menalque as highly manipulative. I don't care how towny he feels himself to be, or how towny others feel him to be. He's too pushy at a point in the game that we don't know alignments yet. That's being manipulative, regardless of alignment, and I don't like it. Let things flow.

[Nero Cain]

Leave yourself out of the "we" and I might allow it.

Can u poison dave firewoofer?

P sure davesaz is town. Didn't you say he was null earlier?

Idk maybe? But he moved up to a scumlean

kinda OMGUSy

[Amrun]

I personally TR Dave.


Titus is the most obvious lynch today. Please, let us lynch her.

Elements should kill Vorkuta probably. He wouldn’t be my top choice but it would probably help sort others at this point. Or, Korina or some other chronic lurker.

Fire’s going to do whatever he does, so whatever.

For whatever it is worth, I have personally designed a game with a town poisoner. I don’t think a delayed kill itself is AI whatsoever.

[Miss Lane]

I'm gonna answer the question that I expect to come up from 7162 without even refreshing the page, using the quick reply. So I have no idea if anyone has even asked this, but...

I read Menalque as highly manipulative. I don't care how towny he feels himself to be, or how towny others feel him to be. He's too pushy at a point in the game that we don't know alignments yet. That's being manipulative, regardless of alignment, and I don't like it. Let things flow.

+1

Elements is also a thinking being, plenty capable of making his own decision as far as the kill is concerned. Unless he specifically asks for your input, you're simply giving away more information than you have to or probably should from an optimal game standpoint, and it implies general disrespect for Elements' judgement by implying that he can't think for himself from a human being standpoint.

[Amrun]

I’d lynch Menalque tbh. It’s not best for today due to the red haired elf thing but I agree with Dave.

[Menalque]

I find dave’s progression very screwy and I think it’s weird he’s pushing at me given what he’s said

[Almost50]

@Mod: May or may not be able to post within the next 72 hours. V/LA

[Creature]

Aw man

[Menalque]

While I don't like Menalque's delivery, this

might

be town. If it's for the reason I think it is.

Pedit: by pressuring. You've made your case and there are 38 more people you need to get a read on.

While I don't like Menalque's delivery, this

might

be town. If it's for the reason I think it is.

I specifically dislike the method.
I also feel the target of that method is the wrong target. We do however need a big wagon or six.

For some reason she'd double her efforts this evening. Even she doesn't understand why.

I had spotted several likely clues in the events of the previous evening, but this one was certainly the clearest.

A lot can be gleaned from the write up.

Doubtful that orcus is town given the NK flavor. But we won't know until someone flips with that.

ok Dave, who made the kills last night and why are we not lynching them?

I think the one that had Orcus flavor is from groupscum and the other one is SK or equivalent.
Doesn't help yet with who, but it tells us what to expect.
If there is a vig out there they should also have gleaned information from it.

The overall writeup has a bunch more information. I'm not the type of person who starts pointing out PRs so that's the most you're going to get right now.

Menalque wanting a leash is very scummy.

Leave yourself out of the "we" and I might allow it.

I'm gonna answer the question that I expect to come up from 7162 without even refreshing the page, using the quick reply. So I have no idea if anyone has even asked this, but...

I read Menalque as highly manipulative. I don't care how towny he feels himself to be, or how towny others feel him to be. He's too pushy at a point in the game that we don't know alignments yet. That's being manipulative, regardless of alignment, and I don't like it. Let things flow.

So the NK flavour implies that orcus is scum, the fact that flavour is important has been pointed out multiple times by you, you thought I was potentially town on D0/1 whenever that post was from... but you’re pushing me despite me having been the kill target from what you believe to be groupscum?

[Creature]

Just spent more than 30 minutes scrolling through multiple scalie shit just to find this avatar

[Creature]

This is why I hate anime avatars

[Creature]

Shit I have test tomorrow

guess here goes my netflix night

[Menalque]

I'm gonna answer the question that I expect to come up from 7162 without even refreshing the page, using the quick reply. So I have no idea if anyone has even asked this, but...

I read Menalque as highly manipulative. I don't care how towny he feels himself to be, or how towny others feel him to be. He's too pushy at a point in the game that we don't know alignments yet. That's being manipulative, regardless of alignment, and I don't like it. Let things flow.

+1

Elements is also a thinking being, plenty capable of making his own decision as far as the kill is concerned. Unless he specifically asks for your input, you're simply giving away more information than you have to or probably should from an optimal game standpoint, and it implies general disrespect for Elements' judgement by implying that he can't think for himself from a human being standpoint.

Why are you assuming that elements is actually a town vig rather than another killing role claiming town vig?

[Creature]

Aka execution boi

Fuck this day if it has all been about wagoning one single player like D1 was

[Elements]

Why are you assuming that elements is actually a town vig rather than another killing role claiming town vig?

Why are you not?

[Creature]

No Gov is a copout

Don't make me bring politics again

[Nero Cain]

Fire’s going to do whatever he does, so whatever.

you don't care that he shot @ me? The lack of scrutiny isn't great. Though yes, I've seen a town poisoner that doesn't make him a town poisoner.

[Menalque]

Why are you assuming that elements is actually a town vig rather than another killing role claiming town vig?

Why are you not?

Because I don’t TR you on play (self-evidently, or I wouldn’t have pushed you to be lynched) and you happen to have claimed one of the few roles for which there is a big incentive to keep you alive? But mostly the first point

[Creature]

He outed his alt in this game, right?

I TRed that as a move to clear the air.

What?

[Nero Cain]

@mena, the BG on you doesn't confirm you.

[Creature]

Aw man my netflix night

[Creature]

Can someone actually be towny?

[Menalque]

@mena, the BG on you doesn't confirm you.

It should confirm me in dave’s eyes if he believes (as he said) that the orcus kill flavour is from groupscum

[Creature]

guess only Enter fits the parameter