Mini 2106 - Magia Record Fate Weave Semi-U-Pick (OVER!)

[Farkran]

I think the trajectory towards Gamma isn't great and seems like an easy target.

Can you elaborate more on this? You've jumped off me in the same way when i was being wagoned by {suji, TL, alchemist, salamence}, now you're sus of {fark, pops} for being on gamma. What are your thoughts about the wagon targets and the people on them?

VOTE: pops

Not impressed with pop's slot.

Can you elaborate on this?

I too am interested in your analysis of pops (@bitmap)

poke

[Kerset]

townreading

Severa
Bitmap
Sujimichi
Alchemist21
Gamma emerald maybe

That's almost my scumread list. Could you remove bitmap?

Town

Bitmap
Salamen
Evenstar
Farkran
Gamma
Pops
Chemist
V&M
Suji
TL
Alchemist
Severa

Scum

Kerset, can you explain your progression on Gamma? Was she part of your scumreads or not at the time of the first quote? What happened in-between for her to make it up to above half of your readlist? I only see a lengthy exchange with Alchemist (which i think was NAI on the side of bad), some content about evenstar (which made sense but again, mostly NAI), a very weak and weird push against me (which is really bad given the reasoning provided).

'maybe scum' matched my null area. Practically my null {Gamma Pops Chemist V&M Suji}, was solved by placing 'barely active" below null-active players. In the end i was comparing him with pops and his inquisitiveness was more accurate so maybe his slot is not so bad. In general i agreed with his side about alchemist.

[Nancy Drew 39]

ego

[Venus and Mars]

VOTE: Venus and Mars

Boooo

A disclaimer here, Nancy is sick a D I was extremely busy yesterday then had a to fulfil my gm duties for my group leading to my inactivity. I am reading up as I write this.
~Venus

Will try to catch up later.

~Mars

[Venus and Mars]

Still on p 23 but liking so far (in no particular order), Gamma, Even, Pops, maybe Bit? I think Severa’s reaction to people falling for his gambit looks townie.

~M

[Gamma Emerald]

I feel sick as hell today so I’m probably going to be doing jack shit. In addition:

VLA between Wednesday and Saturday (up through the end of November), Thanksgiving means family time and that means less phone time.

[Evenstar]

Still on p 23 but liking so far (in no particular order), Gamma, Even, Pops, maybe Bit? I think Severa’s reaction to people falling for his gambit looks townie.

~M

Could you elaborate on these shortreads a bit?

[Salamence20]

Btw, long overdue but

Salamance, how u been it has been ages. I was excited to see u in the player list.

~Venus

*tips hat* Shiro.

If you have any questions directed to me ask me and Ill answer if I can

So, from my understanding of your 351 your scumlist is {TL, Alchemist, pops, farkran}? I'm not sure if i'm still in there, perhaps more of a nullscum?

What strikes you as scum from pops?

Can you provide your thoughts about gamma?

Also about Evenstar?

Pops is scum just based on her posts and votes. From what I got, the vote on Bitmap really didnt make sense when I read that she was reading TL as scum more. Then Gamma and Kerset, Im not a fan of their vote but again pops has made it clear TL is scum but hasnt voted him. If TL flips scum I know where Im probably going next and vice versa.

I like Evenstar still as a voice of reason/foil to SEVERA.

I think gamma has been direct and open when rereading which I thought was town, but others have said this is NAI. Idk I think hes sounds towny ngl.

Im still for TL>Pops>Alch>Chem/ShiroDrew

Falkran is less of a problem for now, Im not sure why Kerset is mafia other than RC (aka YOUR GOD) COMMANDS IT

[Evenstar]

So what am i missing?

In my case? Confusion about my slot. You don't have significantly more meta on me than Farkran, and the two of you play very similarly - so why is one of you SRing me and the other TRing me?

When I look at it closely, I think your defense of me smells of TMI.

[popsofctown]

… you're BoPing Kerset? That wouldn't really be the angle that appeals to me.

Kerset's posted a lot more about what ker reads are rather than why they are.

Gamewide I think people are doing lists too much and I think discussing top 3's and why you feel that way is more relevant but I probably shouldn't try to browbeat people into following my style preferences

[Kerset]

Several, alchemist, gamma, you, (idk about pops). We barely agree on anything with farkran. What is so special about you Eva? You didn't even softclaim to be powerful.

[popsofctown]

Is the first sentence a list of people who disagree with Farkran?

[Kerset]

This are people that me and fark have different opinions about.

[Kerset]

Who am I Boping? You?

[popsofctown]

Oh ok that makes lots of sense since Farkran isn't sure if he disagrees with Farkran about pops right now
pedit: Evenstar is BoPing Kerset and I don't like it

[popsofctown]

Kerset let's play a game.

The mod says you have lynch one player immediately and we win if it's scum and otherwise we lose.

Who do you pick, and why do you pick that person?

[Kerset]

TL bc he is the most scumreaded.

[Venus and Mars]

Still on p 23 but liking so far (in no particular order), Gamma, Even, Pops, maybe Bit? I think Severa’s reaction to people falling for his gambit looks townie.

~M

Could you elaborate on these shortreads a bit?

It’s just a brief skim so I’m not yet caught up but Gamma claimed useless role. That usually tends to be town indicative. I have to reread but you looked to be sorting, Pops had a number of reads he felt confident on, Bit changed his vote and as I already stated, I think scum!RC would be more serious wrt the whole fake rolecop thing.

I will have to reread those posts again to explain it more thoroughly.

[Venus and Mars]

Still on p 23 but liking so far (in no particular order), Gamma, Even, Pops, maybe Bit? I think Severa’s reaction to people falling for his gambit looks townie.

~M

Could you elaborate on these shortreads a bit?

It’s just a brief skim so I’m not yet caught up but Gamma claimed useless role. That usually tends to be town indicative. I have to reread but you looked to be sorting, Pops had a number of reads he felt confident on, Bit changed his vote and as I already stated, I think scum!RC would be more serious wrt the whole fake rolecop thing.

I will have to reread those posts again to explain it more thoroughly.

~Mars

[Venus and Mars]

Btw, long overdue but

Salamance, how u been it has been ages. I was excited to see u in the player list.

~Venus

*tips hat* Shiro.

If you have any questions directed to me ask me and Ill answer if I can

So, from my understanding of your 351 your scumlist is {TL, Alchemist, pops, farkran}? I'm not sure if i'm still in there, perhaps more of a nullscum?

What strikes you as scum from pops?

Can you provide your thoughts about gamma?

Also about Evenstar?

Pops is scum just based on her posts and votes. From what I got, the vote on Bitmap really didnt make sense when I read that she was reading TL as scum more. Then Gamma and Kerset, Im not a fan of their vote but again pops has made it clear TL is scum but hasnt voted him. If TL flips scum I know where Im probably going next and vice versa.

I like Evenstar still as a voice of reason/foil to SEVERA.

I think gamma has been direct and open when rereading which I thought was town, but others have said this is NAI. Idk I think hes sounds towny ngl.

Im still for TL>Pops>Alch>Chem/ShiroDrew

Falkran is less of a problem for now, Im not sure why Kerset is mafia other than RC (aka YOUR GOD) COMMANDS IT

Oh really, I probably shouldn’t have posted until I fully caught up.

We’re not scum here and I will eventually prove that.

I haven’t been feeling well as Shiro said and I still don’t fully understand the mechanics but I felt bad having Shiro do all the work.

[popsofctown]

TL bc he is the most scumreaded.

Seriously?
What if three of the people scumreading him are scum?
You don't want to form your own ideas?
Do you realize this is the opposite of the point of my question?

[Venus and Mars]

Btw, long overdue but

Salamance, how u been it has been ages. I was excited to see u in the player list.

~Venus

*tips hat* Shiro.

If you have any questions directed to me ask me and Ill answer if I can

So, from my understanding of your 351 your scumlist is {TL, Alchemist, pops, farkran}? I'm not sure if i'm still in there, perhaps more of a nullscum?

What strikes you as scum from pops?

Can you provide your thoughts about gamma?

Also about Evenstar?

Pops is scum just based on her posts and votes. From what I got, the vote on Bitmap really didnt make sense when I read that she was reading TL as scum more. Then Gamma and Kerset, Im not a fan of their vote but again pops has made it clear TL is scum but hasnt voted him. If TL flips scum I know where Im probably going next and vice versa.

I like Evenstar still as a voice of reason/foil to SEVERA.

I think gamma has been direct and open when rereading which I thought was town, but others have said this is NAI. Idk I think hes sounds towny ngl.

Im still for TL>Pops>Alch>Chem/ShiroDrew

Falkran is less of a problem for now, Im not sure why Kerset is mafia other than RC (aka YOUR GOD) COMMANDS IT

Oh really, I probably shouldn’t have posted until I fully caught up.

We’re not scum here and I will eventually prove that.

I haven’t been feeling well as Shiro said and I still don’t fully understand the mechanics but I felt bad having Shiro do all the work.

Also, why is Chemist suspicious particularly?

[Venus and Mars]

MOST TOWNY

Pops
Kerset
Alchemist
Sujimichi
TL
Severa

- DEAD NULL -

Gamma
Farkran
Salamence
Chemist
Venus & Mars
Bitmap

MOST SCUMMY

@Chemist1422 post more

I really don’t see why Gamma should be a null?

[Bitmap]

UNVOTE:

I kind of like this catchup.

[Salamence20]

UNVOTE:

I kind of like this catchup.

Really?

@Nancy: I dont understand Chemist’s meta, his lurking around makes him sus, but Im starting to realize this is normal.