Newbie 1965 | River | Over

[Titus]

tbf, i do think pvt is almost certainly scum, but it is always possible

Elaborate here please.

[Titus]

I suppose that, unless we get some activity from Pvt soon, that we move to lynch Titus?

Yuck...unless my lurking partner shows up let's lynch town.

PvT immediately goes on VLA.

[GayBabyJailor]

I suppose that, unless we get some activity from Pvt soon, that we move to lynch Titus?

Yuck...unless my lurking partner shows up let's lynch town.

PvT immediately goes on VLA.

this basically deconfirms map/titus from being considered

[GayBabyJailor]

which means i think pvt is indeed lockscum

[PvtUrist]

VOTE: gbj

I believe #753 clears it up, me and gbj is tvs. Here's my vote, do as you will with it. I apologize, but I have lost confidence in my ability to contribute much more this game.

[GayBabyJailor]

well, guess i'll have to do this now.VOTE: PvT

[Map Wolf]

VOTE: gbj

I believe #753 clears it up, me and gbj is tvs. Here's my vote, do as you will with it. I apologize, but I have lost confidence in my ability to contribute much more this game.

How do you then think is second town, should GBJ be scum?

[Map Wolf]

If this game is still alive by tomorrow, then it'd imply that GBJ-Pvt is TvS. If not, then I'll be here for the postgame.´

Anyone casting a vote (within the next 12 hours) that'd create a L-1 wagon is scum in my book.

[Map Wolf]

VOTE: gbj

I believe #753 clears it up, me and gbj is tvs. Here's my vote, do as you will with it. I apologize, but I have lost confidence in my ability to contribute much more this game.

How do you then think is second town, should GBJ be scum?

Okay I fucked up heavily on the grammer here. Let me rephrase:

If GBJ is scum, who is their scum partner?

[Map Wolf]

Leaning towards Pvt/Titus. Good night.

[PvtUrist]

Heres to contradicting the hell out of myself

gbj's recent posts nearly confirms that his alignment is opposite of mine. who votes where is up to the others.

townreading MW by tonr off of recent posts.

faustiv's ISO pinged both town and scum to the point where I dont know on him.

I dunno about Titus after GL flipped town. Still townread her by vibe.

Guess its between gbj and me today.

pedit faustiv eithout confidence.

[Titus]

If this game is still alive by tomorrow, then it'd imply that GBJ-Pvt is TvS. If not, then I'll be here for the postgame.´

Anyone casting a vote (within the next 12 hours) that'd create a L-1 wagon is scum in my book.

VOTE: PvT

Almost like you gave me incentive.

[Plotinus]

Official Vote Count 3.04

River Danube, Europe

---

Lynching

With 5 votes in play, it takes 3 to lynch.

PvtUrist

(2): GayBabyJailor, Titus

GayBabyJailor

(1): PvtUrist

Not Voting

(2): faüstiv, Map Wolf

Deadline:

(expired on 2019-12-05 20:00:00).

Mod notes:

[/area]

[faüstiv]

VOTE: PvTUrist

[faüstiv]

if this flips scum, may have been wrong on Titus.

If this flips town then sorry dead chat.

anyway I’m more confident on PvT being scum than Titus at this stage.

[faüstiv]

if map is scum with someone that’s not PVT then I have no qualms. He deserves the win after today’s performance.

[Rise]

Aw shit

[faüstiv]

you’re back from the dead 0_0

“Aw shit” doesn’t sound like good news though.

[Plotinus]

Official Vote Count 3.05

River Danube, Europe

---

Lynching

With 5 votes in play, it takes 3 to lynch.

PvtUrist

(3): GayBabyJailor, Titus, faüstiv

<--LYNCH

GayBabyJailor

(1): PvtUrist

Not Voting

(1): Map Wolf

Deadline:

(expired on 2019-12-05 20:00:00).

Mod notes:

A lynch![/area]

[Plotinus]

Day 3 Lynch - PvtUrist

---

PvtUrist

has been lynched day 3. He was a

vanilla townie

This means that the scum team of

faüstiv, mafia roleblocker

and

Titus, mafia goon

have won the game! Congratulations!

Town's roles were

Rise, town cop, Blatant Scum, town doctor

,

vanilla townies: GuiltyLion, GayBabyJailor, Gjt, Map Wolf, TheGildedSun, PvtUrist

.

[/area]

[Plotinus]

Game Events

day 1

• Blatant Scum
  is lynched with 2 scum on his wagon.

night 1

• Rise
  is investigating
  Map Wolf
  (success: Map Wolf is
  town
  ).
  
• faüstiv
  is killing
  Gjt
  . (Success: dies)
  
• faüstiv
  is roleblocking
  TheGildedSun
  . (Success: no effect)

day 2

• GuiltyLion
  is lynched with 1 scum on his wagon.

night 2

• Rise
  is investigating
  PvtUrist
  . (success: PvtUrist is
  town
  )
  
• Titus
  is killing
  Rise
  . (success: dies)
  
• faüstiv
  is roleblocking
  Map Wolf
  . (success: no effect)

day 3

• PvtUrist
  is lynched with 2 scum on his wagon.

Links

Links

• Public thread
  
• Mod PT
  
• Mafia PT (will be released in (expired on 2019-12-02 09:50:00) or sooner, if Titus and faüstiv agree)
  
• Faüstiv
  
• Dead thread

[Plotinus]

Titus and faüstiv played very well. I was surprised that Titus wasn't investigated for that hammer; it's perfectly reasonable to lynch somebody for hammering like that. You won't always hit scum by lynching people who quickhammer -- I did it myself by accident as town tracker in my second game. But it's reasonable to do so. I'm not really sure why GuiltyLion was lynched.

BlatantScum played in a very trolly way, but some people are just like that, regardless of their role. I am not sure whether it is the best policy to just lynch them anyway. With some players you can learn to distinguish their town trolling from their scum trolling, but that takes time and experience and getting to know people.

A site norm that you should know about, that you didn't see in my ruleset and weren't told about when you died, so it's completely reasonable that you didn't know, is that the game isn't over until the mod comes in and makes a post saying that the game is over: sometimes people miscount and someone wasn't actually lynched, or in other queues there can be special roles where it takes more votes than expected to lynch somebody (admittedly these roles are usually disabled in LYLO), or in a closed setup, if there were a vig who could kill mafia tonight you might not know about it. So for all these reasons if you're dead or otherwise not playing, you shouldn't post until the mod has said the game is over.

No harm was done in this case and it's not your fault that nobody told you.

This thread is now open for postgame discussion. You can post here even if you were dead and even if you didn't play.

[faüstiv]

gg all, that was a fun game.

thanks for the modding plotinus

[Plotinus]

Also, lately I've been keeping track of some statistics about who is due for a prod next, when I look at the game. I thought it might be that scum are usually more likely to be the person who hasn't posted in a while, but not necessarily the person who gets prodded the most because you can post once every 35 hours and never get a prod. This is the second or third game I've been keeping track of and so far my hypothesis seems to be wrong:

Day 1: 2/13 scum 11/13 town
Day 2: 3/11 scum 8/11 town
Day 3: 1/2 scum 1/2 town

Even accounting for there being more town alive than scum, in this game, and in the previous ones that i kept track of, scum are not more likely than town to be the lurker who might get prodded soon.

[Plotinus]

A two-or-three game sample size isn't that great but the previous games I kept track of had similar results.

Before I started keeping track, it seemed like my hypothesis was true, probably due to noticing bias, where I paid more attention when it was scum player who was due a prod next and less attention when a town player was due a prod next.