Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[Firebringer]

What other faction do you think he belongs to?

[Untrod Tripod]

Does that exclude him from being another antitown faction or

from what, the other mafia faction we haven't seen that hasn't killed yet?

[Wooper]

Aren't there non cobble alignments? I swear I've seen people talking about them

Do we have a cult that has NKs?

[Firebringer]

There’s third parties but it really looks like your just trying to find an excuse to be pushing Zor now

If you want to hunt cult that’s fine but Zor isn’t one and he isn’t mafia
Any other hunting is kind of waste of time and effort

[Miss Lane]

Why can't Zor be scum?

[Miss Lane]

I probably missed it, sorry

[Amrun]

Why the fuck would this tell you anything about my slignment? It's more likely to soft at my role lmao

You would know why if you read the fucking game, Wooper.

no, he's right

tse was a spider

We are trying to see if he was the particular flavor that killed Formerfish, so, yes, it was relevant, but won’t be now that I’ve said it.

[Wooper]

Missed that post: probably yes but I have nearly no motivation to backread this

Amrun do you agree with the town!Zor stuff UT/fireb are saying?

[Wooper]

Wait what's this Runelord shit? They look exactly like scumflips

[Wooper]

Couldn't murder be the cult kill flavour and Orcus be cult? I don't see how there's a lack of a factional kill

[Amrun]

Missed that post: probably yes but I have nearly no motivation to backread this

Amrun do you agree with the town!Zor stuff UT/fireb are saying?

Yes. InsideJob cleared zoraster. They were town turned cult. We also have other info on cult recruit numbers. It’s reasonably certain no cult recruits are left alive, and fairly certain Zoraster is not groupscum. He could theoretically be cult leader. These things may need to be revisited in the future but he is mechanically poor lynch for the day.

[Wooper]

........
You're taking cult!InsideJob's word that Zor... isn't cult...?

What universe did I wake up in

[Wooper]

ok let's assume that's not completely stupid for a moment. why the {wooper, zor} dichotomy in the first place?

[Amrun]

........
You're taking cult!InsideJob's word that Zor... isn't cult...?

What universe did I wake up in

No. We are taking their word he isn’t groupscum, for now.

We know for other reasons he’s not a cult recruit.

[Amrun]

ok let's assume that's not completely stupid for a moment. why the {wooper, zor} dichotomy in the first place?

Because I dug up Formerfish’s body and you two are the only ones on a list of five we feel could be the killer. The killer is definitely on the list.

[Wooper]

What's the list and why does it definitely contain the killer?

[Untrod Tripod]

What's the list and why does it definitely contain the killer?

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go

[Wooper]

not happening chicken

[Miss Lane]

Night 2 : Korina, EspressoPatronum, zoraster, TrueSoulEnergy, Wooper, Untrod Tripod

i see that this is the list people are talking about

i'm quoting it here so i don't have to do the work to find it again

VOTE: zor

This is the post.

I thought InsideJob was lying?

Just because InsideJob became cultist doesn't make what was a truth into a lie, right? A lie has to be something someone says, knowing what they say is false.

[Miss Lane]

Or is that not how the lie detector works?

[Pink Ball]

You guys, you don't get it. Read Ali's post from last day. E was angry. E probably didn't want to be culted. Er claim about FL is relevant. And er claim about Zor is relevant too. Zor is NEVER an option, and FL is the best alternative. You are discussing lynching between a player who's being replaced, a player who may be conf!not scum and wooper which is a meh read. Wooper is null until he's not. He's null now.

Don't understimate FL. You won't be able to lynch him later.

[Amrun]

Night 2 : Korina, EspressoPatronum, zoraster, TrueSoulEnergy, Wooper, Untrod Tripod

i see that this is the list people are talking about

i'm quoting it here so i don't have to do the work to find it again

VOTE: zor

This is the post.

I thought InsideJob was lying?

Just because InsideJob became cultist doesn't make what was a truth into a lie, right? A lie has to be something someone says, knowing what they say is false.

Or is that not how the lie detector works?

They were almost definitely town when they said it, so they probably were telling the truth, ostensibly. The theory is they may have lied about what JOAT power was used, or that they couldn’t know zoraster was TOWN at that juncture, just not groupscum.

It is possible zoraster is the cult recruiter. Either way the chances he killed Formerfish are much lower than Wooper.

It’s worth revisiting at a later date but it is the wrong play to lynch him first.

P-edit: I agree, in a way, Pink Ball. But town drunk also doesn’t seem like a very scummy flavor. Idk. An FL lynch isn’t awful but I disagree that we can’t lynch him later in a game of this size, with vig too.

[Firebringer]

I’ll just personally kill Flavor leaf later if he becomes a bigger pain.
He is mildly annoying rn and I still think town

[Amrun]

Also FWIW EP has said he is confirmable, and UT has claimed cult cop. They are theoretically possible, but have been excluded for today for good reason IMO.

[Miss Lane]

I really don't like the whole zoraster situation.
the player reads as individually scummy, and the "confirmation" for him is about as solid as rice pudding.