Newbie 1967 | GAME OVER

[Karnage]

"outing" your scum partner would be saying "hey everybody, player B and I are the scum team". that would be against the rules

potentially exposing your partner through poor play, which would be the case here, is not the same thing

[Non lmh]

Newbie 1967

---

Player list

:

1. Naerys
   
2. GeorgeBailey
   
3. gobbledygook (SE)
   Arkias
   
   
4. Fdse
   bugspray
   
   
5. Non lmh
   BigFatDonald
   
   
6. Karnage (SE)
   Sera Masumi
   
   
7. Lovebird (SE)
   PvtUrist (SE)
   
   
8. skitter30 (SE)
   
9. Flavor Leaf (SE)
   RadiantCowbells (SE)

Spoiler: Game Reveals (2)

1. Gobbledygook
   was lynched on Day One. He was a
   Vanilla Townie

   .
   
   
2. No one died Night One.

Events

• 6 Day One Begins
  
• 334 Karnage replaces Sera Masumi
  
• 348 Lovebird replaces PvtUrist
  
• 368 gobbledygook replaces Arkias
  
• 434 Non lmh replaces BigFatDonald
  
• 785 Day One EoD VC
  
• 787 Fdse replaces bugspray
  
• 788 Flavor Leaf replaces RadiantCowbells
  
  

  ---

  
  
• 791 Day Two Begins

if A says a, and B flips green, Non/A are red
if A says b, and B flips green, Non/C are red
isn't my saying I'm red with someone if you flip green the same thing?

[Non lmh]

ignore the quote, didn't realize that was there

[Non lmh]

Karnage is CCing you my friend. Both of your claims cannot exist together.

point was I can't be karnage's partner unless someone else claims jk/doc

[Flavor Leaf]

It’s better to lynch the jk for the chance of doctoring the tracker

[Flavor Leaf]

Karnage is CCing you my friend. Both of your claims cannot exist together.

He is saying Karnage is conf scum in his post prior, this is an irrelevant post.

Noted

[Flavor Leaf]

Ooooo....fdse be hatcheting Nom for Karnage possibly there.

[eth0s]

Official Vote Count 2.04

Lynching

With 8 living players it takes 5 votes to lynch.

Karnage (2):

Non lmh, Flavor Leaf

Non lmh (1):

Karnage

Not Voting (5):

Naerys, GeorgeBailey, skitter30, Lovebird, Fdse

Deadline:

(expired on 2019-12-12 15:30:00)

Mod notes:

n/a.[/area]

[skitter30]

So if karnage is town then scum is exactly nom / fl, right?

Whereas if non is town, fl is town too?

[eth0s]

Prodding GeorgeBailey.

[Flavor Leaf]

So if karnage is town then scum is exactly nom / fl, right?

Whereas if non is town, fl is town too?

No, because I’m town, so if Karnage is town, that doesn’t change anything.

If Nom is scum, they knew who they killed, so it was safe to say they protected me.
But I could see the ulterior reasons for you bring it up so I’ll shut up

[Flavor Leaf]

So if karnage is town then scum is exactly nom / fl, right?

Whereas if non is town, fl is town too?

Also, skitter, this is a hard deep wolf comment with setup play to end game if you are scum here

[Flavor Leaf]

Fuck, it’s Nom and Skitter, and I get mislynched if that’s the team

Karnage flips town, Nom lynch flips scum, flavor lynch flips town, lylo lynch Skitter 100% of the time. She will persuade you hard not to, but if this scenario happens, which is large tinfoil theory, but if this happens, this is the path.

You’ll have my flip in this scenario, so yeah. Use this late in game.

I’m still gonna go Karnage is scum here, however, I am starting to believe that he isn’t, which makes Fdse scummier again because of political positioning, maybe Naerys. I don’t think it’s ever both.

I also can potentially see Nom lying about being doctor as town, which is what I’m covering the bases for now.

If the off chance of Nom vs Karnage is TvT.

[Non lmh]

you won't find my partner that way. either I never interact or bus them till the end if I'm in the mood. I get that the current trend is to play along and call each other out when one inevitably slips but I'm not that clever or kind enough to keep track of it all.
*puts on tinfoil hat*
easiest is to pair me with the passive players, but there's not enough to go on and too many options, so move on,,
most interesting is skitter, wait, it could totally be skitter, yeah, these insignificant details could totally be from scum faking, and look, she's totally defending him here, omg, it all makes sense now
rc,, hmm,, wait,, non was totally sheeping him there, and rc totally scumread the widely townread karnage slot after he legit scumread the non slot day one, oh, that's an odd interaction, and an even odder one with the replacement!?shenanigans, this almost feels manufactured, ugh, if only rc's slot weren't here

guys, I totally figured it out, the scum team is non/fl, no wait, non/skit, no wait wait, I got it) it's fl/skit))
huh, I guess Bugspray got it right after all, what a champ, truly
,,
if you had fun speculating, good on you, now let it go and bring it back after karnage flips green

p-edit
no wait red, totally meant to say red

[GeorgeBailey]

Yikes, again sorry for the prod. Should have called a V/LA cause projects are a bit crazy right now.
I guess there's 4 PR claims right now, and some counter the claims of others.

As non said, if Karnage flips green, then we can just vote him out tomorrow.

VOTE: Karnage

L-2 right now.

@FL is there a reason for someone to lie and claim a PR as town?

[eth0s]

Official Vote Count 2.05

Lynching

With 8 living players it takes 5 votes to lynch.

Karnage (3):

Non lmh, Flavor Leaf, GeorgeBailey

Non lmh (1):

Karnage

Not Voting (4):

Naerys, skitter30, Lovebird, Fdse

Deadline:

(expired on 2019-12-12 15:30:00)

Mod notes:

n/a.[/area]

[Flavor Leaf]

Yikes, again sorry for the prod. Should have called a V/LA cause projects are a bit crazy right now.
I guess there's 4 PR claims right now, and some counter the claims of others.

As non said, if Karnage flips green, then we can just vote him out tomorrow.

VOTE: Karnage

L-2 right now.

@FL is there a reason for someone to lie and claim a PR as town?

Not in this situation, and generally there really isn’t.

It can save actual PR’s, but the requires people to be able to know what you’re doing too.

@Nom - I can read past that surface level way of interactions with people if you’re scum, don’t worry.

[Non lmh]

well then it's a good thing I ain't scum this time around
gn everyone

[Fdse]

VOTE: Karnage

I will reply after exams tomorrow.

[skitter30]

So if karnage is town then scum is exactly nom / fl, right?

Whereas if non is town, fl is town too?

No, because I’m town, so if Karnage is town, that doesn’t change anything.

If Nom is scum, they knew who they killed, so it was safe to say they protected me.
But I could see the ulterior reasons for you bring it up so I’ll shut up

ok but let's assume i'm not playing from your pov

from *my* pov i think you and non are of the same alignment, unless i'm missing something.

going thru this more carefully:

-> karnage and non cannot both be town (and presumably are not both scum either)

-> so one is telling the truth and one is lying

-> if karnage is town he either prevented the nk on fl or prevented him from making the nk. yeah actually this says nothing about your alignment, but non imh is scum (and presumably either knows his partner got blocked, or that you were the nk). p ballsy move tho to cc the true protective like that, tho

-> if karnage is scum then the nk got docced and both fl and non are town

-> if non imh is town than fl is town and karnage is scum

-> if non imh is scum than karnage is town and he either knew fl made the nk and was roleblocked adn was p gutsy in tying himself to his partner by claiming to have docced, or he knew that the nk on fl failed

i kinda don't think that non imh as scum makes that play there, but i can be wrong

it's probably safer to lynch karnage, i think, because non imh can doc lovebird without affecting her check, and it would conftown two people if karnage's scum

i guess that's where i'm at

of course if non imh is scum then we just lose both prs today/tonight

[skitter30]

So if karnage is town then scum is exactly nom / fl, right?

Whereas if non is town, fl is town too?

Also, skitter, this is a hard deep wolf comment with setup play to end game if you are scum here

no i just didn't think it thru

[skitter30]

fl i never try to lynch you here, i nk you and/or pocket you

[skitter30]

i'm actually not sure i sr karange independantly

[skitter30]

karnage anything else you'd like to say?

stricly setup speaking, i think it's better to be wrong on non imh than to be wrong on karnage

non imh plz just don't be town and lying about being a doctor

[Karnage]

karnage anything else you'd like to say

Spoiler: