This "not sure if [x] or [y]" business needs to stop - not just you in particular but in Mafia games across this site in general. It's one or the other and you should be giving an opinion on which you think it is, not just summarizing some possibilities.In post 298, Uncrowned wrote:Not sure if that's something she does as town or if it's a potential scum trying to get towncred from the people she's defending.
I see town motive in her pressuring me to see if my intentions were genuine, even if I didn't like the way she did it, and I see town motive in defending Kanna from being voted or pushed for bad reasons. I think on the whole it's town indicative mindset and skitter didn't particularly need any towncred from Kanna at the time she went to bat for her like that, so I disagree with your possible scum!motive.
Not really. There's all sorts of possibilities here and this single fact doesn't really push me in any direction:In post 298, Uncrowned wrote:Pretty sure the fact that I'm voting Skitter when I could've put the counter-wagon to my wagon (Billy) on L-1 at one stage in the game tells you all you need to know about my alignment.
1) Town you might have a stronger read on Skitter than Billy
2) You might be afraid of being perceived as desperate to survive voting your counter-wagon, as either alignment
3) Scum you might be afraid of fighting with Billy because you think that will spew him town when he is the main counter to you
I'm most interested in times when I disagree with scumreads and why, cause I think generally townies should be as honest as possible about who they suspect and scumreads are the hardest thing for scum to convincingly fake. I will grant you that it's possible that town!you was going in on Kanna extra hard to push her and I'm glad we both agree that she's town. So are you saying that you didn't actually think she felt threatened and you were just embellishing that solely to push her?